High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/27214/2016dismissed

Dr Deepak Kapur v. Union Of India & ORS.

2017-11-27Mr Justice Jaswant Singh13 pages

!" #$$

% &'()*+,-./*((%+%.&/

!"#

$

% ## # &

'( )

$ * % ##

++ ,','',%-./

0((12 $ (3 +4 # )5.

6472# %8,%',%-./

0((12

( 0/

#

+,%,8',,- (%,(',,9

# # ' "

+ $ ( 3 4 ,*,*',,-

+ ,%,8',,: ( 4; + ',,< #

+# #

+ #

4 # +

; (,,%',,94 / 0

#

-+ '8,(',,9

#+

; + +

# 4=

$ + &

; ,%,*',,9 4 +

,%,*',%,

>0 ##

; ,*%'',%, # 4// 0

# / + (%,(',%%

+ # ,%,*',%,? 4 + ,%%,',,9 # # + + 4 / 4=

%<,<',,9

+ ,%,%',,-! /

+

@

+,%,%',,-

,%%,',,9A 7 @ 4 /

4= ++ + ,','',%-

# # # %8,%',%- #

# # ++ A ! .=2 ; ,','',%-# ++ %8,%',%- 4 ## 47 ++ ,','',%-%8,%',%-

4 * $ + '(%'',%-4#

#

7 44 )5

4

& ++

#+ #

#

4 + #+

8 B

#

+

## 4 )50( #& ++ ,','',%-%8,%',%-./

0((1 0((1 +0 ( / %<,<',,9 #

4= # ,%,%',,- @ # #

%<,<',,9

+,%,%',,-

+ (

,%,*',%,

7# + +

; 4

+

+ #

&

; 4

#

# (

/ 4= ,%,%',,-

#

;

# ; 4

#

+#

#

+

!"#$%"& '((#"

)'*

$

+

# +

#''-.'2

# #

7

+# 7

+ 4 )5+

#

#

4 )5 ; 4

34)5 +#

##

+ + - #

#

+ # )5)5

4)5 )5 ( 3 4 )5 ## = #+# @ +#+ ( 3 4 )54

( 34)54 #

( 04)5

+ ;

##+

## ( 04)5 @ # (

4

+

+ #

: #

# < ?

# ( 34 )5 0( +##

C? ##

#

D 9 4 (

# +4 # )5 B! = #

%9<,

!

$ A# ,8,*%9-- 4=

#

+4 # .42 %:,-%9<(

4)5

)5

%,

+ 4

+ # +

##

& #

##

+

#

#

1 +

E

#+

0++ & +

# E

+

@ # #1 + ## ++ # %%

#

5 # ' #

#''-.'2

+ = # #

+ #

+ #

## & #

# %' #''-

##

##+

F #

#/ G

# /

H

#

+

+ + G

H # #+#+ +#

#

%(

+

#''- .%2 .'2 0 !"# $% "& '& " ()*'

+% " , )) +

*

## * ! & $

$()*

$ $ #% " &&' * $

)'

# & ,& * - %* #''- + #

# ' # ' 0 , & +$ .

#& $()*# $ * $ + +$ $ % " ' & & #&$

# &#& ()* $

& 4 +++

# #

#''-

# .'2

##

)

+

)

+

?

)

+

#

#

& + # .%02 0 + G'H # ''-

& ##

#

,

/ G H

#

%9,<"

+ G # #

#

H

# +

+

G H +

#

#

+

/ -#". , ,

/ 0 1,4 #

/

#

; 4 )5 4

# .'2 #''-#

##

7 # /

# ( 34

)5

# )5/ + # +# 3; +&

+ +#

+# ( 34)5 + #

I # # (

#&)

+ 1 ; #4

!"#$%2" #$ #

+

& #)

+E 5 # ;

4

#+ ;

#

&##

%8 3 ."%%"""&4 !3%"3

$

+

# @

+ # # +

++ # +

+

#

/ *

*

* "

) $ "

&

H . $ <2 %- 7#

+

$# *"" $5-4##"

1,+ $ # +

# #

# 4 #

(3 ."%%"". 2

+

<# 0, &1&)

& * ! " * * )

0

+

) 63" %&#"7()#8"

8796##69#4"#"0((#

$

#+ ' 2 3 # # % " "

) ' & +$' , 1&

#& & +

#)

) )

"

& )' , + & *

& 4$+ & "

5+ *#% " "

* ) '& +$ 1

3 $ + ' & + $ *)"

% "

& ' " $ &

"

% " & $ + 0

+

& '( ( #"8")( 9:4"0((#

$+ #

+ # ##

+

%:

+

;#: #40(" <=:$5 %

1$ , # 0 # * &

+ "

$ * +$& ) "

# # "

% " ' & )& $ +$ )6 + )& +) #& ++* 0 %< )=(3 "& '(

)'* 1 1

>3 + # & '(""5 '(3"#"

1, $

#

6J7# 3 6K7# 6K7

&

6J7#

E 6J7# #

#

#

# "

# + #

E !# # # "5 '(3"#"

+

#

# ##

+

# ## %?#-0("$3=" <% ?#"

$

+

G #

+HG

+ H+##

+ #+ +

+##

+ +

+ /

&

+ # 6$6366"?#5

6=$5#7

)'*

(0 (

)'* 1 1+ -6 0("

; -#" ($6#0(

11 $$

"& '(

<

+#5 <@"0("& '(

)'* ?# %9

++ #

++ +# 3; ( 34)5

# # 1 +

&

7

#3

F

/+#+# ( 4+#$ +&

+4+#$

&

+# +# #

# #)5 ', +# ;

;

& # ''-.'2

#

#

@ ( 34)5 /

0((1 0((1 ,','',%- %8,%',%-

#

( 34)5

/ 1

# %<,<',,9

4=# ,%,%',,-

# 4=#

0((!1!"2$3

& +45 ? 1& K ?

# K