← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21815/2018allowed

Shingara Singh v. Punjab Agro Industries Corporation And ANR

2023-02-16Mr. Justice Pankaj Jain14 pages



IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA

AT CHANDIGARH

  

 

   

      

       

 !"# $%&'(# ) $$ (

       



!

  

  " 



!

    #  $ %



!

    & ) $$ (*$+ ", %%    

  '

 

  #( )* &)#( + , '&- .

    



 !

   

 

   !   /) )0 &)#*

          

  1       $

 '



   !

  



       %     



    2 %$

 $  

 $ 





3   

 



!%  

 %     !" # !$!#!!# 

 



  1   

 % '

                                  

                         

                                     

                   

                                         !                            "       #$%&'()*&+,-  % !" #!$!#!!#                         

            (,,&+,.  

   &)+*&+,. &( ,

                $ !  /   0    1      

              $ !  /   0     1   2     $   2  &+,'

  3&+,'23 2,( 2     45 6,(  7   $       /4                               $ ! 829

                           

              !      

     

                      

                        5    :              2,( 3&+,'

23$ !8 $   / 2   

  

 

    

      ! 

  2&& $ ! 8 $   / 2  

   2&& 

  $ !    8  $      /  2  0;00    

  45 6&& <                                 <     &'

      !     



      <                   5   $ 5

, 8               

            

           

-

& 8      

 

  

 45

          <  4

        

                   = 

     

    <                        =

( !       

  

      

      & = 

>  $8                 ?@   5  "   5

,                        = 

& A     5           



  = 

        

                          =9           

  2&& 

  $ !    8  $      /  2  0;00   !                                             

          1             2     

   2&&               2&& $ !8 $ 

   /  2                                   2&&     !    

                0       

       /5            #$5&).&-&+,>

   &     %     !  " # !$!#!' "()# &>+,&+,.0  

    < 8 

                              5              < 8   #$%&).&-&+,>                

                                                                                                         2&& $ !8

$      /  2     0  ;  00       

   2&&       5   

        5  0        

 !  

                 

         !      

 

          2   !   45     ?@   $ !/  0    1  $/0 B  (,+.&+,&/   5  ,.+-&+,&?  C 

                ,+,,&+,> / @$5-   2,>+>+'-(, 5 

      

       5     

        

       (> 8   C           0              $ !/  0    1  2  $  2 ,**,  2  ,(        2    ,**,                          C    $ ! 820     $ !    8  2  &&     50  ;500                         0           

.

2,( 2,**, 45  6,(7   $       /4                   

                        8   C  $ !829         C$ !82  (> 8   C /     $   / 

       D 

7        

  1                  

            

  7  2&&  45 6&& E<     

                                          <          !       

 

                  <                   5   $ 5 , 8           5                         

                                   

& 8             

            5  45

                        <  4

         

       = 

     

    <              =

( !           

                                           & = 

> $8     ?@   5"   5

,                                    = 

& A     5

          

   =  

         

        =9 %         5          

   

          &++-5&++*&++*5&+,+  &+,+5&+,, "0   2.*>-,&&>) 5   0     !       2&&              <                  8  !               1     

   

/   0     @ 

              8      &&  !          ,+,,&+,>

/ @$5-    @   B              !        $    9 1      

!   & *' $( 

  

    ?   @                   

          

               @  !

     

               

  B 38 0     /  %&,+,  ,*** +#  , % +!!-.*#!/0                                                  2   !   45 60                         

                           

                                       C             (+)*'        

      

                         0     

                           9 B 38 0  % ##!-1 #!#

'( 2

                       

!                               !

     

 2

  !  45 6#     D2

         D   7  <        

                 B                   0     !     B 

     8                /       

           0                              @                               "               

     0    B   8            D   7  <     9                          #$ %,'&>.&+,,  ,%3.*#!

 !-!#  45 6/                   2                                           % 

  @  

 

                                 

   B 3 8    8 3      

 2       

        0         2  

                               5                

!     C    #                  9 " 5         !   ,' $( ,!1   45  ##  0#!  !-  !   !!$#% !66#!7

2'2()12  45 6.C   

         2 ,*.'               0   

                             

      -                                       B 3  8         %  ##  !- 1 #!#

' (2  

   5%8##45+ 6 #97*:

6!#

'

()1  *0   !   

  2                      

  8         !      ,  *

' $( ,+  0                              2      

          !        ,,/     

            ,&+*&+,&              ,+,&&+,&                                        

9 /              B 38 0          

!                                                 

       

 

         

          C                  

   

                                              !                           

      

           !                

    

  



                        

          #$%&).&-&+,>

                                                      F                                

                                     

                       0        

     

 0                         

                                                        

          #                      

      



   

               1  

    

      

         

-                                                /              

      

!       

                                  

  @   

      

   @    /        9    1  !    

     1  

    %%    '

  $ 2    

+ ) $$ (, 50 $% 0# 5

  67    7 5

   %

 7