High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/588/2011allowed

Punjab State Civil Supplies Cororation Ltd. v. Raja Ram & ORS.

2016-01-22Mr. Justice Arun Monga3 pages

!"#$%"&&%#'&'( )") *'

&&%% +' "*', ,-' ,&

.**''&'' %%/&&'-0!%%/ 1-2

3!' '''&'''2 4 .**'* 1-*%!'&'*12

'5'6&7$ '&&%% '"5"1%7$ ''& 7 787 9 ::::

3* &&%% )") 11'$ * ''

9 4

7/*'!0! %'"48 * 7* !%%/*/' *'!''

;

7*! ' 5' 6&7 %' % &&'1 !*%

&&%% !-7 * , %%' < 0 ! $$ ' *'!''*%-1*''% 7/** '1*-7/ %%1/**=>&#%7*- *$/$*'1*$/ *&'$ "8 *? &&' *7**'%& 1-''!0*#'

! "

%&'())

)*( @ '*'!-*! 7*! 1#'%% &*&'%$ '*77&&%-*$ %'0%! '*'!''3*&''</*

'!'#%7 3*! 1#'*$0 '&&%/*%%1/**! 70!01$1 '!'$*>- /*#' &&%7*7*

1''!0*! 1#''!%*0 %/ *&'0 '1 *'''*%%1 '"5"1%7%'%&&'1!*% *%%'

!-7*'!''*$0 '''0* &*%- *&&%%/ %%1/**=>&-' 3*! 1#''>-*$ **%- *

)") / !% *' ! 0 % 1 ''!0! 1#'*&'0 '-% *&&% ?*$*'%'% '*&'&&'* &&'!< 3*%//*'1'*/$1 *'1*%1'' 1'"8 &'$*&'0< ! $$* ' *'!''7'1*-*$ ! /$ ? '/ &&' '- * ' %% * 1-''!0*#'

'1'* 1>-1*-' '*!0<1*$ /*%%1/**! 7?- *$/**'&'$ &'$'* -&/'1*! 1#'<$

4 1&&' *! 77/*%%1/** ! 7&'''A'%$! *$! --'%0 ? *$ - ' -0 $' '' & !0 * ! 1#'7/*'!0'!%-*!&''1* $!*% ! '*$'&'03*&'$ " 48&'$''1 0$=$*'/7/% %/*! *$!*!

$ '1%07?*'!0'%%*! 1#' *" !@'0)3#*1'**! 0 %'"48 * *!

$ !0''1 $!0 '-1<1*$ 3*' --0!''B1 %%* ' " !@'0)37#*1'* '-&% 5&1$/* '- 7*%%'*

% <*! $$ '7? - *$/ * ! -!%7-*%7 %%1/**&'-'

"48 '1%07 '' * ! 1 #' &1 * ! !%*'!0 ,%%07&&%%%/ !" !"# +