← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1659/2024dismissed

State Of Haryana And Another v. Sanjeev Tanwar

2024-10-21Mr. Justice Deepak Sibal,Mr. Justice Alok Jain10 pages



     

   

  !      "#$%$&'(')*  

+#"#$",-")"")%")#.$, 

   +")/$$0")1",     * 2  + 3+   2  + 3 * 

  !"# 

  $  % 

  % "& %#    444  3+5 (1) '

  % 

   % (  ($ )) )) )* +" (,(#

-& .   &

( 

 $+ / 0( - 1# 2/0- 3 (2)

#&#%$"+ % (3) '

 $  4) 4 !"## % -$$  # 2 -$$    

% # 

 $#55/0- + %! / $#  # !" 6 #      )  & $ #    %("  7      & % #$ 55  )* 

LPA No. 1659 of 2024 (O&M) [2] %8" $#  %("&% #$) 9 (4) '

 

 # %   #

 %  (  # 9 #/0- $#  %(" !

 & &   &6 % # #  #

$#$ *!&

 $ & 

$&

 # (#  +"

$+#

-+ (-:44)#)  &

& #)  )   &  %   %  .% $# 

 $  /0 -  6 )5 ;)         

"

( .% $#

 $ (  ( - 0( (+ +"  ") &   % $ #$ ,   < "   =  " =

&

  %( >'

 %# (    . +    -:  *  # )  &

( (  %# % 

 

$/0 -  (5) :

 .  &  (+#

- & (  "#( 0( (+   %$+"$  &+ (% +" $ -   +%  #    &

    % &   

      '

#

-



 .  &  % #

% 

LPA No. 1659 of 2024 (O&M) [3] (6) '

 ($  5)      $ - # "%    #        (%# +" $    %$& (!&

( "$   %  &    $ -  %   ?  -%  # '%  % 0%  #   2 ?-'0     =  "  -$$  # @= -  "%%A$  "2 , ) 4 #   %  &   +  +&   " ) 2) 9    0( ( %  (  % ( # (   % $ ? & #   %  #   %  %   #  A$   &

 & $     ( +   (+#  (#  (+ %# $ (7) '

  (+ 0( (%  %$+&  ") 2) 9  #  # # % % (  +"    $ - ! 

   A$   %% +"  ?-'02= -  $ #    % 

+"

%    %%#" %   $  #  $  %% ("  % # % 

( ( "+ +"

$ ") & 

$+" ?-'02= -6 ( # +  $ +"    $ -    

 

 %       #

 ( +"  ?-'02= -   # 

% +#

-

(#  #

 

 '

.  &  ##   (+#

LPA No. 1659 of 2024 (O&M) [4]  (,(#

-+#& $   + #

 %      % # %  +" ?-'02= - &

 %"  

0( ((&

$ ") 6    

 .  (   % +( +# #  ($#

% 

 (#  &  %  &   ($& %+"    $ -    

% <  ($ $ (  %

  (,(% . +%   &  .   $ " "

(    ($#

- 5 ) )5 



   !

"#$%&'   ()    (8) B#      %  +$      % +( +# # ($# 

% C

 ( 0( (+% "&  $ - %  ($   &    %   

#

%   # ($# $ -  5 4) D   

'    

 *+

, -, .   !. $/0/

!1 2.-!1 1   !1"0 %&'   3 

3  

LPA No. 1659 of 2024 (O&M) [5] (9) 6   %

 (# 

  % + $+"   

 

 %   ? & #  +$   + ##   %+"  ($ 0  %&'% &$ %  + $+"  $ -   ($  0  %&' %    

 .%   % # %"+    +#  % " "& 

  ($    

 

 %  &    % %  %       +  " %%+" ?-'02= - "2,) 4

(10) 

#  ( %#  %#" A$  ( %  #%&

$( +&  " ) 2) 9   &   ,   < "   =  " =

  

 ( %  -  0( (    % $E  + 

 (  -  0( ") E  $  4) 4 -$$    

%   

  55 /0 -  &

 &%)*E# #  9 &$#  %("E ( 

 $( # 9 $#  %("E#%  #  .%  * # $     & 

 $" (  ( 

LPA No. 1659 of 2024 (O&M) [6] - 0( ++ +"

$  $# % % 

(11)  6 5)   % ($   

%  &

&   (  0( ( %# +" $      %$&  +(&% % &   +  +&   " ) 2) 9   &    &  +" %%#" % (  A$    +  " %% +" ?-'02 = - "2,) 4'

$-#   % #        A$   &

 ) $      %  ( &    #"   ? 

 ( #% (

* 95

# ($# $ -

% %" #  (

 %+&##%F2

 

    

          

      

     !"

  #

  

             

 

   

   $%%&'$%%(

    "

    )   

        

) 

*     

  

  "    " 



+       )

   ,            ) "

    #

  

 )  "

 

-)'. /$%&0    ) 

+   "       

)   !    

  

              

!/   )

LPA No. 1659 of 2024 (O&M) [7]

    ")          

    " 

   ")   1  "

 )  

      #           "  

 &( . )/$%&0#         # 

  



  !

           

 !   "        1    " 2

   ") 3&%3$%&0 ) ! 

   

/    " 

 "    

4 *      

    

   ! 



      !/  







    

  

         )

   )         

     "          

   / ) )" 

  

"   "    0 ########## 5 ########## (% ########## (& ########## ($ ########## (3

 )/

6   ##########   ##########   ##########   ##########   ##########            !  

      

/      !" 

   "      

      

  

 )7  *'&/+

(12) 

# # % (

# ($ #

%

LPA No. 1659 of 2024 (O&M) [8] $#"+ $  #&   0( ( (    % $  &       0( ( % +&   " ) 2) 9    A$  %% "+" ?-'02= - "2,) 4&

&$     (  +#     0( ( (  +"

$ +

( #" 

(13)  '

 %+" % (

  #   ($ #    $ - 0  %&' %   #+$ %  + $+"

 

 (

 

  . %   

 (

   $ -  +      +#  + ( " +"  (   %$ # ($ +"

% &( # % & &  & +"  ( A$  + "%%+" ?-'02= - "2,) 4 (

 # ($# 0 %&'%  #&F2

&% / / 

/       1     1     - / 

      

  

)



" 

   .

  

 )   #

 /  " 

   

     

      #



 

    /      "  ) "*

 

 

)      " 

  

  

 /

 

    )  

)

     )    .

  

   

   

"

)

LPA No. 1659 of 2024 (O&M) [9]  8

/      

   

   )   /   .

   /  

   

     

  ) 

        

)     

     

  "       



   " 

    

 /    

/    

)

        

    

 

  

 

.

  

 /

 

)"

"           " 

      / "

 7  )" " 

/ ) 

)

   .

  /

     9   

  

  ) 

     ").

 

 7

(14)  '

    ( +     



(% - 0( (+& ") 2) 9

, < "  =  "=

  %$    A$  %% "+" ?-'02= -  , ) 4 & +    "    #  #

     (  0( (    (    %% +" 

?-'02= - ,) 4  &

& '

&  # .$   % &+" -$$  )) ) D % & +$  (   %   

 

$  /0 -  &  %  G"  +# H+&+%"%8%#  # +# &

+ &"#$

$" ( ( +"

$&  %$

LPA No. 1659 of 2024 (O&M) [10]

(15)  ?  ( # + % &# #% ( $ (($

(16)  / $ 

(17) 

  ( $ % 

%  # "    #   3+!   

 

  3! 

)    :

  

(CFIC :

  + FIC