High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/23471/2017allowed

Rakesh Kumar Sharma And ORS v. Union Of India And ORS

2018-05-14Mr. Justice Darshan Singh12 pages

Vimal Kumar 2018.07.28 11:25

!"#"$%

& '

()*+

*% ,-*./ !"# $

!" % !" /0 &'(") * +,) !"

-.-/"! !" 0!1 1

%1 "# 1

1 - %% '2345((3. # 6- + - +,"% - " 6- #- ! . !"" %! 6- % % .

1 !" 1! + - 1 7 6 "8

9: %;1

%&" $<

19: 5('( 1 '33 = %> "

1 - ! -

6-- " % % %! %

" - 1 91: 53(45((*

! % # "

6- 1 (4('5(('? >

! # ''(35('4 # ('(@5('*.1 - 7 6 "8 " % 6- 1 #

" - ? 1 + -># 59: # % - " 1 ? % > # 1 "

4 6 ! " !% % "

6 A @ #?1 "B"

+ -> ?.

+ - > "! -

# CA " B"

+ - )

6 % - !"& "" " - 6-

- -

!- !"9"

% 6:& "" " !- !"-

% - % %B

!". -

6 - - - "

"# %6

% . "

- #

6 6< !D 9<:

"! 1 % % &" + -#

6 6D -"

% -

6-1 % % &"

@ .

+ - ) . !" - 6 -6

6- - -%# %%- % 6 . !" - - - 6

6- - B 6

"% E & " ,)A- # = - 5('A '( ''# # # ?

+ ># ,"

%('(@5('A

72 =

% 1 # # . !" - / # "

! ('(*5((F 9 , )*: # " .-

" % " !"

-%A(- .-# #

5('@. !6"

66#" " -.# 6 !. 4 )" % 1 5A'(5('A !% " "- "

%!6- 1"

% % .-# -

6-,-. 6-

% - / % 6" ! ! " % 5((*#" - !"5((' 6 % -6 "

# 6-1% .4

)1&" (3''5('A 7A % 5A(45((*

. -

6 "- "

# # - 6 " # 1

#" - " # - "

- " .! 6 1

1 " - . ! " 6- 4

# # % !"" " ,"% *F( - # (''(5('@ 'A(25('3 .- # "

- > - #" # 6

" "9 "- :& %" " # # " "B(A(25('@#" #-" -" 6% . " #" , )'A . !" # 6 -

! 53(25('@ # - " %"#" , ,)'@B')'@B'(" '( . 6

B ! 6 # " -% # ! 53 # , 5#" -# " .- %

-6"%" " 6 -

!""# ""

4 # # % % " "

5((F "

% % - . ('(*5((F 9 , )*: - / 5 " C

"E . 1 ## $ " - # "! - 6 ! 6 5((* 9 :# "

- % 6 5((* # 5('4 +!

53(45((* " "! - 1 7 6 "8 . " 6 " % !"" "6-4 " " !" " " 6 % !% .

-6 -%%" "6# % 1 9) :6 " #! ! " . * 4 ! # "% " .- 6/" 1

- 6 / " "

'5 55A 1 . 1 6 6 6"

- " D " ,) !" 6- !% " 6 " % % .- " #

! 6"" 1 !" % % - " ,) !" B% "! ."# "% D - 0" % 1 % 1

#" 1

&" 1

% 9 &1: 'F

0! "

0 - &1 # 1 "

- &" '@'%% # ; 1 B/ D ! .-

4* - # % 1 " " %

"*5 - #! --

- # " " 6 6

# ! - -

= 5(('6 " " 6 # - . # - *5 " " - 9) :'( #! "1 %

. # % "

"!- % 1 !" ! ! F D @ - 6/"

# CF .%

"! - 1 7 6 "8 "" 6

6 "6 - %% - #% " - " " 6 # " !" #

6 % 6- .%

6 "6 -%! -# - 6%6 # -""-#! E . # % ! - ! -

" ('(*5((F9 ,)*: "

% !"B . # .6" % , % # 6- !% 6 !" !" 1 "

"6- "

6 #."4

" "

!" "%

" " . " ,)A# #%"

C+.+E

% 6-

- G " %'5'(5('@1 # %" 6 !" - # 6 !" " & "

# " 6/"6 #

- 6 , % %#" - # 6,! . # *(('5('3 # # & , % 5'(*5('31

#% C$ % $!% % -# 6- '234 " # " "6 "" % - , )'@B')'@B'( - ; '5(F5('3E # "6 %17F2'2)1G5('3 # 6- # - / " 6-6 %%"1 55(45('3 6-4 # " - 6-1 "! 1(A(45('3 . !, " 55(45('3

C' " - 6- $ 6 $% 1 /6 $ -1% 5' 5('3 "! 6- 1(A 5('3 5 H 6- "/ 1

# " '@ 5('@

#%" 9: H !" # 1 #

6 - " " 6 *F( -

I " %! 6/" #"!

96: H ! % "

/% 1 " % " 6 ,

6 - " - " 9": H ! 6" 1

- /% 1 - I ! & 5B5((AB< "/ "# 59:

1!+ -1!$< 0 9

-: 72A(52B<B00 '' % 5('4 A $< 0 9

-: 72A(52B<B00 '' %5('4 9: H ! "66-

" " 1 &

E . " 6 " 5'(*5('3 "

! 6 "

% %

6 % 6 # " % - ! " / " " " "

"" - .- # 6 ""

6% "% """# 1

# ""# "#1 . -" # 6 6# 6 #--%%6-

6- $ 6 " 6 ! - 6 #!

%- %.-!6"

5((F#""

" " 6- # % " .

B !6 -

- 16

6# " % - % . %! !!### $"6 - " 6 "-4 . 1 ## $" D J # 1"6

" " 6 " 6- 1

6 $%1 & D 6 - / % $%1 %

7544A5('F"(*(F5('@L! !% " ! -. "# F6 !

# C # 'A5((F 5345((* . 6 - # / % 6- -" "

% &'

( )

(

& ' ( +, !

& ' * *

( (

( .$/ ! " 6 " - . - #

- , 7* *(F5((3 6D - 'A'5((2 .

# ! , 71 * " ! 6

6%!" % - %

!6%0 1 "B % ! % F''5('F !

-6 'A5((F.-!6"

" 6! " - *45('*. ! %01 " %% " 0 1 " # !" " . # 6 "%

" " . " / % $ 1 F''5('F$#! $ 1 - "

%! ! . " % '( - % !" % 0 1 " 6 - 6 ! ! "

'4 'A 1 "" % - #

# % , 7'(F''5('FD . " %! "1 "

*45('*9 , 7A: ## -E ." % '() *( - !" % " " 6 - 6 ! ! "

'4'A 5'1 " #

6 - "

% - ) 6 " % " 6 " 1 %% 6 " !"

- 1 " - / "

- " # !" !#6!"

# .

B . 6

!"#

"D 6 . # 1

) -

/% -" " -1 "

-% 1

& ' 1/2 01

2 3 4 0# 3 5