M/S Vardaraj Buildcom Pvt. Ltd. And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

(1)




   
  

!"# $%#$&'#("#)*#$ + ,-.!$%!$!/ 012%345"6"%!4%"7#$- 8#"1"14#$- .#$-0- '"!"# !$9!4!!4%"7#$- 8#-(4%#4"-
 


   


  $#-#4"& '7$1 !-71-7
7($!+ %53!"#+ $"7#(#"1"14#$- -!21:!4;!+ +!$9!4!+

$$#-(4%#4"- !4%< 4# $$#-(4%#4" 


7#"7#$#($"#$- 23!2(!(#$-)!9*#!22=#%"-##"7# /0%;)#4"->


*#$# #$$#%""7##($"#$-$4"> <
7#"7#$"7#/0%;)#4"-702%*#$#($"#%14"7#1;#-">   
7!22#4;# 14 "7# ($#-#4" =$1" (#"1"14 1- " "7# 4"1 13!"14-%!"#%  !4%?@  (0*21-7#%04%#$'#3"14- !4%    "7# 6!4% 3A01-1"14 3"+ @?  $ -7$" B"7# 3"C+ 4 !3304"   (#$!"14   '#3"14    "7#  1;7" " !1$
)(#4-!"14 !4% $!4-(!$#439 14 6!4% 3A01-1"14+ #7!*121"!"14 !4%#-#""2#)#4" 3"+ 3" $-7$"B"7# 3"C 7# (#"1"14#$- 32!1) " *# =4#$- 14 (--#--14  2!4%-!1%"7!5#*##4(0$37!-#%*9"7#)51%#-#(!$!"#-!2#%##%-4 %1

#$#4" %!"#- 1# (#"1"14#$   4 <  D <<  D E<  !4% ?   D (#"1"14#$   4

  !4% (#"1"14#$ < 4

<@  D    !4% ?    70-+ !22 "7# -!2# %##%-  !$# !

"#$ "7# (0*213!"14   "7# 4"1 13!"14 04%#$ '#3"14    3"

(2)

"#$ "7# %#32!$!"14 04%#$ '#3"14   3"+  "7# !=!$% =!- !44043#% *9 "7# 6!4% 3A01-1"14
22#3"$ 4 E

  7# (0$(-# !3A01-1"141-%#5#2()#4"!4%0"121F!"14 "7#2!4% $ $#-1%#4"1!2!4%3))#$31!2-#3"$-!%/1414;"7#($(-#% )#"$#- $!%!"#=!$17#(#"1"14#$--0*)1""#%!$#($#-#4"!"14 $$#2#!-# "7#2!4%14"7#9#!$ <+=7137=!-4"!33#("#%+"7#$# $#+"7# (#"1"14#$-145:#%"7#=$1"/0$1-%13"14 "71-
0$" 4 "7# =$1""#4 -"!"#)#4"+ "7# $#-(4%#4"- 7!5# /0-"1 1#% "7# !3A01-1"14 ($3##%14;- (14"14; 0" "7!" "7# 213#43#   2!4% )#!-0$14; <

?!3$#-7!-*##4;$!4"#%""7#(#"1"14#$-!4%"7# 34-"$03"#% !$#! 

@  !3$#-   2!4%   "7# (#"1"14#$- 7!- *##4 $#2#!-#% !

"#$ */#3"14- 04%#$ '#3"14 G   3"  7# 6!4%

3A01-1"14
22#3"$+ !44043#% "7# !=!$%   "7# 2!4% )#!-0$14;

??  !3$#-  " 1- 0$"7#$ (14"#% 0" "7!" 14 "7# 21;7"  ($51-14-34"!14#%14'#3"14  3"+"7#(!9)#4" 3)(#4-!"14 1- $#A01$#% " *# )!%# " "7# )!/$1"9   "7# 2!4% 72%14;-!4%4""#!37 "7#2!4%=4#$-"1- 0$"7#$(2#!%#%"7!" "7# (--#--14 7!- *##4 7!4%#% 5#$ " "7#   51%# !(!" F4!)37!E<4@  +*0""7#!)04" 3)(#4-!"14 7!-4"*##4%#(-1"#%14"7## #$#43#
0$"!-"7#=4#$-7!5# 4" 3))0413!"#% "7#1$ 14"#4" " "7#  6!4% 3A01-1"14
22#3"$ " $#3#15#"7#-!)# =#5#$+ %0$14; "7# 30$-#   7#!$14;+ "7# 2#!$4#% 304-#2 $ "7# $#-(4%#4"- 7!- $!1-#% ! ($#21)14!$9 */#3"14 "7!" "7# (#"1"14#$- !$# (0$37!-#$-   "7# 2!4% !

"#$ (0*213!"14  4"1 13!"14 04%#$ '#3"14   3" !4% "70-+ "7# (#"1"14#$- 3!44" %1-(0"# "7# !3A01-1"14 ($3##%14;-   !4% "7#9 3!44" 32!1) *#4#  '#3"14   3"  # #$#43#  1- )!%# " "7# 151-14 #437 /0%;)#4"-   "71-
0$" 14 ,- !"14!2 !3:14;

(3)

4%0-"$1#- 5 '"!"#   !$9!4! !4% "7#$-+
  <   %#31%#% 4 @@ D  !/15 H0)!$ 5 '"!"#   !$9!4! !4% "7#$-+
 @ %#31%#%4 @@  4 "7# "7#$ 7!4%+ 2#!$4#% 304-#2 $ "7# (#"1"14#$- 7!-$#21#%0(4')"H!)2!#51!4%"7#$-5'"!"# !$9!4!!4% "7#$-+
  <     %#31%#% 4 ?

 !4% 6;13!2 #5#2(#$-5"6"%!4%"7#$-5'"!"# !$9!4!!4%"7#$-+
  E <%#31%#%4< < #21!43#1-!2-(2!3#%0(4 "7# /0%;)#4"   "7# 4C*2# '0($#)#
0$" 14 414   4%1! 5 '715$!/ !4% "7#$-+    '

 D 151-14 #437 /0%;)#4"-  "7# #271 1;7
0$" 14 !4/!4! 7!"1!  5 5" 
   #271+   6 <ED,-'9#'"0

4%0-"$1#-5414 4%1! !4%"7#$-+
@E?@, %#31%#%4? !4%,- !-!:"1 -"!"#- 5" 6"% 5 414   4%1! !4% "7#$-+ 


E,  %#31%#%4   # 7!5# 7#!$% 2#!$4#% 304-#2 $ "7# (!$"1#- !4% 14% "7!" "7# (#"1"14#$- 3!44" *# (#$)1""#% " %1-(0"# "7# !3A01-1"14 ($3##%14;-14320%14;"7#32!1)04%#$'#3"14  3"14 51#= !3""7!""7#(#"1"14#$-!$#(0$37!-#$- "7#2!4%!

"#$ (0*213!"14 "7#4"1 13!"1404%#$'#3"14 3"7#4C*2# '0($#)#
0$"7!-1440)#$0-/0%;)#4"-+!2-#I!)14#%"7#$1;7" "7#(0$37!-#$ "7#2!4%"%1-(0"#"7#!3A01-1"14($3##%14;- 4 '4#7 $!*7! 5 '"!"#   + ??

E '

 

+ "7# 4C*2# '0($#)#
0$"  %#3214#% " ;$!4"  *#4#  $#7!*121"!"14+ =7#4"7#
0$"7#2%""7# 22=14;#

#3"&G J  70;7 !" "7# 1$-" *20-7+ =# =#$# 143214#% " !;$## =1"7 "7# !((#22!4" *0" 4 %##(#$ ($*#+ =# 14% "7!" "7# !((#22!4" 1- 4" #4"1"2#% " "7# *#4# 6!4% 2139 " 1- -#""2#% 2!= "7!" !49 (#$-4 =7 (0$37!-#- 2!4% !

"#$ (0*213!"14   "7# 4"1 13!"14

(4)

04%#$ '#3"14 + %#- - !" 71-,7#$ =4 (#$12 7# */#3" (0*213!"14 "7#4"1 13!"1404%#$'#3"14 1-4"13#"#5#$94#"7!""7#2!4%1-4##%#%$1-21:#29 " *# 4##%#% $ (0*213 (0$(-# !4% "7# !3A01-1"14 ($3##%14;- (14"- 0" !4 1)(#%1)#4" " !494# " #430)*#$ "7# 2!4% !3A01$#% "7#$#G04%#$ " !0"7$1F#- "7# %#-1;4!"#% 

13#$ " #4"#$ 0(4 "7# 2!4% " % ($#21)14!$1#-#"37#$# $#+!49!21#4!"14 2!4%!

"#$ "7#(0*213!"14 "7#4"1 13!"1404%#$'#3"14%#- 4" *14% "7# 5#$4)#4" $ "7# *#4# 131!$9 04%#$ "7# !3A01-1"144"!:14;(--#--14 "7#2!4%+!22$1;7"-+ "1"2#- !4% 14"#$#-"- 14 2!4% -"!4% 5#-"#% 14 "7# '"!"#+ 04%#$'#3"14

3"+ $## $)!22#430)*$!43#- !4% "7#$#*9 !*-20"# "1"2# 14 "7# 2!4% 1- !3A01$#% "7#$#04%#$ !49-0*-#A0#4"(0$37!-#$!3A01$#-2!4%+ 71-,7#$429$1;7"=02%*#-0*/#3"""7#($51-14- "7# 3"!4%,$"$#3#15#3)(#4-!"14 $"7#2!4%4 !$#3#4"/0%;)#4"+"71-
0$"14414 4%1!5-'7$1 '715:0)!$ 7!$;!5!  $- K  ??    '
 EL 34-1%#$#%"7#34"$5#$-9!4%7#2%"7!"!(#$-4=7 (0$37!-#- 2!4% -0*-#A0#4" " "7# 4"1 13!"14 1- 4" #4"1"2#%"!2"#$4!"15#-1"#"1--##4"7!""7#6!4%2139 #I($#--2934 #$$#%"7!"$1;7"4294"7!"(#$-4=7-# 2!4%=!-!3A01$#%4"7#$=$%-+"7#(#$-4)0-"*# "7#=4#$ "7#2!4%4"7#%!"#4=71374"1 13!"14 04%#$ '#3"14  =!- (0*21-7#%

9 4#3#--!$9 1)(213!"14+"7#-0*-#A0#4"(0$37!-#$=!-#2*=#%0"

$)"7#(2139!4%*#3!)#%1-#4"1"2#%""7#*#4# 1" "7#6!4%2139M 4 !/!-"7!4 '"!"# 4%0-"$1!2 #5#2()#4" !4% 45#-")#4"
$($!"14 5 '0*7!-7 '14%71
(#$!"15# 0-14; '31#"9+ !1(0$ !4% "7#$-+  <  '

  E+ "7# !3A01-1"14 ($3##%14;- =#$# 37!22#4;#% *9 "7# '31#"9  ! "#$ (0$37!-#  2!4%+!

"#$(0*213!"14 "7#4"1 13!"1404%#$'#3"14 3" 7#
0$"7#2%""7# 22=14;#

#3"&G J < 7#$#3!4*#4A0!$$#2=1"7$#-(#3"""7# -#""2#%2#;!2($(-1"14"7!"!(0$37!-#$+-0*-#A0#4" ""7#1--0!43# !'#3"14"1 13!"1414$#-(#3"   "7#  2!4%+  3!44"  37!22#4;#   "7# !3A01-1"14

(5)

($3##%14;-+ !4% 3!4 429 32!1) 3)(#4-!"14 !-  "7# -!2# "$!4-!3"14 14 -037 ! -1"0!"14 1- .1% A0! "7# 5#$4)#4" 49-037#430)*$!43#3$#!"#%*9"7# =4#$+$!49"$!4- #$ "7#2!4%14A0#-"14+"7!" 1- )!%# !

"#$ "7#  1--0!43#     -037  !  4"1 13!"14+ =02%*#%##)#%"*#51%!4%=02%4"*#*14%14; 4 "7# 5#$4)#4"  
 

      




  !

 "  # #$ % & #

'(%)

* +  , - # ' # #.  /

 0  "  1#. +    
)

 1# .+  , - # ' # #.+   ,  #/ +  
2

3 / 

 4 #

#  $, 
**  

 22  0  !   
,  5. 4  / -


, 5.4%
**3





 6    '

  7  '- # #  $$1  +7*


)* II II II

 7#  $#-(4%#4"  -31#"9  7!-  (2!3#%  $#21!43# 0(45!$10-(2131#- "7#5#$4)#4"+=7137!22=#% "7##I#)("14 2!4%0(4=713734-"$03"14#I1-"#% 4"7#%!"# 1--0!43# '#3"14"1 13!"144 "7#14-"!4"3!-#+"7#$#-(4%#4"-31#"9#4"#$#%14" !4!;$##)#4""-#22+-0*-#A0#4"""7#1--0!43# '#3"14  "1 13!"14+ !4% "7#$# $#+ "7# A0#-"14    "7##I1-"#43# !4934-"$03"144"7#-!1%2!4%*9 !49   1"- )#)*#$-  4  "7#  %!"#    '#3"14  "1 13!"14 %#- 4" !$1-#  7# !

$#-!1% (2139 %#31-14 "7#$# $#+ )0-" *#1)(2#)#4"#%+ =712# -"$13"29 !%7#$14; "  "7#  "#$)- 143$($!"#% "7#$#14+  !-  7!- *##47#2%*9"71-
0$"148  % - 9 -. 58 " , - #' # #.+  E'



?4"7#-!1%3!-#+"71-
0$"#I!)14#% "7# 1--0#    %1-3$1)14!"14=1"7 $#-(#3" " $#2#!-14; 2!4% *#24;14; " 4# -#"    14"#$#-"#% (#$-4-+ =712# $#/#3"14;"7#$#2#!-# 2!4%*#24;14;""7#$-1)12!$29 -1"0!"#%(#$-4-+=7-#2!4% =!-  -1"0!"#%  14 32-# 513141"9""7#2!4%$#2#!-#%M # 7!5# 7#!$% 2#!$4#% 304-#2 $ "7# (!$"1#- !4% 14% "7!""7#(#"1"14#$-+=7!$#"7#(0$37!-#$- 2!4%!

"#$(0*213!"14

(6)

"7#4"1 13!"1404%#$'#3"14 3"!$#4""7#2!4%=4#$-

$=7-#*#4# 1"-"7#($51-14- '#3"14  < 3"+ 7!5#*##4#4!3"#%7#(#"1"14#$-7!5#(0$37!-#%"7#2!4% $"7# (0$(-#-   -#""14; 0(   ! 3249 $# "7!4

 !3$#-   2!4% (0$37!-#%*9"7#(#"1"14#$-7!-*##4$#2#!-#% $)!3A01-1"14!4% ! 2134#3# $ "7# 2!4% )#!-0$14; <

? !3$#-  7!- !2- *##4 ;$!4"#%7#(#"1"14#$-7!5#(0$37!-#%"7#2!4%=1"7"7#1$#9#-=1%# (#4"7!""7#2!4%1--0*/#3")!""#$ !3A01-1"147#97!5#"!:#4! 3!2302!"#% $1-: 7# (#"1"14#$- 7!5# 4" %1-(0"#% "7# !3A01-1"14 ($3##%14;- $ E 9#!$- !

"#$ "7# !=!$% =!- !44043#% 7# ($51-14-  3" !$# $ "7# *#4#  "7# 2!4% =4#$-+ =7-#2!4%7!-4"*##4(0""0-# $!(#$1%  9#!$-!

"#$"7# !4404314; !=!$%7#(#"1"14#$-+"7#(0$37!-#$- "7#2!4%!$# 4""7#"122#$- 2!4%*0"7!-(0$37!-#%($(#$"9429=1"7!51#=" %#5#2(3249 $"7#1$($ 1")"15# 4 "7# 21;7"   "7# /0%;)#4"-   "7# 4C*2# '0($#)#
0$" 14 '4#7 $!*7!C- 3!-# -0($! !4% !/!-"7!4 '"!"# 4%0-"$1!2 #5#2()#4"!4%45#-")#4"
$($!"14C-3!-#-0($!+=# 14%"7!" "7# (#"1"14#$- 7!5# 4 $1;7" " %1-(0"# "7# !3A01-1"14 ($3##%14;- #5#4 04%#$ '#3"14   3" 7# (#"1"14#$- 3!4 429 32!1)3)(#4-!"14 $"7#!3A01$#%2!4% 4 '715$!/C- 3!-# -0($!+ "7# 1--0# !- " =7#"7#$  "7# (0$37!-#$7!-!$1;7""%1-(0"#"7#32!1) *#4# 1"04%#$'#3"14

 3"+=!-4"-(#31 13!229$!1-#%$%#31%#%=#5#$+14
1512 ((#!2  <E  ? 414   4%1! 5 ##"! #51+ "7# -0*-#A0#4"(0$37!-#$=!-;$!4"#%*#4# 1" 4434-1%#$!"14 */#3"14- 12#%*9"7#$1;14!22!4%=4#$04%#$'#3"14 

3"  '143# -037 1--0# 7!- 4" *##4 #I!)14#%+ =# % 4" 14% "7!" -037/0%;)#4"($51%#-!49!--1-"!43#""7#(#"1"14#$-

(7)

=#5#$+!151-14 #437 "71-
0$"/0%;)#4"14,- !"14!2 !3:14; 4%0-"$1#-C 3!-# -0($!+ 7!- 34-1%#$#% "7# ($51-14-   '#3"14   3" !4% 4#;!"#% "7# *#4# -037($51-14-""7#(#"1"14#$"7#$#147#151-14 #4377#2%" "7# 22=14;#

#3"&G J < 7# (#"1"14#$ =7 ;" #I#30"#% "7# 6#!-# ##% !

"#$1--0!43# '#3"144"1 13!"14!4%"7#-G3!22#% '!2# ##% 14 "7# 9#!$ ??  )037 !

"#$ (!--14; "7#

=!$%+ "70-+ 7!- 4 230-G-"!4%1 " A0#-"14 "7# !3A01-1"14 ($3##%14;- )037 2#-- " 32!1) "7# *#4# 1" 04%#$ 3" $#-73!0-# !3"147!-!33$0#%" "7#(#"1"14#$43)14;14" $3# 3" (#$-4 3!4 *# (#$)1""#% " 31$30)5#4" "7# 2!= 14 "7# )!44#$-0;;#-"#%*9"7#(#"1"14#$*9"$914;"145:# )1-(2!3#%-9)(!"79 II II II

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

"#$ 34-1%#$14; "7# /0%;)#4" 14 ')" H!)2! #51C- 3!-# -0($! !- =#22 "7# /0%;)#4" 14 ,- ' 9# '"0

 4%0-"$1#-C 3!-# -0($! '"122

0$"7#$+ "7# /0%;)#4"- 14  !4/!4! 7!"1!C- 3!-# -0($! !4% ,-

!-!:"1 -"!"#- 5" 6"%C- 3!-# -0($!+ !$# 4 "7# -1)12!$ 214#-  4 '041"! '!7$!=!" !4% "7#$- 5 '"!"#   !$9!4!+
 

 

%#31%#%4 ?  !4!$;0)#4"=!-$!1-#%";$!4"*#4# 1"

(8)

'#3"14  3"""7#(0$37!-#$-+*0"-037A0#-"14 =!-4"%#31%#%+=71371-#51%#4" $)!$#!%14; (!$!  $%#$ 451#= "7#!*5#+=# 14%"7!""7#(#"1"14#$-*#14;"7# 3241F#$-!4%-0*-#A0#4"(0$37!-#$-!$#4"#4"1"2#%""7#*#4# 1" '#3"14  3"
4-#A0#4"29+"7#($#-#4"=$1"(#"1"141- %1-)1--#%

   !

"#$%!  ! '#("#)*#$ + %-