Cit Ludhiana v. M/S Mahavira Cycles Ludhiana

ITA No. 3 of 2010 (O&M) 1 Gurbax Singh 2017.08.28 11:47



    
      
 

        ! "#$#%&'(  ))#$$#% *
%")  +,
-./!0# %                      122 33 %    4$

5$

6#* 7"3 
%!/$*# $          1 $2%! %   & 8.

 9
:

 
.    8.

 9

 ;. 







 

 



 

 








 
 
  



< 7:/) * # 3-

!

 


"!
#
$

%&'

() )




 



 

"!
#
$

() )



* 


*

 

 
 
+

 
, 

"!
#
%&'

() )

 


 -

 -


(. / 0
/0


"*
!

1

'2
/

3
40




 

5, 

 

+
1 
*
"!
# $

() )

"!
#
%&'

() )
 

 -

 -


 






 

"!
#
$

() ) (

"!

#
$

() )
 
+

+-

 

 


(2)







 
( )2 ())'
1
6""
 
+-


"*
!

1
 
!+ 
  
7
879
  
/

3
!+ 40


#

ITA No. 3 of 2010 (O&M) 2 ((':5#;":())&



"!
#
<&:5#;":())&



*
- 
'''

()))
 *
,
+  
=

 , /0 3>


 


 ,

59+
"*
!

1
 
!+ 
, 








?

1


*


 
*

8


+9
,
  



&)55@
/0 >


 


 ,

59+
"*
!

1
 
!+ 
, 




?

1
*

8


+9
-

 

 


*

 
1
*

  
, 

,


*

 

 


 


 @
/0 >


 


 ,

59+
"*
!

1
 
!+ 
, 







 

 


 

 


 

"!
6
:
#  


A*

"!
# .<): :())(
"!
#
<($
B
$'%: :())$




 

:
5, -
-

"!
#
%2&
B
2%%: : ''2

,

 
+

 

 
* -
+
1
*

 

 *
* -

+
1
*




+@
"
"!
#
%&'

() )

,
+  
=

 ,
 +
 *


/0 3>


 


 ,

59+
"!!






 -
*



ITA No. 3 of 2010 (O&M) 3 (. / 0/0


"*
!

1

'2
*



(..$'( :



 
 


 

  
  


*
+-
 *
1



&)55


"*
!

1

'2 @4
$


,
 
 -

  


 -
  

  

"!
#
$

() )
* -
+
 




 
*
,

 

*



+-
 

1 

*


*
- 

=
, 

+-



('

'''
 
 
*



#

 *



&)55
*



.$<$'<.:

!
 
, 



%.



,






C
**

"*
! 1

 "
A  



%&



, 


 




() ).

())<
! 





*

(< )& ())<
 
#
*

 *



&)55



*



.$<$'<.:

6

 
) ).

())2
1
"

*
, 
 D
+-


?


%$/$0




 
*



2'(%&(:

!



&)55



, 


 <22 %.<:



 *




.$<$'<.:

>
*



&)55





?
1

*

 
*

 
 


 


 
*

8


+9 



+

**

"*
!

1
/ 0
E"!/0F



 
) ).

())2
6

 
(< )'

())2
1
""


, 







5, 

, 
 
 

 


ITA No. 3 of 2010 (O&M) 4  
,

+

,
*




+ !

?


 
$ ) ())2
1
"""
*

*




#
"
, 
+ 
+-


?
 






"!/0
 

(< )'

())2
 

+
 
-

,



 
 

 
,

+

,
*




+
-



<%



, 





.

())2

*


, 
*



.'(<%&':


,




'%(&%2&:



&)55



 
+-


 
(&

())2
1

"6
 


<%







+

"!/0
,
, 
*
+-

"!/0


 
(& ( ()).




+

!+ 
"
* -
+

 
,




<%



, 
 







+

!+ 



 
(< )'

())2
 
+-

"!/0
 

+


 

 
,


+

,
*

8


+9
6

 
('

)'

())&

!+ 
+



+-


!

 
+-


?
, 

* -




<%



, 
 
 
+-







 


(<%/(0



6

 
( )2 ())'

!+ 



 
+-


?
5

 

+-

    %

>



 
 



  <

*-


 
 *



&)55



*


.$<$'<.:







ITA No. 3 of 2010 (O&M) 5 *
!

?




 


  







&)55


 G


?
1

 



 
*




+

*



&)55



"


"!/0










+
 
 

 
,

+

,
*



+
!

?
*

*





"
, 
+ 
 



 
+-
"!/0
, 

-
 




<%



, 




*
, *


 .'(<%&':


,



&)
55


 

+-


, 
*
+-
"!/0


 
(& ( ()).

!



+

!+ 
"
, 

+-

!+ 
 


 

1
*

 ,

8 
 9

 


 

+

*

8


+9




*



&)55



!


 
+-


?



, 
  >
 




+-




 
+-

"!/0

(& ( ()).





 
+-


?


<%



 
(&

())2
,+-

 
$ ) ())2
 





"!/0
, *

, 
 

 

, 
 
+ 


?
 

-
 





"!/0
 
(< )'

())2



 
$ ) ())2
"

*



?
*




&)55
+-
1

 
*

 
 


 

ITA No. 3 of 2010 (O&M) 6 
*




+
!

!+ 



,


 
+-


?


<%




!

 
,
+
 -

+-

59+
*



 

  

    



  
 
 
#
<<'(

())&


-
)<
() %
,






 -
 


 
 ,




, 

+-

1

 


 
*

 
,

+



 
 
"
, 
+ 
 


+

 *


&)55



, 

 
1



 
*

1 
"
, 

 


H *


 
*
+

*
,



 

+

1 

 


*



+


 

 

*  
+-
 

+

*
+

* 


 

 , 


+



+-

1

 
 3(&
!

+
 *


&)55



, 

 
1



 

1 
G

 


H *
, 

 
+
 

*  

 

1


+
*

1 


-
"




+
*

1 


 
1
,



,
 

 
,
-
 

 
*
+


,

*







 




+
*

1 
"

 


*  

-

+

 

1
 





+


 
*  
,


 

H *
,
 

 



"




ITA No. 3 of 2010 (O&M) 7 
H *


 
*
+

*
,



 

+

1 

 


*



+


 

 

*  
+-
 

+

*
+

* 


 

 , ('

G

 
 
,



,
 


,
1
+-

5



*-
,

* 
 
,
+-

 






, 

*


 


 
*

 
,

+



8 
 9 4
.

"
,


 ,
 
,
+-

1






   
 
/ 0
 



 
+*
 

=
 


 


  

=

+
1 *

+-


?


  
* 1


 
"
, 

 


* 


 
+-

"!/0


!+ 
+




* 
+
* 



?

 



 
 








 
,
 , ?
- & 

*


= *

 
"!
#
$

() )



+




* 
 
+
* 



?

 



 
 





 
,
 ,

, 
 -
 


 
+-

"!/0


!+ 

"!
#
%&'

() )
+






* 
+
* 



?




 
 -





= *


 
,
 ,
?
-

ITA No. 3 of 2010 (O&M) 8 '

7


 




+

   < 7:/) * #          /!=    /=/$-(     )#

>    ?=$8       /!=  >


: 
 $




>
 +
 $