High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3124/2015dismissed

Executive Engineer Fatehabad Water Services Division Fatehabad v. Suresh Kumar And ANR

2015-02-23Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan7 pages

!"##$%&%'(

)#$*"%+#',%'##-. !"#/!0!1!"#- 2#-+%$#&%+%&%'

#"%"%'#- 4#-&*& 2*-#&/5*6!-"/#-& #&7'1#'"&

-#&#'"(3 - -%"!62!%'%.118.!-9!'! :::

2"!"#!-9!'!/!&7-##--#1"/#%'&"!'"7#"%"%'-!%&%',! $/!88#',#""/#!;!-11!"#1< ''#)*-# 3 .7!&&#109"/# '1*&"-%!8 -%0*'!83$*63=!0*- *-". %&!- %' "#-6& ;/%$/ "/# ;->6!'?-#&7'1#'"'/!&0##'/#81#'"%"8#1"-#%'&"!"#6#'"%'&#-+%$# ;%"/!88$'&#@*#'"%!80#'#%"&0*";%"/*"0!$>;!,#& =#!-'#12"!"#$*'&#8/!&-!%&#1!";81&*06%&&%''"/# %-&"%'&"!'$#.%"%&!-,*#1"/!""/#%67*,'#1!;!-1$!''"&*&"!%'!&"/# '*&;!&$8#!-89*7'"/#;->6!'"7-+#"/!"/#/!1;->#1-

1!9&%'"/#7-#$#1%',6'"/&"!>#'-6"/#1!"#!88#,#1"#-6%'!"%' !'1&*$/'*&/!+%','"0##'1%&$/!-,#1"/#%'1%',!&-#,!-1&''3 $678%!'$#2#$"%' "/#'1*&"-%!8%&7*"#&$".;!&7#-+#-&# 2#$'1&*06%&&%'-!%&#1%&"/!""/#;->6!'/!1;->#1'89'1!%89 ;!,#0!&%&%'"#-6%""#'"89!'1"/#1#"!%8&"/#-#/!10##'*-'%&/#10#-# "/#=!0*-*-"!'1*'1#-&*$/$%-$*6&"!'$#&#+#'%"/#-#/!10##' +%8!"%'2#$"%' "/#$"'89!1#@*!"#$67#'&!"%'$*81/!+# 0##',-!'"#1'&*77-"&*$/$'"#'"%'%"/!&!8&0##'&*06%""#1"/!" "/##',!,#6#'""/#;->6!';!&'"%'7*-&*!'$#"!'9-#,*8!-

33 &#8#$"%'7-$#&&!'1;!& "/#-#$-*%"6#'"-*8#&!'1!&&*$/."/# =!0*-*-"/!&#--#1%'1%-#$"%',-#%'&"!"#6#'" !+%', /#!-1 8#!-'#1 2"!"# $*'&#8 !" 8#',"/ !'1 /!+%', 7#-*&#1"/#78#!1%',&'-#$-1."/%&*-"%&"/#$'&%1#-#1+%#;"/!"' 0!&%&-%'"#-#-#'$#%&6!1#*"

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

"%88<

1!9& -6

"%88

. B 1!9& %' 0#";##' AB

"%88 CB

.A1!9&0#";##'<C

" C

.B1!9&0#";##' <

"%88CB

.C<1!9&0#";##'

"%88

. 1!9&%'0#";##'

C"%88AC

C!'1%'!889-1!9&%'0#";##'

<"%88 BA

< =#!-'#12"!"#$*'&#8./;#+#-.1#&'"$'"-+#-""/!""/# ;->6!' /!1 6+#1 !' !778%$!"%' - %&&*!'$# 1%-#$"%'& - 7-1*$"%'6*&"#--88&!'16*&"#-%&&*!'$#-#,%&"#-"7-+#"/!"/#/!1 ;->#1- 1!9&%'"/#7-#$#1%',6'"/&-6"/#1!"#

33 "#-6%'!"%'0*"!-#789/!10##'&*06%""#109"/##6789#-&"!"%',"/!" -#$-1-&*$/7#-%1$*81'"0#7-1*$#1!&%";!&'""-!$#!08#0#%', 81-#$-1 /#7&%"%'8!;-#8!"%',"'*&$!6#"0##)!6%'#109 "/#'D08#2*7-#6#*-"%'

!"# $

% &'())*+,-'./)!'1%";!&0&#-+#1!&88;&(3

! "#

$ #

% #

# #%&'

! (

# )!(

# #

!(#

( #%

! #

# !, '"/#7-#&#'"$!&#"/#;->6!'?-#&7'1#'"';!&!1!%89 ;!,#-.;//!1'#%"/#-0##'%&&*#1!'!77%'"6#'"8#""#-'-!"#-6%'!"%' 8#""#- !'!,#6#'";!&"/#$*&"1%!'"/#-#$-1& '1*0"#189."/# %'%"%!8'*&"7-+#"/#!$"/!+%',$678#"#16-#"/!' 1!9&%'

&#-+%$#%'"/#7-#$#1%',6'"/&-6"/#1!"#"#-6%'!"%';!&'"/# ;->6!';!-1&1%&$/!-,%',&*$/'*&"/#;->6!'/!1&*66'#1"/#

33 $'$#-'#1-#$-1& /#6!'!,#6#'"%8#1!-#&7'&#""/#!778%$!"%' "!>%',!&"!'1"/!""/#-#$-1;!&'""-!$#!08#0#%',81 /#;->6!' /!1 "!>#' !78#!"/!" /%&&#-+%$#& /!1 0##' 1%&7#'%"/;# A "%&1%%$*8""!"/6"/!"'"/#'# /!'1%'"/#-#789""/#$8!%6&"!"#6#'"1#"!%8&"/#;->%',1!9&7*"%'09 "/#;->6!'-"/#7#-%1AAB"

<;#-#*-'%&/#10*"'"/#"/#- /!'1%'-#&7'&#"!'!778%$!"%'%8#109"/#;->6!'&##>%',7-1*$"%' -#$-1%'"/#'#9#!-7-#$#1%',"/#1!"#"#-6%'!"%'%# A "/# &!6#;!&1#$8%'#1'"/#78#!"/!""/#-#$-1%&81!'1'""-!$#!08#/%& *-"%&"/#$'&%1#-#1+%#;"/!""/#0#&"-#8#+!'"#+%1#'$#/!&0##' ;%"//#8109"/#6!'!,#6#'"!'1"/#=!0*-*-"/!&-%,/"*8891-!;'!' %'#-#'$#!,!%'&""/#6!'!,#6#'" %'1%',-#$-1#109"/#=!0*-*-"

!&-#,!-1&"/#;->6!'?-#&7'1#'"'/!+%',$678#"#1 1!9&%'"/# 7-#$#1%',6'"/&!'12#$"%' "/#'1*&"-%!8%&7*"#&$"/!+%', '"0##'$678%#1;%"/.1#&'"$!88-!'9%'"#-#-#'$# /# $'"#'"%' -!%&#1 09 8#!-'#1 2"!"# $*'&#8 "/!" #+#' ";!-1&''3$678%!'$#2#$"%' "/#$"."/#;->6!'%'&"#!1 -#%'&"!"#6#'"&/*81/!+#0##'!;!-1#1$67#'&!"%';*81';-#@*%-# #)!6%'!"%' 'D08#7#)*-"%'$!&# 001&2

!"# $

% &3#4 " $

0 05'3 1'()5)+.-/,6;/%8# #)!6%'%',"/#%&&*#''3$678%!'$#2#$"%' "/#$"/#81!& *'1#-(3 -!

# #%

./0!- &'&

1*234+

* +

*+ &15 6 !

* + 7 #%

# !

) ) ! (

&156* +

: ;< <

* ;<'+< :&&

* ;=<+ >&& !

" * ;> + - -'

# $ % & #!* ;> +- &&1 # ' () &*

& $

'+ * ;>&+ <'1

, -

* ;> +' ''-! # / (* ;>'+ 1 ;!

$ "

/* ;;

+ >;

-+' < ;!( ) 7

8 ? ? #

&156 !

#7 8

&156* +

3C3

'1*0"#189. %' &*0&#@*#'" F*1,#6#'"& -#'1#-#1 09 "/# 'D08# 2*7-#6# *-" %' $!&#&

% &' 7 $012 0&10& 0 8 0&

2 %'()5.+(- .)!'1

#&#2'()5/+.-/,!&/%"%&'"%$#!08#. ;/#-#%'%"/!&0##'/#81"/!";/%8##)#-$%&%',1%&$-#"%'"/#=!0*-*-" %'"/#$!&#!1!%89;!,#-;->6!'.;/&#"#-6%'!"%'/!&0##'*'1" 0#0!1%'8!;'!$$*'"''3$678%!'$#2#$"%' "/#$".

-#8%#-#%'&"!"#6#'"%&'""0#,-!'"#1!&!"/*60-*8# ;#+#-. %' ! -#$#'" *88 #'$/ 1#$%&%' "/%& *-"

-#'1#-#1%' 3 06*/09()5)"%"8#1!&# "

10# "

' %&

%99 "&' 40#&0#&'#&: 1#&1#$%1#1' .

!88"/#F*1%$%!87-#$#1#'"&/!+#0##'$'&%1#-#1%'$8*1%',"/#F*1,#6#'"& "/#'D08#7#)*-"%'$!&#& 001&2' 2 % :

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

3<3 '"/#!$"&"/#7-#&#'"$!&#"/#;->6!'/!1-#'1#-#1 &#-+%$#-6"/#9#!-AAB" A 0#%"'1!%89;!,#0!&%&/#-# ;!&'1#8!9'/%&7!-"%'/!+%',-!%&#1"/#%'1*&"-%!81%&7*"#/#=!0*- *-"/!&#)#-$%&#1%"&1%&$-#"%'%',-!'"%',-#8%#-#%'&"!"#6#'"0*"/!& 1#'%#1"/#0!$>;!,#&/#-#%&'1%-#$"%'!&-#,!-1&-#,*8!-%G!"%'%' &#-+%$#&&*$/.09!7789%',"/#1%$"*68!%11;'09"/# *88#'$/%'

# "

10# "

' %&

$!&# &*7-! !'1>##7%',%'+%#;"/# 8#',"/&#-+%$#-#'1#-#109"/#;->6!'0#%"'!'%'"#-6%""#'"0!&%&."/# -#8%#-#%'&"!"#6#'"1%-#$"#109"/#=!0*-*-"0*";%"/*"0!$>;!,#& 1#&'"$!88-!'9%'"#-#-#'$# -%"7#"%"%'%&.!$$-1%',89.1%&6%&&#1 + - ;4&#&<(.'()5* 8*$>9 /#"/#-"0#-##--#1" #7-"#-H#&