Mahipal Singh Mann v. Union Of India And Others




    
 

"#$%$&'(')* + ",'-"./')0, "))  $#'#')$1 2(

)')
)%'"")%1(  $(-)%$)#( 1"3* )45.$ 16(#'&$ "7'2/,"13"

)45.$ 16(#'&$"1')%$1/')0,/'%,6

1$($)#*8 1176) 1"#"-#3" "39%2&"#$ 1#,$-$#'#')$1 1 :".9%2&"#$ 1
81$(-)%$)# 1'#') "#,$$9%2&"#$1 1)'. "#,$$9%2&"#$ 11$(-)%$)# 1 "7$(,,"1%;"79/$)'1$-6#:%2&"#$$)$1".9 6)7"5
  

,$-$#'#')$1,"((60,#76%'&'".1$2'$;#,$1%$1%"#$%   1$)%$1$%  5:  $)#1".  %3')'(#1"#'2$  1'56)".9  ,")%'0"1, $)&,9,")%'0"1,9-"(($%')  <<  ,$51'$"&#()$&$(("1:1#,$%'(-(".#,$-1$($)#-$#'#') "1$#,"##,$-$#'#')$1;"("--')#$%"($-6#:/6-$1')#$)%$)# .'&$ 2'%$"--')#3$)#.$##$1%"#$%+ =+  ,$($12'&$(#,$-$#'#')$1 ;$1$%'(-$)($%;'#,%61')0#,$-15"#')2'%$1%$1%"#$%+ ==+,$ -$#'#')$1"(("'.$%#,$("'%1%$15:'.')0  =++')#,'( 61#9;,'&,;"(%'(3'(($%)> ==,$1$"#$19#,$-$#'#')$1'.$% ?$##$1 "#$)#--$".==9;,'&,;"(;'#,%1";))= == 

88 ,$"&##,$3"##$1'(#,"##,$-$#'#')$1;"(1$')(#"#$%) = == ,'(&"($,"(&,$@6$1$%,'(#1:,$1'56)".5:;":')#$1'31%$1,"% ".(%'1$&#$% #,$ 65.'&/$12'&$33'((')#&)2$)$ $2'$;

/$.$&#')33'##$$9;,'&,;"(,$.%)



 ,$&"($#,$-$#'#')$1;"(&)('%$1$%"(-$1#,$
)%'")

.'&$/$12'&$ --')#3$)#5: 13#')! $06."#')(9=>> ')(,1#9 $06."#')(4! $;"()#6)%'#1-13#')')#,$($.$&#').'(# ==8=>,$-$#'#')$1,"%$"1.'$1'.$% 88 &,"..$)0')0 ')"&#')#,$1$(-)%$)#(;,'&,;"(;'#,%1";))     ,$1$"#$1  #,$  -$#'#')$1  '.$%      88   ($$A')0 ..;')01$.'$*8 '!C6"(,')0#,$'3-60)$%1%$1%"#$%   )$D61$8 !E

''!%'1$&#')0#,$1$(-)%$)#(#&)('%$1#,$&."'3(#,$ "--.'&")#1-13#')#
)%'") .'&$/$12'&$')#$13(
)%'") .'&$/$12'&$

$&16'#3$)#! 6.$(9=>1#,$($.$&# .'(#==8=E

'''!%'1$&#')0#,$1$(-)%$)#(#&)('%$1#,$&."'3(#,$ "--.'&")#1-13#')#
)%'") .'&$/$12'&$')#$13(
)%'") .'&$/$12'&$

$&16'#3$)#! 6.$(9=>E

'2!%'1$&#')0#,$1$(-)%$)# 65.'&/$12'&$33'((') #  "--')#  #,$  "--.'&")#  #  #,$ 
)%'")  .'&$  /$12'&$  5:

"&&1%')0#,'3#,$("3$:$"1"..#3$)#"(,'(5"#&,3"#$( '$==9')$&$(("1:5:%'1$&#')0&3-.'")&$')#$13(#,$ 1%$1#,$)45.$'0,61#)1$&1%"())$D61$8 ")%8

2!%'1$&#')0#,$1$(-)%$)#

/#,.%1$2'$;($.$&#') &33'##$$3$$#')0 1#,$ :$"1(..;')0 ==8=> %61')0 ;,'&,-13#')##,$
)%'") .'&$/$12'&$,"(5$$)3"%$ 13#,$/#"#$&"%1$F

88 ,$.$"1)$%1'56)".,"(%'(3'(($%#,$1'0')"."--.'&"#')5: ,.%')0#,"##,$&."'3#,$-$#'#')$11(65($@6$)#:$"1(;"(5"11$%5: &)(#16&#'2$1$(76%'&"#"(')&$#,$-$#'#')$1,"%)#-61(6$% 8 8 #'#(.0'&".$)%?$"1)$%1'56)".')-"1"01"-,,"(1$$11$% #,"##,$-$#'#')$1')"&#,"(-1":$%#,"#,'(&"($5$&)('%$1$%13== =#'..

$%)#0"#,$1'#13#,$-.$"%')0(#,$-"1#'$( 1$(,1%$1;"(".(-"(($%"#$1'.')0 88 ;,'&,#,$ -$#'#')$1,"("(("'.$%')  88 %"#$%



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

$(-)%$)#&6.%)#-1$(63$#,"##,$-$#'#')$1;"()#$.'0'5.$1 ')%6&#')<')&.6(')1
/"%1$,$%$&'(')&6.%5$#"A$)".)$5:#,$

65.'&/$12'&$33'((') &&1%')0.:9#,$;1'#-$#'#')'("..;$%,$'3-60)$%1%$1 %"#$% '(($#"('%$ $(-)%$)#'(%'1$&#$%#($)%#,$&"($ #,$-$#'#')$11')%6&#')<')&.6(')')#,$($.$&#').'(#
/"%1$1 #,$:$"1== 8=#'..

;'#,')"-$1'%#,1$$3)#,(

88

$(-)%$)#8 65.'&/$12'&$ 33'((')'(".( %'1$&#$%#%#,$)$$%6.;'#,')"-$1'%('D3)#,(13#,$%"#$ 1$&$'-#1$&1%131$(-)%$)#

 "7'2/,"13"!

6%0$  "1')%$1/')0,/'%,6!

 + 6%0$ %')$(, ,$#,$1(-$"A')0<1$"()$% $(<  ,$#,$1 $-1#"5.$* $(<