High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1584/2012disposed of

Sumit v. Neelam

2015-01-16Mr. Justice A.K. Sikri,Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta6 pages

# $ %& !'( () +, -./ 00(11!' 2(3*.* ((1!/ (*0"('

!" #$%& "#'($ &&!

!" %#$%& "%"

) %

-+ 3--/ 4"5)!'( 3'6(!00(11!' 3!13!7.77!34"5)!'( 3'6(3(*0"(' #'($ &&!*# 8 9!8 *'!' !00(!14 '6( !00(11!'6.*:!" 6!* )6!11(;("'6(7.";/('!""()3(("!'("# 0!**(":8'6( *'3 )'.";($ !/ 18.3'&46 9!

496(3(:8'6(0('

1(":86 / ."(3-()'

<$&$ !&!"$ :& '6( ".!33 !;()'4=$ *63'4>'6()'?& **1.'

/!33 !;(:8!"()3(( 53)(49!* */ **(" 6( /!33 !;( :('9(( '6( 0!3'

(* 9!* *1(/ @(" <==#!'5 11!;(!**4(6* 1!* 4 *'3 )' *!3!))3"

;' ".3 '(*!")(3(/ (* '(3/!33 !;(4'6(0!3'

(*1 5("';('6(3!* 6.*:!"!"9

(!'5 11!;(A.;!36!

!;3!!")6!:

'("!* *.)64:.')6 1"9!*:3.' '6(*!

"9("1)B 9(5(34'6( 0!3'

(*''6(/!33 !;().1"'0.11';('6(3 3/'6(5(38:(;

;

!" 6!5( :(( 1 ; *(0!3!'(18 ))3"

;184 '6( !00(11!'

1(" !

<$&$ !&!"$ :& '6()' **1.'

/!33 !;(:('9(('6(0!3'

(*:8!"()3(( 53)(6(*!

"0('

9!*)'(*'(":8'6(3(*0"(':8

;!93 ''(*'!'(/('(* "(* 3!

; 5!3 .* 03(1 / !38 :7()'

*4 '6( !5(3/('* /!"( '6( 9(3()'35(3'("!"!03!8(3 */ **!1 '6(*!/(9!* /!"( 6('3 !1).3'!003() !'

3!1!*9(11!*")./('!38 (5 "()(1(":8'6(0!3'

(*"

*/ **("'6(0('

< $&$ !&!"$ :& '6()' **1.'

/!33 !;(:('9(('6(0!3'

(* :8!"()3(( 53)(5 "(7.";/('!""()3(("!'("# ()(4'6(03(*('!00(!1:8'6(6.*:!" < .3 ; '6( 0("()8 '6( !00(!14 '6( 0!3'

(* 6!5( !/ )!:183(*15("'6( 3"

(3()(* *0(3'6('(3/*!")"

* ('(3(":('9(('6(0!3'

(*47 :(!3 ;

9!*

'6()' 3;3!' !"()3((

53)(:8/.'.!1)*(' '6 '6( 0!3'

(* /!"( '6( 3 3(*0()'

5( *'!'(/('* !*

3*' /'

3 "

**1.'

'6( /!33 !;( :8 /.'.!1 )*('."(3-()'

'6()'6()!*(9!*!"7.3("'6( *!

""!'( 3'"!84 (4, 33()3"

;*'!'(/('* *()"

'6(0!3'

(*!*3(C.

3("."(3-()'

'6()' 00(11!'-./ ' !" 3(*0"('((1!/ !3( 03(*('

.3''"!86(86!5(:(( "('

(":8'6( 33(*0()'

5().*(16( *()" /'

*'!'(/('* '6( 0!3'

(* ( !00(11!'6.*:!" !"

3(*0"('9

(6!5(:((3()3"("*1(/!

3/!'

*0(3'6( *(''1(/('4'6(!00(11!'6.*:!"6!"0!

"!''!1*./ 1!)*'

'6(3(*0"('9

(6(3(*0"('9

(6!"!))(0'("'6(*!

"!/.'

1!)*'6'6(0!3'

(*6!5(!;3((" 53)(:89!8 /.'.!1 )*('."(3-()'

'6()'6(86!5()

3/("'6!'!7 '6()'6!*:((03(*('(":8'6(/ 3 ;3!' "()3(( 53)(:8/.'.!1)*('6(0!3'

(*6!5(*'!'("

'6!''6(8!3(!;3(("';(''6(/!33 !;("

**15(":8/.'.!1)*('

'(3/* 7

'6()' , -()'

'6()'3(!"*'6.*+

"#$ $% "#$

& ' (

)

* + *

&, 01!

3(!"

; *.:*()'

$&*69*'6!''6(0!3'

(*' '6( /!33 !;( 96(3(5(3 !;3(( :8 /.'.!1 )*(' '6!' '6( /!33 !;( *6.1":("

**15(":8!"()3(( 53)('6(;3."'6!''6(86!5( :((1 ;*(0!3!'(18 3!0(3 " (8(!33/3(4:'6'6(0!3'

(* /!803(*('!0('

53)(''6( *'3 )'.3' 03(*('!'

*.)60('

4*'!'(/(':89!8

3*'/'

9.1":(3()3"("

"(3*.:*()'

$&4*()"/'

9.1":(3(C.

3("':(/!"( )6*6.1":(!

'(3* D/'6* 3/'6("!'( 03(*('!'

'6( 3( (33(" *.:*()'

$&!"'1!'(3'6!( ;6'((/'6*

3/'6("!'(

3*'/'

96(3('6(0('

6!*':((9 '6"3!9 6(.3'4:( ;*!'

("!

'(36(!3 ;'6(0!3'

(*0!**!"()3((

53)(':((

()'

5( 3/'6("!'( '6("()3(( # 6( 0(D .3' ,-./ /,01 2. 3--4 /,01*

%5+ 4(D01!

("'6(*)0( -()'

'6()'!*."(3+ -./

01'

&/ 2

% 4

* + *

5 6

% 2

& /

& (

) 7

&, = 5 (9 !:5(!"!

'(30(3.* ;'6(*'!'(/('*/!"(:8 '6(0!3'

(* .3' $

3*'/'

&!"'"!8 (, $*()"/'

&49(!3(*!'

("'6!''6(!5(3/('*/!"( '6(0('

!3('3.(!"3(C.

3(/('* -()'

'6()'!3( .1

11("!"'6(

0!3'

(*:(;3!'(""

53)(:89!8 /.'.!1)*('))3"

;1847 $ &96 )6 **.003'(":8!

"!5 '*

'6(!00(11!'!*9(11!*'6(3(*0"('4 *!119("*(C.('184!

"()3(( 53)(."(3-()'

'6()' *0!**("(

()'

5( 3/ '"!8:8/"

;'6(7.";/('!""()3(("!'("# 0!**(":8 '6('3 !1.3' ' * .3'6(3:*(35("'6!''6(0!3'

(**6!113(/!

:.":8 '6(*'!'(/('*!"'(3/* '6(7

'6()'9(5(34 )!*(!8 '6(0!3'

(*3(* 1(* 3/'6(*'!'(/('* 3'(3/* '6(7 '6()'4 '*6!11:( 0(''6('6(30!3'8'!5!

1!83(/("8 !))3"!)(9 '61!9 5 (9 !:5(4'6(03(*('!00(!1*'!"*"

*0*(" #'($ &&! #$36" #7185* %" ) % ;:* #$36"