← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21673/2018allowed

Richmond Park Owners & Residents Association v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2023-08-16Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Ms. Justice Harpreet Kaur Jeewan7 pages



      

  



  

!

 ""

  # 

     

""""""  $%"

    

"""""""""   !

&'

"

   " "

'

 &'

"

    #    

   

   

 





!"  

 # $

%%%%% " " '

( "

'

&  "  

() *) (*&+ .&/0 1  # & ,  ! 

 2 '

   "

2    

  " 

 

22





 ! &3

2

"

41   &3)5 ,  6 60

 

 , 0 2 "

"



 

   "



( 7  "

 2 (3 *+ (*&+

.      1  2



"

  (3 *5 (*&+ .+0 

 '   82

" 2    

    (+ *9 (*&+ .$0

 ! &* ,(0 

""

 87!:! ;

1  2

"

22    ;  2-    "

1 1;

87!

1;    87!

1;

 22 



"

! 2 2  ; "

 < "  ;.&

=>.?@

"  ! /. 

 1  

 

2  1 



 ! &* ,(0  '



   



A :   2



  

 

/ ?       ;  1;   

1  1 87!

;

< 





"

!    < -   1;

 2   "2 ?

      " 



  "   1   2

 87!



 1;



 " "

  "

2   1 

  1;   2  ; "  ;.

& " 

87!

< ! 4

 

@ (3 *5 (*&+ .+0 

 '   82

" 2  

   "  62 6

"  1

 



    87!

;

   2



 87!

1;

?    :

"  2  2   

2 87!

2     " "



 



 1 2  !

2

' <    "

 2  () *) (*&+ .&/0 "



   "

 ! &5

&3 

.

B  



 

  

     





  

  

---- ---- ---- ---- B       

 

          ! "

  #   

  $       $   

    

       

    

    %       &   '$    ( 

  ) 

     

 * )   

 

 #     

   

 $

         

)

 + $ ? 

1 

  

 "       "

"

  2 1      ;"

  



   1        

   

  "

 "

        E    

  

   "

   

   2





 ! &3 



""

 





2  

 ) ?   2  

 

 2 2 ;





"2

61 !

2  

* #+,-./ %%01/,.2 3."

'.4"

-+ 3%

,%004 5624 #5,-

+% 2010 (4) RCR (Civil) 600 would come into play, that a quasi judicial order should contain reason. The relevant part of the judgment reads as under:- ,  %  "            (

 * --  

 $ 

          

          

 



     .   

     



 



7

-    

  $



         

 $

 /      



  



#    .   

  $  / 

    #   0         #

     /     

      

  0

   



   

      .

   

     /      

     

 $ 

 (

 ' 



 

 

 

 $

     

      '

  

  0 





  

  1    .         

 $    

 

 $ 

                     '    

  

   2        -         

  0-1   . 

   

3 0

   

 0$$    

 

    

   

    



     

  /    

          

  4

.

 2   $    0

 -  



            

    

      $  '

 0  0   0  

 



0 

 

 

5%  %    ( 567899& $ :$/ $7;.7;78   %               



  0     $ 

          $    

   %





%5<8=&//;  >? ?  @   !#  ?99=A(( <9 $ 

(



 

 >=

(   &   /   $     B     



     B -

 $

  

  

 

   

 '        $      

   



B

) B 8.

Resultantly, the writ petition is allowed and the appellate order dated () *) (*&+ .&/0 

  2   

 2  

 



  "

 



  

 

"

2 

 ,0 



 

" "

'



 898%.

 ( 

 #  

 7 ! ;"

F 7  1 #