← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3224/2015dismissed

Rinki v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2016-11-16Mr. Justice Darshan Singh15 pages

     

!"#"$% &



&     



    

  '%()'*+       

 

            +,  ! 

     !

    "

     #!

   $%  $&'  (  

)       "

   

   )*)    

+ 

" + )   !  "  #!

  ,$&'(  !  "     

  + )   " ( ! "    

  " "  + 

! (! 

        

+  -

! &$&% + )

) " ( .  ! (        + ) (     /  

   "    

  + )   

 

!  

  .

) .

"

 

               !  (  

      "   (  

)   ()  .  !    0  + ""

  ""1)     "  " 

)   



 " !    .     

) "   ( .   *&$$&2

   ."

  ( ' $&2 .3%  ( .

!

 -

! 2 $&'(   

  -

! &,$&2           ."

   .     "

   ! (  (

) "

      )! (  ( (   

4  $ #)))  !   )

     "

        )       .35

" ) % 6

               

  !

))     

      + )



"  

)

!  

+  "

)   

      3  )    )  (          

  +     +17 $$28' $&2 )   (!  ! 

!  "

)"  (!) 

) !  " !

    "

  " !(    "

 

  (  

    (        (

) " !)!

        !    

 "   

 (  (     7

"! &2$&'

"   + )(  

 ") " !  06  (  

 #!

 ,$&' 2 1  " ( !  #!

 ,$&'

  " 

 "      #!

 $%$&'       

+ (  

 !

 !    "     

( 

  

)(33 

( "

) 

 (

+  ! 

)

!

.

"

  0+   (     

(. ! #!

  $'$&'!(  "   "

 

"  ( 

!  

") 

+   

    ! )            (    

" 

  -

! &,$&2( 

     ' 4  1     9( 



 !       

)  

    (   (   "   . ) 

) " !     !+

 :

   "

!9(   !   ! )  

  

"-

! &,$&2 



!    ( )  )    /!

;$&&<=%++$,$ !")



   ( !       ! /  

+  



   )" 

  !    " 

     

 "  !"  " .3<  

"

)"        "

" 5 1      !

   9     

  (    " 

  )      ))

    

4 ) "  #!

 ,$&'   "

! (      )  "   " !(

  "      "



   

) "       "

"      !/ " 

    "!  &  $&&5     !     !

4        #!

 5$&&, <     "! &$&&5

)

>  

")" 

"  " )



.         "

)    

""      '    + ""

  ) ) 

)  .

       ( !

     

" 7   -

! &$&&%( 



? 

3+0"  (

)  

>

()! 

"   "   "    )

 "        (  ( !     "  

>

> ()  

!  "

$&&%)     )

5$&&2  "  " )  4 "      

)     " 

"

  !   

 ( " ))

! )



 !

     ( 

     "! &$&&5 " .  (       

))   ) )  " ? 

   " (   !))   "

 () &$&&5  



") 5 $&&2 (  *&<$&&5( 

! (  )

&$&&5 8    "

  

     

)         "! &$&&5@.3A   .        

)  

   ) ( " ) (    )

       )   "

  "     "   !: ( 

>      . 



)    

  )   

 "(



) 

>   (  !)  )   !/

 !    

  3  $&&5   (  ( 

 .   3    !    " !( (        + ( )  

 

+   

 

 !   

 .



)    )    3+ ) ,  36.    .3 (  ( 

. (       ( 

 

   )     )    "  " )  

 )!   ( 

. ))"   !"    

  .

) ."

  "  () .! 0+  ""1)  ,28

( 



 # 0 "  ! 4 : (   



) ()  

 # 0 " (! ! 

& ) )

 /   " (    )  ."

     " (

"   " #



!3+ @A  36"   "!   

   

 "   !

" (  ."

   



#0 ! ! B) )/ 

  "))" 

   ."

  + @ A  36

   ( "))" 

 (  )     



(   "      ) "  )!!

   (   "!)       ))" 

.  "  "     .    "( 

) "  

))  ? 



4 ! "

) " (  .C6C  . &  

  )                  

)  )  

/  ."

 

    ! )   "

 

"  #0  !    )  



/    

 " (!" )    D

E(!"!  "  

! 

!  ()

   F" ! (    " !       ) 

!  "    "   "

    "   

"    ( 

 "     ) )  

" 

  

 "  "!  " )       .(     .    ."

 

-



 

  ".  ! )) 

) " !      )  :     

  !   (

) " )   !    . 

.  -

! &,$&2;    )  ) $&'=  "  ! !    " 

   "

)"   " "  (         )    

 "  )

 

>     ) 36      "! &$&&5        )  







    

!  

  3 !   !

  " 

")  "))"  !"

"

     36    $&&5 (  

:  

  

  

.(  

      ! )    $   (  (

         

 )))>

) 

>   . )  !

4    #!

 5$&&, (    

  # 0 "  0 "! , $&&8

      "! &$&&5(   "

  !       

"       

     (   )  (     

! 



  "

)" $&%     (

) ! 

" 

 !  " (  

  !  

   )  " 

. 

    (

   ) 

  "      !) 



 



  

"     

""   )  

)   





  !

>   

 . 

   (   "     

)

    

    !          

>               "!  &  $&&5      !





    !      #!

  5$&&, (  

  "

      

      ) 

)   ")1 !

   

)" )   $&&5       ;$&&,=  

  )      ) 

  



 

) 

"     !)

 "" 

     !  

  )   3    3$&&,@.3$A 

(     )) +   3(  "     (

)  "

!!         

 . !

 ")  (        "

   :   (

  )  :""

 

     " 

" !

   "  

  "

)" ( :    

()(  $&&5       

    : 3 !

       

"

""

      "+    

 ; ")  (   + =( "  (

/  "    )!

 (  

))"

     !     !   

  ))"  

 (

  

  

  )  

   " ! "> 

  "

     .   



  !   

      " !(         )      " (

."

 

   "

 ( !;(   =  

  ! 

     "        -

! &$&% )!     + )

!  

)   ) 

3 

  

   

     

    

 

  



 

    



                

     

 

        

 

 

     

!"  

   #    

      "   $    %          

      & '

  





    

 &   

    

(  "  $   '

  )*)*+*),

( $

 - .$-/"

  %   )(  )

!(

  

) " (   !    ( 

 



 .36 

 (   



 "



) "   (    3$&&5  "   ( 3      1%  -2334351 

   

6666666666666 6666666666666+**     -               

   66666666666666666666  !  7  -     .



   !  

 

7 



  

  7  







    

  /            

 666666666666666666 

666666666666666666666 

 6666666666666!

 666666666666666666666666.



  

 0     8323      9  6666666666666666 5!8323  



:



 

      !  



 

  5!8323   

 



           

 





  5#87  1323;#237  1%  -2334351 8%153

315!%1% 323<&-233!<&5!

<31833513$21%3  =5!32>( )      

 ! 

    





 + 

    

    

 



4

8  7)?@A. B%)?@A/   

! "

 

  > ,       



      

  





   C 





  

 

9

  

 @   

 

  

 C 

   

!        D ! 



%

"

               

   1 !      



 

   



    %

 "       

  



         

  

  

 ! 

         

 !   E % 

        

   ! 

      :  

 

    

     A   ! 

                       

 7  

 

? %                7 

 

   

   %58%153

8323#;13!3$2143515!13 $32 #5<#F3 %!F3323=51# =< "2%<3 13%2  5!

 #5  13  !&7  4#51  5!  &32 ;%2 14351%#53!<#F3%513$23 35"3#;

;#GG#8%5-8%153

 )

  >

  > 5> 5> ! > ! > !

 > !

 > ;     -  +

  > 5> ! > !

 >0

  2 :  " !

  (   ")

 (

 D(   E    "     -

! &$&%@.3A( .



  

   



 

 !

  "

" F   .

" !         "   6   



    "  

! (      



     (

  D E    !    @ 

"   

   A:   (

 D E (

  .C6C@

) " A  (

  ))

    ! 

/ (  .

D(   E  

:"     ( .

  )  D ED(   E  ) 

  

)"  . !. "      

  ) "   (  ! (        

)

 " D (   E 



) "  

        ( "    ! 

!     # 0 "  

  

)" 

   )   "



   .   

   

"  "  ( !    /  

( ( !   

   (   ' : (  !



:      )



( !(!

) ))" (   

 ) !( ) /      )  !    

) "  !

 

" "  "   !  " (

   

)

 " 

 (



    "  5 (

!

    ! 

  )     "   

! " 

    

" (  



  (    "   !         !           '     " !"

   () "  !" '

     "   !"

 )          '      ( 3 D 

     " 

    

  

       

  

 

:

  

+*)@()D

     4   2 5+@DE,?E       ) (*E(+*)@  

 

  2 5))+?    <  $ (%  

    

    

"   $

 .

2(F/

 

  $

  

"   1

         :

     $

   

    0 <        (    "   . )  "!   )  :

   3 D    



   

% 

       



             



  $

   +?)*+*)@ *+*,+*)D7          

   

 

$(A7  :

  

   

    "   % 

  

  

     

       

     



 

   

  

0

  8  )

 :  

 ! !

  

"   ( !

  

)  

  



    ) 

""       "  G"  

 "

.

)

   .    

!     )    )(

)(    C  

  ) ?   ( 

"   " 

" 

   !    : (

 /)( 

) (    ( ")  

      + ) 

  /     (     (    !  )  )  "

       (   "

 "

+ ""  

    + ) "     (     ( 

  

 )  (  )

"  ( "    !   )  

! 3  



"  

         

 ! (   (   !)  

"

 

     (

)?   !

 )

"

  

   )

 !   !  

 (



)

 .       H       '  )          (  /     " 

!   

     :"       "  .

4 !/  (   



""  "

  

       )

   ) )

   !   

 ( 



 

  



")

"     

(

 !) 3   

 )   

"       

    

         

     :  "

     (    

 "    ) '     . 

   (       

  

  

 

" + ) ) !(: (  ! 

+

"       "

   !! ( 

  

  )"

     ( , 

)         (

          

 $$5  +       "

 0+1    

&



& "/ 1  )>   I 1  

! I