← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/310/2010dismissed

M/S Paliwal Industries Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Karnal

2015-09-23Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary7 pages



     

 ! "#$#%&'(

)$

*#+ *%!,$-# $ ./#0# ! 1122 ** % 00#$$#% -%"0  34 -7 + %48 -% *4 -5 %  1 $2%! % & 9/

 :8

/  9/

 :    



      

   

  

 

     !"#$"% &'( 



)

 "*   &'( 



)(  ;

58,0 - # *4 

)



 #

+,'

-  .'&/+0 &1'23     4,,/& '. '

      -   . '



  5 676 8 0   &1 23  - '

990:;3<,,/



,,+),9&

  =

!) '&    

 &

    

             

    (

      

    (   

  

 (   



 .

 

> 6#  ?



- 





@@-  0#?3 5 



(  

(

  '     ( 

    

 

     ( 

( (  

 

)



  

 



  

 

-

 

 



 ,,+),9    @9&&A4<) ,,,+  



#

4 03

' ,,,9& 



 

4 03

' 





'

B



    

'

B

  (

  ( 

 !)  "<

"

A&,,&,,,<)  "< 8#

&+9& A/<)

( 

  .

 



    





 

 (  %  

  ( % 

  

   



 '

B

 



    

  .   ( 

    

 &&A<)

 ' ( &







?





-  .0'

 3C?- 0'3D-

      

  (  (            

 &+/&A+/@,    "<   8    #   7    *  ,,4),A 0'

,,A),+3  

 

  ( 

        



     (  

    @,,A   

&9&A/,<)  //,,A



    > (&





'

,,+),9&?- 0'3     

'

B

&





( 

@ ,,/&'.'

 



  E  4,,/&'.' &  



> 



)



(  

   4 ;     

    

)

    

      

       '

  B

 

  

,,A),+





+030

3

'  

( ( 

;

& 

"< 8F#   

    A B &  

(

  

'

B

 

?- 0'3    +     

   &    

    

  (  

"

"< 8# 8  



 (  

 %

.

 



  

 

 %           

    (     

(



+030

3

'

.

   (

A 

    

   (



 

 

 7&(  (  8F#

 ( 

   '



 & '



 





 

  .  (



  ( 

   &&A<) ?-

0'3

 

   !) 1/-(



 

7 

 



 &

(

A&,,&,,,<)  ( 

7*,,4),A  

& 7*,,A),+&



   

  

(   (     

   

    

     



G

 





    





  

(  (   (      

            ( &  &



&  (



  

&     





( 

  

< 

            (



 

&

&

   

      (      

  

# &

8F# &



&+/&+A/<) .



&/&@/,<)     

 &9&A/,<) 



 &+9& A/<)    



   



&

.

  

%

       

& 

&( .

&+9& A/<)



&

     ( &

 8F# &

'B  

2 9        

       ?- 0'3&  

 !) 1+(       ;  

   ( 





- 

&   

> 6 '

. 

"# ?



( ?- & /@- /@&#'5  ( ?- @@&- > 6 " > ?



?- ( #(> ?

4@- A@A;  

  ( 

 

 +;        

 

  

        

      

       (   ;  

  

 

  



   ?- 0'36  9( 



     '

 (

"

&(

A

 

 ;    

  

      

 

(    (

( '

   

(&    





 

 

 9'

 ( 8# &

      

  =  

       



-



&

(   ( 

 

  '

        

 

(&               





 

 @H

 



&



  

  (  ( ' &

           H       &  ( 

  

 ( (( 

  

&





   

2 @

  '

  B

&  ?- 0'3          (

      A    

   

       





   (     

   

    

      



# &

8F# &



&+/&+A/<)   

&/&@/,<)&

   

       

 &9&A/,<)     

&+9& A/<)- 

  





  .

       

 - 

 



 '

B

&?- 0'3 & 

  

  



        '

 B





,,A),+& 

  

  

   .

(  /



   



 (     (    

?

  &   =

  

'  



 ;

58,0 - # *

,!< : 2 0= -4( 

0 %!-  #%

><$> ,!<