High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5959/2011allowed

(O&M) Om Parkash Alias Oma v. Satpal And ORS

2023-02-28Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan10 pages

!"#

$$## % & '$# " &("")*

+, -".'("/0 "$$##

+ 1#0203 . $4

*5- '("0/ $4

8 #.0" "$ !"

# "- &("# $& ' 99" %"# 0 " " ( " $ '$#: / 03 .*,.03 $03 " &("2 # ( 0'3 .0" &(";## 03 : , <;<;<) - <& ; $.) 3 :& -&- ( ( 4 3* 69 " " ( -& 0 # ( $ & & ( 5& /"&# 0- " ;# = -&#0+"# " "= -&#

$ "/ "# !"#

0"#(,""- " $'(": $#, ((+"# " ( &#& ## #($." ##.0,"",-( /-." 0," $'(", ("$.#" ##.>" ##.,- &(" "# !"? ,"!( $ & ". " ##.0" ,"#"(-& +#.-( /-. $4 "(#( &!

(" ##. -!0 &##."&(" $'("" $ ,#.0 !"? 0,",(" / " ##" / & &#$#5& "

&"0", >" ##.##"$(-#. (> " $4 ,. "$> $'(": $#"""-&-#(3 . *,.3 $, ( & - $ #. 3* > $'("" / !"? "$# +"# ," ", 2<0;"( "!$(/, " &""",&&> $'(" "(" ,"$##'+#.0 ,"" - ( "<*

!"? 5& ( " # &0",/ ""/- @-#&-# ., !0- &-#,#!-.", -($&0##"& $$$

*$4 6"#$ , 0,"

$4 &$,"5, ( "# $

"$#("$ ##,(&,

A"" "# "&5& %"&# ,""!$# & " (#( /( $4 ,"# /(8&4 3* B69C

< & 4 $ /0 ," & $ " # # ," C

A"" " ./# <& #.C*

8""$ , D&$$ &# / $" $/#

& ("& /# 0"# E "- " $'("A 0,"$ /"., &"$(,""" # ="$ B# (" A $($ "&$"# $ A" A

'&#2 0 # 0'""3$#0+"#"

,"#",, !(&"0"$ #.

!",E -." ""$#>""-- &(","

##(" . >""$,

6 #",&&0 (#.", 2<0 ;"( "/ #$FE B

A6 *5";""- 0# 0$ 4& '& ( .02<0;"( ""- &("" (# -#. $ #. !"0 ," " - - &("2<F (.,"##(" .

/;*4 66G =" #/$ "$ ##,

! "#$%%&

( )$)$*+ )$*,

)" )&& ( )#%%

- -((. + /

( (

="$ B# #&$& & FE

;$.<*

FE " (&

."#

B * #$#

FE BFE B2

#-##

FE -#. "#

! ;$. $&-. !;

0 +#.

!8 ;

= "#

! F & !"#

< -&#" $#. #/ " &("##,(& "- FE * ;$. /(# $4

FE * ;$.<& $#.

FE *

;$. ( 8&4 3* 69

FE *6 ;$.*&

!* ;$. !"#

!* ;$. "# $ 8&4 3* 69

" (# &# "$ 0"= -&# & 4 ( " $ B# /& " $ 4(,(/&4 "#("& &4 0"-- /" 0""

9 -&-& "(#( /( $4

,"# /(3 .*,.3 $-&- ( ( 4 4 3* 690 " , " & $-$"# #-#. $ <&4

,( $4 6/& $4

*&##.0"# $, -." = -&#/, 0,""#"# (( / ""#$$#- ";& 0,"",& " $ *$4 6"/$&$$ " &("

&#0," $4 $$ $ /" -$ (E$

<"/" # &# "$ -(( " &("" <"" $&(, 5&# &.#-#-

="# "- &("&("(/( /-" #,##& .","" D&"-&-. $4 -." "(#( /(-&- ( ( 4 4 3* 693 $ -#(( $4 & ," $4 & $.-&"= -&#-.# $$ #/ , ( $ #, " #& " , =" ((/-."= -&# " "" -&& "(#( /("( -&-. $4 #/( " &-#

=" "-#," #,-(

G " "-(#/"&""# $ & ' 99" %"#,-(#,"

' 99" %"#$,# #(# <,-." # $ / #" $ 0,"& 5& " /"&# ,## "#(# $ /"/ 0,"& &#.#" #/&" "$ ' &#/$ & $$#-#" &#! #," "$ & D& $ /("&-.", -#&- &"&$ /(&#"&""# ." $ &/ "

="- " $ B# $'("" , ((" A ( ##.(" ""-&& "(#( /( "(-&-. $4

3,&-5#(". E -&" &" <, $'("0,"" " # " . -. $ (" "$# /("5& ""$# 3$ "$" #/ & #$ --#"/ (/-." , ". # ' # #."$ "(", A&$$ ("/ (/"# $ 3 "/(& 5& " $," $ "$-&- ("0" $ 4 &#&

& ($",-E. "" "(#( -&" & " "

/#/ "-& /-." " ' # #.$ " $4 "(" .("/#/ "-&D&" " (#( /(-. $4 -(" " "$

& " <*" ( "-#( ##"/ , "& !"= -&#&4 /& "$ B# ( $-&-.$( ##., ( &$$ ""&,5&((" $ /& " $ =" &-(" $ B# (/, " !"? $ " &$$# . " " " (/( " / ( & - "-& "A $'("" " E " .##(0" !,-&"& - -&

"$##>" -(&$$# . $ '("-(/#-# =" ##. #/ ,"#$$ (/"$ 5&# $

=" 0"(&4 / & /& "$ B# ( $

; (&4 0"= -&#"-" (/ .(&"&,", D& (// ##" &

4/ "#""(#. -#.," -( 0"# $"/(-#

0 -."= -&# "$$#"

"/(-#". $( " . 0< $ $ $$ $ "-!"= -&# $ " " $ " "- //#-#"

=" $ B# " # $ #!" +$(/,"("0"&$0" $ --# 0,""" (""/ "E-#. & -." 0<"" $# -." " "(" ( " " # # ( $& / &" #E$0$#0 /##(E$0E$ " ( ,## $&# ( & " $ & (& (0# && (5& 0##(/. &#" 5& /"

="&&4 /& "# (" $"$$##B$ B# # $* 00B

="( -."= -&#&4

## .

(#.0"$$#$ =", "$$# $* 00B," ?G @$ & "#(# $##&# #H -"$, # $.-#-.##" $5#./ ##.

'" $$#$0" ##&

$$# 0.0$ (#.

8 5

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#