Khushpal Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS
!
"#$#$ KHUSHPAL SINGH
% &'%$(
)
($* +++++
!"
#"$% &' "(" ) * +"
'"
-"'"
.")/0 %"(.
11111 )
($*,$-./0 ' "
'"( , $ 0
+$2234225
0
,7
",
' 0"
+ ,"# "0 ,6
& " , '
" 8929: ;
<0 = #' (> ' "0+
,$"
,"*
'"
( +"
+$$ ", "
$>3>"
2 ?"
6 $"
&
('"$,
'"'
@ ' ,6.
"
6 +$) .
"
'"
0 0($ +
+ ' $"
& # ,
* & (
,
' <+ $"
# ' ' 7
&"
'
+"#$$" ' .A+
,'$"
# 0$>.
'"0+
+'"0+
#" ('$
2893"
"
-2- ' "
+) $"
."0
& 92 "+ " * $$"& /"&&"
('"
") ' $ "(""-"$") +.
"
#""$ 00 ,
"0+
'
+ " ' ",
"
"0+
+
& '$
2893 "
#" ' ' &' (
,
' "( * +$ , $"
" "
+ , 283)9994 "+ .A+
,"0+
)9B ,'( ".
#" C0 (
"'
#' $' ."
&".
+ 0$ (
(
(>'"0+
(
, "$$. ' ">. .
0$ ,'( ".
#""0
@ +
'" "
,'",
"
.
0$)'
'".
"0
2:95 8B ,'"0+
".
# '
9 8B# ' #
22932999 ".""( * :95299 ".""( * : 7 0(. '" ' $" "$$. #"
(> '
"$( ", . $">7 "*
'"'
'"
'0
".
,2)53):24 #' +'0+',"+"
* , (>'
' #
"$ + +"
" #$$ 7 "*
'" '
'" ( $ & $> 0 & '
"0'
,
& "
, ' "$ ' ,"* ) '
#* )
# '"
& '" '
"+-
#$ & ' + , '
-3- ",
"
".
) '
#* ) ' "0+
,"* , '
#" +"
+$$ * $ ("
& .
528345 4 " 8929: #' (> #" + +" '
'" ' ( C0
#' +'#" ,"*
'"( +"
+$$
"++
& ' "$$.
. && * ' ,) '
'"( , $ 8 0 0"
+( & 0 )'
, $ '
$> #' '> "+-
#$ & '" ' "0+
+
& #
"- (>'
"
'" '(
&
+)'
#" ' ' &' (
,
' ",
"
$"
."0
& 92 "+ '> ,0 ' "+-
#$ & '" " 0. , 2)53):294 '"
"$ > (
(>'
#* ) +'
#" ,"0$)' ".'"( ,
, (>' "++
+# ''0$"
'"0+' "+
, ' /
,0$$> %0 , '
' $> '" & * ' " $ , ' , $$ # & ".
'" '"
(
!
! #
" $ %&!!
& !& '
" $&%&
( ! )
*
! 3 '
'"*,0 ' "*
"0
-4D+ "
,
)
-
.
. &
/ -
0
1+,
210 ")
+ '42
-
"
) ) "
-
5
"
+ " )
#3
#,
6
5 7*58 + $ %4'% 5
44 1"
") +
%'4 0 ,
""
,
"
)
3 ,
%
)
"
) , #,
. 7""
* 5 8
8
. +
$ &%49
! 18")
+ 4'4&2
, )
"
: "
"
,
; $
5
+ '
" -
$ <
" )
$
! '
"
-5- $ %&!
! & '
" $
'&%4
"
=
"
, ,
""
&10 ")
+ 4'42
>
"
-
8
8
)
"
+
""
#3
#,
: 5 7 '0 "*
'
'" '
' .$, "+-
#$ &
">. , ' ".
"++
"$ < & + "
0 "*
"($+ +0."
+ +)' #"
$"
"
'"'+"
#""$
#"
0
& ,
"++
&"
+
<+0' "$ ,"*
#* )'0
&
( &'+ .
"0'
> "++
"
+
),
#"
'+" ' + .
"0'
> ' + "
> 0 %"( /
) ,7
&"
)6'"
&"
''"
"0'
>'"
"
,<+0
,'"$ ++
&$>)'
,+"
+$$"
(
,
, 0 ,'".
"$ >
'"
( &'$> " ?"
6 $"
&
('"$,
'"'"
'
"
'"'
#"
-6- +"0
%0 +
(>
$"> &'+
+ +0
,
+0.
<0
'"'+ +"
'
"0'
$, '
# '" '
'"
"
$
"0. ,2)53):294 #"+
*> (>'
"
".
, @):24
:952999 #* ) " 0. , 3)5994 #"' ",
(>'
99229,
+ ,'",
"
".
)'<+0 * '"
+ ..
'" ' ".
'" "$ > (
"
' "$
C0 ( & ' ,"* ' $*"
< "+ , ' "
+ +"
'0 ?+ "
.
> "
%
"
! )
,
, >
,
,
,
=
, @ , . = $.
9 . A
.
+B 0 . +
,
'!%4"
'!
"
.
'!%4
C
' !& ) ! )
> "
"
' %4 " $ %&!
!. " $ %&!
' %4
.
-7-
' !%4
""
!%4$ > " '&%4)
""
"
)
A
",
""
.
#3
#,
, !%4$ "
"
> ,
"
)
"
")
.6 .
")
,
, >
""
,
, ,
,
""
"
)
,
) )
$ !!%4D
: $,
,0 '
'"""." ,"+ ' $">
, ' ",
"
".
++0 + '
"0'
+ +"'
+
0 * ' ,, +
,
( &
"( 0'
"
'"""
#' '>+ +" '".
0)'
'".# '
0"
>,0 ' $">+
'"'"
,"+ #" 0$> C0 (>'"0'
"
"+'"
&'#" 0 ' <+0 * * $ " 89829@0
0$ 0 %"( 6 * $ * + ;0 '. A
"$= 0$) 59 ' +'"
& "&"
' .#" ',,+'"'
,'".
C0
#" "++ (>'"
<+0 * # '
0"
>&
"
*"$ +
'"
&' "$ C0 >"&"
'' <+0 * ) ' +'"
& "&"
' ,, + #"
"
"($ '
-8- ' C0 > ,, + "' +
" ,
& '" ' ".
#" &
(>'<+0 * ",&0"
,'" /
"
"*
>, + "$$ ' $*"
< "+
" (>'+ .
"0'
> '
"$6' ,+ "
> /
,0 %"() ,7
&"
) '0
. + =
. #3
#,
1 2
,
E D
%!%4"12%!!%4&.
& ,
'
0 B 8 ""
2 '
,
; FG%%.
E
. "
) ) .
. '!%45 E ""
$ ,
)F + "
9 + =
. #3
#,
1$ 2+ ,
,
$&%7G
.
+ % "
8 #,
. 8
. -, 5 . 0 B .
, &
8 #,
8
.-, 5 .0 B .
,
$ &%! ##. " , + ,
" )
8 #,
8
. A 9 9 '
. +
5 6 1'
2 ""
, , E
H
-9-
$; %.
! ,
,
> )
& ,
> ) " .
9+ =
.#3
#,
1 2
"
> ) " )
-> )G
;4
8G
" '!.%4-
)
A -
-
E
)
, )
8G%
,
"
5
@
)
)
-
"
)
0G 8G
,
8G "
" .
) ,
" )
, , . 9 + =
. #3
#,
1 ( 0 B 8 1 +""
2.
, .
'
. !
D
""
"
)
.8
, !9 =*
.-+
-10- 9 7 '0 "
&0 (> ' + $ ,
'
'" '
"0'
'"*"- ""
'"'"++ + ,'".
C0
(>'<+0 * #"# '
0"
>"0'
>#' " '+'"
&"&"
'"
,, + "$ >"
'0+
'" '
'"
'
0 ".
"$
&# ' '
"
' .(>'
#">("+- >"
29"
'"'
,+"
+$$"
,'( #" '>"
29: #' ' #"
0"
&4
0".
C0"'"
$"
?"
+ $ "
&
('"$, , '
") '
#* )+
'"'".
'"* &
(
#$$ .
' ( & " $"> ' ">. , ' "$$. ) '
' .$,#" ( "+' , ."
,'"0+
'0
$ +$" .<+0
,"
>"$ '
'" '0 &'$>"- "+
" ' ."
"
'"
+
, 0 ,'.
>"$ >
(>' . "++
+# '$"# 2 7 '"* '"
$"
+ $ "
&
('"$, , '
+ * "
'"*&
'
0&''
+0. "
"$
&# ' '
@ # 0+ "$
+0. '""
0 (>'
<0 ' 6 +"
("
& .
22 " 229@292 #' +' #" (> ' <+0 * ) "
"$") *
) .
"
" #$$ " '
<0 2 " 939@295
" (> '
"$ 6' , + "
>) /
, 0 %"() , 7
&"
& , ' ",
"
+0. +$"
$> '
# '"
# '"
& " $"> (> '
& '
-11- ".
,'( .
>)''"
'".
" ." ' . (>' "$
&# ' '+ +"
#"
$"> (>'
'.$*)0+',"+ 0$> ,$+ ,
.' + +"
<0 2 ' , + "- (> ' <+0 * ,
"++ & ' ".
, 3)5994 " "&"
' + +"
, @)9994 ' >"
2999 "$
&# ' ,
$"> ">. #" "++ (> ' ' ,, + ' .$, + +" & '" '
+ +" '
">"($ (> '
,
"
$> 9 >"
"
'" ' '"
"++ ' ".
' >"
29 . &" ' $ , ' /
"
+ .' $">4$"
$, '"* & ( "++ ( " *"$ , ) $ "( $ > ,
" $">
,'"
".
+"
' ", (,"
' $"
# 7# 0$ ( "*> ,%0 + +"'
"0'
. +
'" * '
0&' '> ."> ( " $"
+ +" & ' 0"
& ".
'
) '
#* ) '
( $ >,
$">
'"
".
.0 $$((
(>' (
' .$,'+
.
0
"$
+0. ,$+ '" '
'"
"++ ' $">
( " (0"($ "&"
' ' "++ + , ' ("$"
+ "$ +
"
# ' '>"
29&"* < +"
,
"
," &' - & "
,'"$ : 7 "$
+ '"'"( *"
".
'"
(
#"> ("+- ( 0"
>) 29) '
#* ) '
"
4,
, 0 #" " (>'
"0'
29:#' ' ".
-12C0
'"
"$ > (
(> '
" ' + +"
(>'
"0'
+ 0$
'"*' ", $" "$$># '
"#
"- " +
'+
>"
,"'
&' '"
"++ 0 ,"* , '
' "+
, '
"0'
'00,, ,
.$"+- , +>) "
&"
' "0'
'"* & "++ ' < $"
"
0 ,
' (> ' <+0 *
+ $ >
+
&"&"
' ."
#"
& ,"
( $ >A$ "( $ >,
" $">
)0+'"
"+
"0'
+"
(0 '$ 8 '
( &","
+"
(
0. (* # ''".("
&"
&
#
"#"
,',0 +
&' +'>
' '"
"$ > $ *
,'$"
'
''"(
0"
<+$0 * % >. '".' +"
+$" .'" '"0,, "
%0 +(>"
$">
,'".
+ "$$>#' ' ".
"$
&# '
#" ."
A
'$"
#
+"
(
0. '"*< +
+'" & . ' $"
(0,
'"0 +
7+"
("
("+" ,+
+
"$"$$ A "' "(
+A' &'
+
'"
". $">
,' "$+
"
.">
'0(0,, + "' "& . ".
&' '0
$> & ( & "$ "'$"
,"*
)'". (& * 0 # &'"&'
'0"+-
#$ & &'
'$"
"++ &'.
>"
* - &"
>
+. ,"
> ( "+'' .
0&
+ &+"
+$$"
,'( ,"*
-13- '
;
<0 = " 8929: "++
&$> " '
"0'
"
+ <+0'"$ . '"0+
+ ,"*
# '
"
,9@.
'
.' " + ,+ ,
> ,'
'
"$$ # -)
($*0 %#, I
E'' "- &4 "
F4 E''
"($ F4