Joginder Pal v. Union Of India And ORS.
!"#"$% ! &' ( )
*% +,* -
-
-
!
# $
!
-
- ) % & ' ( )* +) )+,)- . /0" &'# !# ' # &# !
)) +1 )+,) - . 20
+3 ,, )+,)- . 30" &'
&# % "
4 5)6 +) ,**) "
)2 +7 )+,, ,2/+ " "
8 4## 9 8 " '"
)/ +7 )+,,)2 +7 )+,, !#
! : (
'
# &
.!
&
%# "
& !4## &';
:,*+ % < != !!#
&';
:,*+ !"> ( !#'
; +7 +6 )+,, */+ !# (
&!
#:
? > ( # '
( '"
"! +6 +6 )+,, #& # ! ;! +6 +* )+,, #
( '
!,,-,04
!5 ! ! ,*2* - @,*2* !A0 " )7 4
! 5 ! ,*73 - @,*73 A0 "
"!
!
"
$"% $"% &"
'
(
)*
" + , #" "
-
./ 0 0"/ #01
20
0%
20 #"
0"/ 3#
/
' 3# 0"" '0#( # 3% 0 4%" 56
"
#(
% !
% $%"7 # 11' (
"
##"
0"/ #%
0"/ %" #1
##,%"
0
11"
$
" #
' '(
( #"
!
"%
% #"
$"%
)*
" + , #" # 11'
!
% !
%7 11"" 0 4%" 56
"
#(
% !
% $%"7 # 11' (
"
# #"
0"/ #%
0"/ %" #1
##,%"
+ 8 "
% ( " 0 0"/ #01 *%##
20
%"
20 3# #0% 1 (
"#
'
/ 3# 1 %1, 3# 0"" '0#( #
3% 0 4%" 56
"
#(
% !
% $%"7
%
0 11"
"
"
( "%
$"% &"
'
(
)*
" + , #" #
+ 0"/ 3# '"3
9 "
'
0"
"
3# # '
( 1" 3#
/
' 3# ( 1"
0%
20 3# 0"" 0# ##
1"
"# 3# (
11"
##0
# '/ 11"
1%
*1" 7 1%
*1"
1,
/ 3# 0%" "
(
#,"
"
, "
1%
*1" #01,"
20 3# 17 3% 3# 0 4%" 56
"
#(
% !
% $%"7 # 11' (
"
##"
0"/ #%
%" #1
##,%"
$
" #
' '(
( #"
!
"%
% #"
$"%
)*
" + , #" # 11'
!
% !
%7 11"" 0 4%" 56
"
#(
% !
% $%"7 (
"
# #"
0"/ #%
0"/ %" #1
##,%"
'%0#
3%
+ 8 "
% ( " 0 0"/ #01 *%##
20
%"
20 3# #0% 1 (
"#
'
/ 3# 1 %1, 3# 0"" '0#( #
3% 0 4%" 56
"
#(
% !
% $%"7
%
1"
"# 43# 3# (/
% " 3% 1,
/ 3# *1 "
(
#,"
" 1%
, "
"
3# ( 0 0"/ #01
20 3% 0 4%" 56
"
#(
% !
% $%"7
% :
0
11"
:
% ( ' ! &# )) ,) )+,,- . )0 "
!
4 , # ' !#
! )2 +7 )+,, ' & '"
'& .!
"
&
' !
) 4 # ' +7 +6 )+,, " '
?
> ( !#.! (
.!
# !
"
"
<
& <!
# &"
'
%B( ';!
#! && #"
"
' ' . !#
! "
& !
4 ) )2 +7 )+,, ,2++ ' # ,+++ ,6++ "
' &
.!
& #"
&
' !
4 )"
. +7 +6 )+,, !# .! ( "
# & & & !'( ' "
+1 +, )+,) !
# # < " ,3 ' > )/ +, )+,) " '" '
!#! > ' ( " !## '!# < &
! ( ' !#
' 4## ,*+? 4 # )* +) )+,) # # !# '
# # # ! ?
>"
& 63C
'
& ' ! 8
!
"! "
# )) +1 )+,)- . 20 % &'
"
#&'! 8
! ? ! 4
+3 ,, )+,) - . 30
. " $ !
" -0 ( ' "
!,,-,04 5 ! ,*2* " )74
!5 ! ,*73 '# # !#
!,,-,0! &# # D #!# ' # -0 % ! ' ' " # # < !! !! "!! & " #! '.
-0 % # # '
!
$ ! D## > & &'>E& #4
4 ! ,,-,0 4 5 ! ,*2*
##
#
# !!
&
> 4
!5 !& ! ! ! !# ( ' # &
/ & ! & "
'& ! ! ! & !
& ! ! > ! < " # !# ' # # !! & <&'! ' '
& !"
' ! !!
! ' '
> # # D
" ! ' !! % #$ 4
#!# ' #! & # ( '"
!,,-,0 ,*2* ! !
& !! %
' &' ! >E& # 4
4
)"
&
$ ' ,0#
4%" # 3# "
3" 1 ,0#1"
# 1,
1;
,0#1"# ,#%' ,% #%"
/# 3 11"
/
" 0" "/
%7 # 1/ ,#%'7 1/7 #0';%"
/ 0 # 1 0 $%"7 3 /
,0#1"#
/
0 11'
!
% 3
0 0 "/
# '%7 %"
0"/
1#### #%
0"/
" 1#% 0%"
%,%"/ # 11'
!
% $%%
0"
,0#1"# 3% % 3 0 "# #%" 0%" .7
7 1"
20"# 1 (
/
%
#"%"
#,%
1
01"
!
%
0
, 7 ","" %"7 '%0# #%" #/# "# ,0#1"# 1/ 3
0
" #0#,#
#1##
& 0#
#
0
" #0#,#
#1## :7 ,, #0' #%" 56
4%"
0## 56
56 # 3# 0" "# 1" " 1, 3
3 ,0#1"
#1##
#0#,#
11'
!
% 3
0 0 "/ "
0 "
,0#1"
1" 0## 56
56 1/
3 !
1/ " 4%"
$%"
1" # # 0#
0#
%#
,#%'# , "/ 3% 1/ 3
"1 4%" 3"
## 0#
%# 0# "
# 3# '#%
11'
!
% 3" 0"
(
3" 0"
#0
%"
%0#
(#"/ 3" 0"
#0
%"
%0#7
1" #
## 0#
%
#"%
1,# 1"
, (
#7 "
7 4%" 3"
" # 1 ,0#1"# 3%
1 1/ 3 ,"1"
20/ , "
1.# "
20" ,0#1"
#1##
% %" 3 "0 (
20"
, #%0"
% 0 4%"
4%" :
? ! &' $ 4 ! ' & ! ' ' " # "!
& 20/
% # 1,"
20/ 1, % 3" 0 #
"0
;0#"% # ( 20"
,, "0"/
1#
%
( % 0 20"
(
56
#, #'
7 #%, ,
*%##( .
)( 3 ,"1"
, %# 3
#"
17 3" 0"
%
,"1"
, %#7 #01
'%1 0.
& " 1%
*1" 3# 0%" <%
=
%
4 #," " 1 #01,"
20
=
%%# #
20"
# ' 3 ,0#1"#
#1
%"#
&# % 0
1,# 1"
#* "1#7 ,%.
"17
"1 '#"
"1
# / 40% %" % *,%"
/ 11'
#%,
%
. !
& 20"
#%,
"
"
% :
"
< " !# ,* ' " "
< # ##
#
! !#
! ) ,, )+,, ,, )+,, !' #
!
!! #
#
! !!
! '
' "
'! & ! ! ' ' ! '"!"!" &D! ( '
& !!
' & F"(" # ! # %( &! &'>E&
#4 #& #
!
4?!>E& #4 " #$%"
& '
" ( ) **
+* ! # & < ! #
'
# ' & # & "
& + > $"% 56
#""0" 7 # "," '/ "# 0"7 (1"
#("
10#"
( # '
,, "0"/
, ( 0 "/
%#
(
#"
17 '0"
#"'
# ,0#1"
, , #
1, # " %
*%##( & #
,, "0"/
# '
,, "0"/ 7 "
7 "
%##/ (1"
#("
10#"
0#
3% "
, , #
". #0% %" ?
# %#
"# 0"
4""
$##1 ( 1
@01
"
0# ( "%7 "
3
1, ##'
1
,%" 3"
,"
1
0" "/ % , , # ,"%0 ,0#1"?
, #"
*, 3/ # #( / ,0#1"
"
,0#1"
, , # *%##(
, , # ,0#1"
3# 1 '# 0, ,( 0# %
(1"
#("
3# #%
# "%7 "
1 1 #
, , # ,0#1"
3# 3"
.
(1"
#("
#3
#0#"
(/ (1"
#("
10#"
( .
%"
,#"
% %## ". "
#" '/ (1"
%" ,0#1"
1A "
20" #3
#/ .3 # 1""
%"
,0#1"# 3 1, #
1
.3
,#"
% &# "" 1###
, "7 1 /7 3"
(1"
#("
""
.
%"
%"# '0"
%"
" #
%"# 3
". "
#" '/
(1"
%" ,0#1"
1 , ##'
1
. 3"
,
,#"
%
3"
%"#
1## #
,"%0 , #
%"
3# ' 0"
"%7 1"
*,
.
1.#
#0,
%#7 20" *, "
1.#
0%"
#0'#20"
1.# ' *1, /
"
/ " ,, ( '/ #0,
%#
)(
0" "/ %
.
"
#"
%"#
3% 3# ,0#7 "
,
1
,0"
3
# 0" "/ 1/ 1"" %%01#"%#
1
" *, " 3/ " # ,0#1"# 3 (
1
#0'#20"
,0#1"# #(
#"# %"
0" "# % "
"1
,#"
20/ 1/ ( 1/
" *, " #
& , "
3" *, " %%,"'
7 '0"
3" # ' (
,, "0"/
( *, "
B % %%,"
%"
,#01,"( . :
,0, # ## 20/:7 # " %%,"% 3
#0'(#(
,%,
# '
,, "0"/:
B7 "
7
"
%01'"
0, 0" "/
( (1"
#("
"
#% #" # '
,, "0"/
# 3%0# #"
, , # ,0#1"
, , # ,0#1"
'#
,( 0# ,0#1"#
,( 0# ' % 7 "# # % 0 #% "%
1/
'
( *, " :
# !
!! # '
' & < !! & ( ##"& ! (# ' >E& #4 ,$ &
" -
)) & 2*
& 0"#
#""0"
/ 0" "#
,,%"
#%, / 0" "/ 3"#
# ,#"
0%"
1,
/ 1, # ,0#1"7 20"
""
"% "
% #"
# " #0% "%
"
#"
#
1
#1 "
#"
# 3%0# "%7
1, # ,0#1"
C &# 0"
>
( #1' # # ;01"#
"# 0"
4""
$##1 (
1
@01
"7 < 4(% D" ( .17 4""
</# (
@
<% 37
01 D"
(
$ $ #,0.7 7
!
( 4 '07 "
!
D" ( >""1 <
." ("
$
( < & $ %1
% 0# "
#'
20"
1,
/
1 '/ #%, / 0" "/ ,#"
0%"
". "
#" 3 1, # ,0#1"
3(7 %#
1#% 0%"
( "07 ( '#%
#""0"
/ 0 #7 0" "/ 1/ ". "
#" #,0"'
,#"
0%"#(% %
20"
3"
%#
1, # ,0#1"
%"
%#
20:
% # & &' >E& #4 $ .( "
" %0
!
& )
B #
#"
3" 20#" 3" #"
,#"
(# %
,,
"
'/ 0"
%"
("" "1"
,## '/ 4"" (1"
$ *%"
#1 20#" 3# # #3
1"( '/ #""0" % 4""
</# ( @ <% 3 &
%"#
%# 3 3 #, "
3#
, #"
$###""
$"
(
,1"
11## 7
7
7 (1"
</# ,, " 4 - @
5$"
(
,1"
11## 6
0%"
,"1"
20/ #"
1 #,%"
# 1#
3%#
'%"
( 0%#
& 20/
%
1
0 %# #"
#, "
$ "
20/ %% % 3" ("
0 #7 20/
% #0'1"" , "
3" % 11" #, "
1"
0% .
3(7 (1"
##0 "%
#, "
20 1
# %0# #
3/ 1/ #1##
#(%
$ " # , /7 (1"
#1## #, "
#(%
& #, "
%
#1##
'/
3"
,"" 0 $"% 9
#""0"
& 0"
20#
#1##
#(
0# % 0
#, "
'
"
'
0"
, , # #"
,#"
(# %
&# 0"
,, ( (3 ". '/ 0"
'#(?
5<% 3 %#7 $ ,, C7 , +6 +
> $"% 56
#""0" 7 # "," '/ "# 0"7 (1"
#("
10#"
( # '
,, "0"/
, ( 0 "/
%#
(
#"
17 '0"
#"'
# ,0#1"
, , #
1, # " %
*%##( & #
,, "0"/
# '
,, "0"/ 7 "
7 "
%##/ (1"
#("
10#"
0#
3% "
, , #
". #0% %" ?
# %#
"# 0"
4""
$##1 ( 1
@01
"
0# ( "%7 "
3
1, ##'
1
,%" 3"
,"
1
0" "/ % , , # ,"%0 ,0#1"?
, #"
*, 3/ # #( / ,0#1"
"
,0#1"
, , # *%##(
, , # ,0#1"
3# 1 '# 0, ,( 0# %
(1"
#("
3# #%
# "%7 "
1 1 #
, , # ,0#1"
3# 3"
.
(1"
#("
#3
. #0#"
(/ (1"
#("
10#"
( .
%"
,#"
% %## ". "
#" '/ (1"
%" ,0#1"
1A "
20" #3
#/ .3 # 1""
%"
,0#1"# 3 1, #
1
.3
,#"
% &# "" 1###
, "7 1 /7 3"
(1"
#("
""
.
%"
%"# '0"
%"
" #
%"# 3
". "
#" '/ (1"
%" ,0#1"
1 , ##'
1
. 3"
,
,#"
%
3"
%"#
1## #
,"%0 , #
%"
3# ' 0"
"%7 1"
*,
.
1.#
#0,
%#7 20" *, "
1.#
0%"
#0'#20"
1.# ' *1, /
"
/ " ,, ( '/ #0,
%#
)(
0" "/ %
.
"
#"
%"#
3% 3# ,0#7 "
,
1
,0"
3
# 0" "/ 1/ 1"" %%01#"%#
1
" *, " 3/ " # ,0#1"# 3 (
1
#0'#20"
,0#1"# #(
#"# %"
0" "# % "
"1
,#"
20/ 1/ ( 1/
" *, " #
& , "
3" *, " %%,"'
7 '0"
3" # ' (
,, "0"/
(
/ *, "
B % %%,"
%"
E,#01,"( . F
E,0, # ## 20/F7 # " %%,"% 3
#0'(#(
,%,
E# '
,, "0"/F
B7 "
7
"
%01'"
0, 0" "/
( (1"
#("
"
#% #" # '
,, "0"/
# %0# #"
, , # ,0#1"
, , # ,0#1"
'#
,( 0# ,0#1"#
,( 0# ' % 7 "# # % 0 #% "%
1/ '
( *, " :
51,## #0,, 6 & , , #"
3 '
( " ;01"
,#"#
'#% % #
;0#"%
% 1 0
,;0%
%" / ,# % ,## '/ ,0'
% 0" "/ 3" 0"
1 # '
,, "0"/
1#
,#"
%0#
$#
0 7 0" "/ "0#" 3" "#.
%
'"3 ,"#
1, 3
1.
3% ,;0%
%"# "#
/ (0
(#"# 1 3" %(
#20%# 0"/'
0
%"
# % 3" '#% 0 #
"0
;0#"% % 0
1"
0"
0# #"
,# % 10#"
#%
#
1 # (
,, "0"/
*, , #"
&# 03"" "
01"
;0#"
%# 7 3%
1# "
,"
%,"
0
3 &# "
0 # "#
"# "
, %0 3# """
0" "/ %
1,"( %##"/
(
. %0# 3% 1/ # 3 '/
" #
1
"# %# B "
1#
".
#%, / %" #"
20"
1,
/7 1,
/
20
1. 1,
/ 3
#,% % 1,0"" #
1#% 0%"
'0"
#%
# 1"
0"
0# #"
1 ( 1 # '
,, "0"/
*, , #"
1#
1,
/ 0## 1 1"
(#
1,
/ '
0"
3%
"" ( "%7
%# "# (""
0
(
"
0
0 "1 ,"1 )(
"
#""0"
/ 0 # 3% 0 "
#%, / 20/ #"
20"
1,
/7 1,
/ 0"/ '
0
%"
# % 3" 0 #
"0
;0#"% G>
B 0# , ( -;/
/ -;,/ $ 4 D#>E& #4 1 -
2 "%1!
)! & " !! < ! " # ' ' .
! ! ' ' & ( > " !! & ' !!!
! '
' ! &
1 #' " #$ 4 !
& !! & !
&'$ 4 !!
& # <! '
# ! > &# ), ' 4 '
!!
>E& 4 !! "
D'# #!# ' # "
!. >E& #4 ! !!"
'" " !
'"!"
D " !! !! %>E& 4 & 2*
1"" , #" #, "
3# ,, "
%" 0"/ '0"
'#" 1#
%" 0"/
#1# #, "
# %" 0"/
1, ""
'0### 3% (/ 1, ""
3
"
& #, "
3# ,, "
%" 0"/ 3# ,0"
". #%0"/ 1"
'0"
'#" 1#
0"/ &# (/ # 0#
,#
,"
#, "
& ,
%
% #%,
% #, "
3# "
#0% 1, ""
0"/
%" '#" 1#
%" 0"/ 40% .
# 0#
,# % ""
"
(/ 1, ""
0%"
%01'"
( 0"/
%" 7 % #%,
' "/
, "/
1,0 / "1"
B
0#" #
$1#""( &'0
0"
( 1"" 1"" '%.
#%, / 0" "/
% #"
,0#1"
1,0 / "1"
1, #
#, "
D 0#
,,
'
#, "
#0'1""
%"7 #%, / 0" "/ 3 ,##
# ". "
#" '#%
#, "
0"/ #0'1"" "# ( ' ". "
#" # #, "
3# 3 '
0"
"# %"# " # 3 ,"
%#
(
#"
1
#0,, "
#0'1##
0#
#, "
# ("
0 """
;01"
"# 0"
""
4""
</# ( @ <% 3 '0"
,#"
%# 3 #"#
%"
#, "
'" '#" 1#
0"/
/ *, "
'#%
%" 0"/
#, "F#
#"
'#%
'#" 1#
0"/
%%# #
0
, " %
#"
0 1 '%0# 1#% 0%"
# ' 1" %#"
"
% ". "
#" '/ ,0# 0" "/ #"
1#% 0%"
"
%
,
# 0" "/ & ,
%
% #%,
%
#, "
'"0
'#" " "
#
"#
%"
"
"1
1, # , "/
< (7 ( '#%7
0
, 7 '#%
/# '/ 11'
#%,
% #0
%"
;0#" 1,0 / "1"
:
% #!
& !
!
& " # ! " ' !" '# #!# ' # #" &D 4 ! !! !
' & " # # !# ' # ! "
# !! " & "
&!!
## !
"!!
!!
" &'$ 4
# '
!
!! '
" % ! ' '
. / 2 3 ! '
( %# #! ' ' < ! & ( '
'
!! ' !!& <! & ' # & '.
3
-
- 4 ! &' ( )