Union Of India And Others v. No 3379785 P Ex Naik (Ts) Shamsher Singh
!" #$%$!&!&'
! "
#
$% (' )*( ++
+ ,
)*( +* , &%'() " * +*,*- *./.
0+$1 +
+ ,
-.
*/ 3 +&+ + * 4 $- + $ + $*(0+&*%0+%%*%5363563 783! *$*%'(+.*%,%9 '*.99%-4+'( + $% 4* &*% + '0 0 %& 00- + 0 9,$&+%*'.(.,:8*8:%*'.($
# 0 1 #234!0&5 5
$%34*..%+,(363 *%4*%9+*&%0,:940663/;+ %9+*& 0, + :9- + $% 4* &*% 0..4& %*'.('0*.&4++%
!
""# ! $
% & +$%0.%-'0+ '*.99% *+0+&*0'00'*%'*%&1%&00%*'.( .,0,56< 6<0+$%,%*': +*% *$$.9*4**..4%:%%%*%5363563 783! +$*:$*0+*%%7*9%+*0
!"
!
# $ ! %
& &
' (!
! # )
* )+ ,
- & ./ = .& *&&:% 0, + *0 %- + $8 0%*+*0.%+*&*+*4$ +067$%%$!&%!" 8 1 4& 5#!0&% 1"!4 8 9 $ $!& 4%
+-+.*%9.0+$8 0%*0+% !0:*>%&,'(+ ?'. $7/-4+'(-
0+',+*:40
$ +7$.*0.*4,*%+-+.*% '*.99% +.%+*:9%+&*0**+$%0+ (* @ *..(-*09;%',*%$**&*$+ *%@0+:%9%%'(+ ?'.$7/9* .%* '
( )****
+(
#,-.+/ )$ $
0 1 2" 3 4 !- #"-%9%%36 566 +*%$**&*$+ *%@ '9,7*9%+*0 ( % & + 0 &
- & . - &
) +% & .1'
&
& 2 +
&
+ 3 & & & & & 0& 4& '
'
+
+ +
"
&&
5 '
& "'
4& ++
&
&
6
7& +
& 6 &
+ ) 7& 8&
7&
9
9
& 7&
% 8&
0&
9
& +
+
& +
& & / *%&0$**&*$+ 0+:%9 $*!9.*.( %9+0*9+*9**(9.*,+'(+:90%.*( *%.*9+-+.,*.(*009&+*$$:%%0*'. &+;*+*,($.-'.*&.($*(,807* 0 $*( $- +'(- + *% %.*(% 9.*,- *+ +* '9,&*&+4*(>9%-+-;%'*..4%-'4+ *0+*+**0$'&9%$*$%0+ (*$+%*00.&0+4$
+*%9*$**&*$+@+0-+$7/ %9.*%+*+ &+/4*>0%%9+.*0 **0$9:&*$%03@(**%+*4+ +*%:4*.*$$*+*:'*99$%* >%&,'*& '
( )
+(
#,-. + '
/)
/ -"
' 30 1 2" 5
+.:*$**&*$+4+0* 7*9%+*0
*
&
&
& % +
&+ 3 & &
1
"
!" , , 6 "!
" "
"
, #
,"
% 8& '
& +&
& +
& &
8&
&
& && , '#
7 #"
!" "
2 3
+'
:
8& & &
%
&
+067$%%$!&%!" 8 1 4& 5#!0&% 1"!4 8 4 %9!&5 & 36 +++*%-+.*%9.0+$% ',+*+*0*%>%&,**$$.9*'.+* 9*- * + ,,' 0 + %09 9,'** *'.+, 4* *.*%(9$0+%*'.($*%+*+%4,0 +*$$'0+9+&+,*A&0%& !00-+ 4.%.(.*>0*'.9*$
33 $$0+*&,-+$.*9%.*9*+ B%& C9+ >%&, $*% '( + ?'. $7 /- 566563@-9*.%* :$&5 4+$&38;% &$!&!"&5$ &5 8 4%-4+9+ $:$199 1! !" *&% + .:*$**&*$+0+*%:%9*7*9%+*0 % & 1
) 5 % & * 4 8 1);
&9%% &
+
&0 0& &
+ % &
& '''' ''''
2
% & '
% & < =:
&
&
9 $ !
&0 0& & +
2 &
+
9
; /
&" 4 &# %!" 8$%!04 35 +&+-:'.(9**(%.*(%,*%'(+ *&&:%4+'(*9+*..&9*%*%9.&%$*% '(+99%-+$-+*&0*%.*(%,',*A +*,'+'(+:90%.*(*%.*9+ 4:-+ 79$+*':$9$.-*.%+&+:%99%%'( +$7/9*.%*0 1 2" 34 !
- #"+, /*%9*.%*-"
' 30 1 2" +, /5+*-(+%09$.99%-'9,& .%807*0$:8*8:+,-'4+*0+% +*+*%'9%.(0*$%0+(*0,+ %*00.&0+$ 3 C+**,*(-*0+79$:+$* 7*9%$**&*$+-*99+:%9 $*!%%'(+ $7/-+7-+*9**%0*'.&+'9, :%+*&&:%-+$-+*%:,0*%0*'. &++*&&:%-+4.%0.*9&*9 9* 0 *9 :8*8: + *&&:% .*.(- +'( + %.*(%*&0*9.*,-+4.%**9+*++'* 0.,*+'(*($$%:90%.*(*%.*9+ 4.%009:.(09**,'.&'.9A*&*+&*&0 +0...0+*&&:% 3= %,&4+++9*0*94+9+*99% :8*8:+$$%+4**9&*9
9*0*9'%0%,&4++*+:(9$- *%0*'.&+:%+$$%-+'(- 9*('*,%+0*9,+*-+.:*9*0*9 *99%+$$%-$-+,*A&0*:%9'(+
?'.$7/9*.%*) &$!&!"&5$ ;%
7:
4?- $% + &1$& <-%9%%3635563=-4+- *%9.**,*%+7-+*+'00%&00- *+ +* '9, %4% + 99% + .:* $**&*$+*99+:%9 $*!*7*9%+*0
4 - . 7& +&
& & & & &
& + + &"
% - . &
8 & ; - .6 6>-?"8.
& @ > A+
#
+ ) 5
? + & +
) 5 ? + (2 + & 92 &0&- .
- . &"
%
3 8&
% &
+0-9+*%%0*'.&+'9*,:% +$$%-$-+,*A&0+:%9'(+$7 /-9*.%* ) &$!&!"&5$ ;%
7:
4.%094 / ;.-+%9.**0.*4,*%+:%9 $*!-4+% *009:&+'9,%4%:8*8:+99%-+ ':% .*.(-+%4,0+*%&+-:8*8:+ 99%- + '9, + 9 0 + +0, %,&- 4++ $,$ ;. + *+ + $ $%*%*9.*,-*%-*%,+4+ 3@
9 + :%9 $*! '9*, $9% 3635563=*%+$%*%,0+*%:%9-+* ,'0+ '*.99%-+(*563 +&+-+ $%,0+:%9 $*!%%**$,$, $*9+-'*%*,.(*0*%.*(0*'= (**A&$.*9 4:-4++%4,,*%+% :8*8:+$$%-'**..(90%*%0*'. &+;*+, +0-4++%0*'.&+:%+ $$%*++&+:%9 $*!'99,*.( *.90%*9*%9&9*0*9;*+ $$% .*.(*.+%*%0*'.&+
'9*, :% + $ $% 0 + A& ;* + *$$%&00'&,*%+0*: 3
: +4 9 + %9.** 0 .*4 ,*% :%9 $*!,*A+*%%9.**'*7$.*0.*4 ,-+'(-+7$.*0.*4,-*,*%:%9 $*!*.,*A++%90%'0:8*8:+ %09 $. 99%- -
- *. . + 99%-+**(,A+&*&0+%4,* ,*%+%-*%+*-+0..9,$.,-*$. +%-'%$9:0+'*0%.*(*%.*9+
$& 1 45 4!" 8$%!04 *0,*+-+/0%,+4$ *% 4+ + ':* *0*%- + *, %,% + ,$&%%,**%*%*00,% 3
9+,*9*.0+*'%9%%-+-*..+ $%&*$$.9* !-0*(-*.*% !%$%0 .+
+ ,
/ .* ,/
A*:&+ 8 8 4%9 2$&3=4 %!& 5 '
%=!
8 8 44 9!4 '
%=!