← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5708/2013dismissed

Isha Khasa v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2016-07-13Mr. Justice Darshan Singh13 pages

 

   ! " #    "  

  

     

   

    

     

   

"$% "%&'(')    *)+!,*  - .    



  !"

$%& '()* )+,

-  . !"

$%& /0*' )+,



1

2  !!2  

 

  !"

 

& 3,

$%& '()* )+,  

& 

(

$%& /0*' )+,

4 

 !"

 

& *

+)

$%& /0*' )+,

 .4. !"

 " .

 !"

 

++

$%& /0*' )+, 

  . !"

   !"

 

& +,

+0

$%& /0*' )+,

.   / 4  5        6



#

8 

5 #  

" 

 7   #

6 #  # 5 ## #

6     6#

 

$



   #



 

& /

(

  "

9 "#

#

5  " 

 "

 " 

 7 )+:1:)+ 7

      6     

 ;

" 

  4  " 

  8

  8  #

6    2 5

  < 

 "

    # 5 6 

 7  



 !

"#  0'



  5    # "   4    #

 $

 # 7    

  ;

" 

6 

$ 7

#

    

%    $ % 4   #

 # # 7  5

5 6

54 #

   #

5

7

 " 

 7 5 #5  "  

5('7. 5

')

54 #

$

 

+  #     

6 

#

  

        "

 

 5   7   +/,# 5   

5

 

6 4   

6 

6 # 5 

 

    #

$

 =#

6 )> )+ 4  # ?$ #     #

#

5

   4   #

5  .

=#

6  ++ )+  6   $ #  5

6 #

#

" 76 ' )+=   

 #     5

4 

#  /+7.

('4 # 5 #    5

5  # 

5

6  

 # 76 / )+4 

5



5 !

   ,+ #   5  

5   6     #

$

 # 76 / )+ 7.5  5 ## 

    7 #   4  

  #    )  7.    ') 

5$

 7.  5

5 

#  0+ +'!# 7

" # 6 6 

0  5

 4 7    #  ?

-%0%&$% '$%( 1'$$%%($ *12( $%13'%4*12( $0  

/ ,( ,0 (,  

'

,* ,* (0  

0 ,* ,0 (/  

( ,/ /* * 

/+ ) 0+   "

   5

/+7. 6  

5          !## 

    5 

   

     

  & / 

 (  5   

      #

   #

$

5   " 6   $ # 

1 ) )+,4 

 

5    

1 ), )+,

 ## # 4 

# 7

 5

7    

5  

6   #  

 7 

6

 5 # 7 

 

& /

( =

#   ;

" 

 

 5



7.  5  

 

5 

     #    

 5  



6 



 5

# 7    

 6    7  # 

6 #

"  7

5 6    #

$

 

 8     #     



  .

5   < 

#    

   .

    6 

6

   "

 !# 7

" #

   # # 5

  

# 7 #8

 < 

  5

  ((   ?6

.      5   



 # 7 #8

 # 7

5 #77. 

    

 #

  8

   7    +)  #

5

"    

 $ ! < 

 #

#      < 

   # #  5  #   

& / 0 ( "  "    "

 "

  %    "

 ! % 5   

'

 # 

 < 

  "



    7



@

 < 

   " 7

4   # 

5   6 < 

   # # 

4 

@ 

 #

"

7 #   "  6       #

   #

@#



?  =  7.

5

 5



 

7.    

7#5

6 

55 # 

6

  #

 4  

!  .7-"

 "  

  !+>*($/'/ " # 

    $

 

 7. 

6 7   +A



#

 5

 %   7 $    

 

 

5 

#    #  #

  $  "

5   "

 < 

# 5

  #



 $  "

# B<7

5

 2 %  < 



#



 7.

576 



  



 5



  < 

#  

   

  

  

#  

         "

  5   ;

" 

 < # .

 "   

 

  

 < 

5  

.

  

#7

7  5      

 ;

" 

4      

 

 #

6 6



#  $



   

6





')7.

55      #

$

7" 7 #

 

7



.  

7  

     #

6 #

#   6    #

     5 #  #

  5  

"  

  #

 4   #

      

#.          #   

/  

'5   

 

 

  ;

" 



 +/  5

  ;

" 

    

   

     6    

 7

C 

/5 

!   

  ;

" 

4 " 7  

'

C  "

  

     

   

   6  

     5 .

5  

 

 ! 

6  6





 

%

  

 "

 6   & " 76 , )+,6

5 #  5 ?

  

     

      



  !" #  

  $ %  

  &

   

 ' %(   



  !" )  

 (%!

 (

       %( 

%  

 *  

 

   & ( + (

   

    

  $ %  

  &

  ,  

  $ %  

  &

     

       -  



   (

     .

  6  "



# #

   7

  





  6 # 

7 

   5 

# E5   <#  

 

  6  & #    5 #  

   4  7 6   6

 

  

     4  $ 7 "  #

     

7 ! 

   

?;

" 

5

7   

6 5 #    "

#

6  

 # 4 #

      #    #  "



C 

'  7   4 

" 



6 7  7 

5   

 # 

#

. #  

   

  8 

# 4 6 5

   "  

 "

#

   #

4 #

  #

 #

6

"



!

# +/  $

 

 



  #

  #

4 





   #

 #      

5  

  75 

5"

5 6  5 #

#  "

""

#  

   

67  7  6 # 

5

 

5

 <7



 

6 #

#

 5  

6     #  4   

 67 

5 # 8  

6  

5 #

   ?# #.

 5

 

 # 76 ) )+ 5#

 #

" 

7. 6

  



 

 

 5 ?# #.

 ?

"

  7

  #  #

 ?# #.

5

 

    ?# #.

 ? "

 

# 7 #

6 # 7 7



F      # B#

3

  #

B#

"

 7 # ! +>*/$+'/, 

  

# # 6 

 ?

# #.

 ? "

 

5      

 

 

 5

5 #. 

   

76 

 

    # #   

6   6 

5#

 8   

# "       7. ## 4  

5  

  6 

7

  

     5   ##   =  5  

 5  

        #   #

 

7

   



7 6 # !# 

 6  

 5 

" 

7

  5

  #

# 6    .

  

 # 

 

2 "   6

  H+>>+I+$$00 7 #

" 4 #  

  #  #

B<#   4<

  #



# 6   6 

 "

#   #

   65  < 

# 5 

  #

   #

        7 $ 

    / %   # 

J " 

  H+>*+I/$$+'>



 0  #  

  #

  1   "

# 65

 <7

5 6 "

""

# 



#     #

5 77

6 # 5 #7  75# 7 # 

 

 8 

   5   

 5 #

 "

 < 

# 5 8   

 < 

#   

  6 4 $ #

 6 "    #

6       

 5

6 

5

 5

 <7

  1 

 2    7 $ 6 " 5  

7.

5

 

    

0  # 4 J   6 "  D

 #

5  #

 

5 #  < #

   7 "    #

5  

J5

5

   # 6 5   

5   # "  # 

7   

 

E 0 

5

5#

# 66 #

1  

$ $ 7 76   6 # "

# $ 

 # 

 <  4    # 6 



7 " 

6





#  #

6      

# 



 #

5 #  



6#  

5 8 

5  .   6

5  5 #  8 

5   5  #  #  5 #   

5 4  

 

6 

 6 # #  5 #  



 .

5 

    #



6   6 

 

  <#    #

 

     #

 5

   

" 

55  #

#

     7

4 

')A7.

57  6   7 5  <#  " 

"

5  # 5 "   6

  #

#

6    

 7   

7.5   

 <#  " 

7.  

K  6 L     



6  

7 

5

 

  < 

# # 

 

  # # ;7 !C 

+'6 "7 2.7    !

5   4    2   



  6  

7

  # "         

  7

 !#  ))'  5 # #     < 

# # 

 %  7! ))/

!  ))>  

6;7 !6  6

 2.

 

7



 7"

 

     9 6 (  )+,  

 D!#     5 

"72.  !

5      

"  #

      <7

 #

#   6      ;

" 

  .!,'?/)   

"   <7

  <7

#    #

# !#  1

;

.  #

 2.

  ))(9 7

52.

.

=  7   #  7

2.E   

   #

 6 8  6

 #  7

C 

+067

#7 5 # "      ! 7 ; .

 ))0    B 7  7 ;

" 

  ))(   !  7=7

;

" 

  6

  ))>    B 7. ;

" 

 . 

   )+)6 

  < 

# # 

 

6 7

   5  5 .

        %  

   &

 $

$#.5 15 =#

6 +( ))0

 )+

  6 

 

  # 

  -   .      #     

        67

 7#   < 

# # 

 # 6 7

  6  #7 4   

 

#  

#  # "     



" 

5 # # 

      #

  "

5

  5  7



  7    

 "   #

  #

$

4   

 " 6   6

?

  

:

 75  < 

# # 

5  

6

     

& *C#



 # 

 

  5

  

!  * )+,   # # "



 

5 .    "

#

 7 # 76 )+ ))*

#,+ )+   

+)C&

$   

  !  * )+,  <

 7

.  %  7=#

6 +( ))0 

  )+ 

  "



 

B#   7 # 76 ( ))0

1+'

))(   

!B#

 # 7  5

  7 

 

 " 5

5    

  <7

 

+,?

 "

    5

  

 #

6 

@ 



8  <

 

5     < 

5   1 76 32  

 "   

 

7. J 6

 " 7 

 

+, "  #  J 6#

#  6

  

      "

# %

 

?;

" 

 

#

# 6  7 #)+ )+)

#) )++   #

#

# 

  

?;

" 

  7& " 76 +) ))*

9 6* )+)

 7 #), )++

1 ) )+,

  < 

 "

  8   " 

  4   5

 6  6"



C  

+/ " 

 5 .   "





  

 #

#

   





  7 # 76 )+ ))*

#,+ )+  "  

     #

 7.5  



  < 

# 5 

  < 

#  "

   

6 4     < 

# 5#

 



 7 

 # 

 

  < 

#     7

C 

+0   5



 7   #  

   #

 

& >C "72.7 !

5  4  2  





1 )/ )+/

 # 6

 5

 4 2. 

  

 

7

  

 4!# 5 #5

# 7

7

B"

  5 

 

 #  

B#

= #  

$  5#  

  ))(6     #

 



 

4 " 

# 

    #   

))*?)>5

        7 

7

5    

   B#

 = #   K5 # 

 

@ L4 "  "



# 

5 

      

?

#

 

#

% ;7  !5       #

$ 4    # 

;7 !HM;7 

 "       "

# %  7! ))/

!  ))>  7 

 ;7 !C 

+'    

5

     2  7 ;8 

 +

       !

 .

N

 +



    $ 7 $   7   "   < 

 # 

 

  7

7



7 

   "

5        "

    $  5  

  6 < 

# # 

 "

5 6  

     

  8 

# 5 ##

6 

5

 

 5

# 

  8 

# 5 #

     # #   

 

 6

 5



  7  

 

# 

 7 

 

5

 

5

 

 .   7    "    7  %   .

: 

-  %    6