High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4436/2014allowed

Central Warehousing Corporation v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2018-02-15Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath8 pages

!"#"$%&

$( ) ( *+#"$,(-( "$ ""$ ( . / +$0 1 $2* (# #-$2 $#

$( ) ( *+#"$,(-( "$ ""$ ( . / +$0 1 $2* (# #-$2 $# 3 453 / 6/6 3 7

# $ %&# '%&( )

6/6 3 89 ( ):% * ++ # #) ,

+ $( ) ( *+#"$,(-( "$./

+$0 1 $2* (#-

++ ./.0

+ $( ) ( *+#"$,(-( "$./

+$0 1 $2* (#-

++ .1" .0 & !+! )#"

2! 3

"!"

" ),4 " # *#)"

,,! , )5++" 3,## 5 ++, ""5

# &5 , " ,#" +

67&) )5# # ! ) + )"

& #

"&, +

7) # &)+"1"8 3, " + "9& :!& ;++ ,2

5&#&'" / , 1 ) #&)+"#&#

+5< , , #! = "9&">6- .".0 *= "9&++"/ , 1 )- .++".0

&" ?>6? ,

&)# + )5) " #

"9&

& # )5# * '" / 1&##+ 1" 5 %! &( )! + 6> " '"/ @1&##+++ + "9& +

#; +

# '"/ @1&##+&( ) # "

9& 4"& +

!&"" ,+5 + 4"&

6! ;

3 + " :

>A B :

>A +

&, : > ?A 4"& + 1&) :, / , 1 )

"& 1"? 7 1

">66++", , ""5

# &5 , " ,*++"! "##

# &5 , " , &

>? A,&

# &5 )" , !

+& + #!

+ "

" +

4"& + " # )5# + 9&* " &, " )&& 5&"" ++" & ""5 )!! 6?

*# !

+ 5 ## + #! & 1"?-0 ")

+ '! + * ## + + ?

) )! )5 '! +

+ # &" 5! " , + 4"& + = "&+ # &) & !+! "

# # 5

&5 , " ,, #&" + "9& )# "

" + )5 # #!

+ 4"& +

6C 7&) "" # + + ! # ++ "& ) " #

+5 3! 1" "7

&&) ) )!# !&

6),

:&+ &( ) 1

#-' +, 8 ;

+& 7& 0:&+6> )5, 4#+ * 4#+ &

7 &&) :&+ $

:&+!

" &

$%(

)

+ ,*-* !

7 &) :&+ $ &

! & 6

" &

$.%

/ 0 & 1 2

$% 3

+ ,**4

$- 5 ,*-, &

! "

7 &) )5 # # :&+ "

& 4

)+##5 ++) )++":

#'&5 ++) " , , " , &# "

& #! "& , )5, + ++

+ + 7&) # ) "&

6 + 4"&

6 #") 7 &&) :&+ $""

&#! + &"3 + , &#

7 &&) :&+ $ &+ 4 ,!) &" 5# + 4"&

>,, &#

3, &++ # = "&+ # &) "

++9& +5

) :&+ $ :&+ + 4"&

6 )

&, ,& & &) + & ) &"

.3* )")+18 3* )"./ +$0 1 $2* (#8 '

;" " )5&

,!,) :&+ $"

D) (& , # ) ,??>

7 & &) 1 &( ) + =

+ / +$0 1 $2* (#.* $( ) ( +#"$,(-( "$

# )5+ 1,+ & ,

* = (& )"

)5+ 1 "&+ 1=

# ,

# ,"

" )5 '!$" & =>6

+ / +$0 1 $2* (#.

(#* < ## $2 $* ( >

(#* < ##-&# 0

" )5 '!$" , ##5)51 #&)+" &5 & !

+& 1"? ""&+ )!3 $

5= >6

+ / +$0 1 $2* (#.* 3* )")+1 )5'!$" >

! # =>6

+ / +$0 1 $2* (#.

(#* < ## $2 $* ( 7,+51 &( ) + 1=)

3* )")+1 +(#* < ##-&# 0*1= + "

3* )")+1 1=-0

++,)!

3 7 !# $*8,*--

. /:

5 .5 .

2!"

(#* < '

-&# 01= , "! !+## +> 6

## + )52.)+1&# &

, E ! + "&+ # + 2 !,, &," "

#"&+

" ""& " "

" # ## +), ! 5 ! ) "" ,+5 D "" ,+5F *# &&)

" :&+

" )

" )5 5 4"& +

>&#

#" 4 ) 3" #!

+,#"

4"& + 7#+5+ 1 "&+ ! +5 ,& &, #& )& & )&! " ))&," )5##!

+ #&# 4"& + 1 "

++5&) G4#+ :&+ .

)+##5. .4"& + .

= "&+ ##+5&) ! #& # + ),!# & "9&)&# + 5

# #" + " )5# 7&)

> "

& ) # +5

+ 4"&

, +

+ )+ 4 )5 1 &( ))5 ,4#+ &+"#! 4"& +

" & "

& 4 ) , "& 1 + # &

)5":&+ $

* #

&+ 3,## 5

& :" ""5

# &5)5 ,!

+& + & : " *!5

" &

+ 5 " &"

3* )")+1 +(#* < -&# 0" +5&#2.)+1&# &7

" # # )5++" '! +

++5++, + &+ ++,) # #&, &,& 5 " #"#5 )#+ " "" "

+ 9 6/6 3 :

1# 3,A: HA :# )+ HA