High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16952/2024disposed of

Union Of India And Others v. Karam Chand Jc 429113 Y Ex Subedar And Another

2024-11-18Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma10 pages

!"#$"%&'&#()*

"#$% &'()' *

+) ,-+ ..

. /

,-+ . ..

. + ,!+-./ #

0122 3

2 1 145 #$2 6 #523+6 722 + # 08529!

3+6 72:

;<= # -502 .!52 023+6 72

>>>>

. /

!,55 2 4 *

35*

;<=

+23 * 2. :

5 , 2+ : 5

+2+ ?

;

<3 2 *2+ -. 5 12

+ 0+

7 8 -!

+345 -.57120 : *

5, +2-1.*

42211 4+

%!1 2 %345#1(6 *

A + 0.

?B 2:2

:5215!

,57 :5 6735 7!

+5+2-1. C 7 - ,2 +42+752 ,+:

0 67

B50 :+752 ,35+2-1.422+D

1:-.5#+721) + & 85+2-1.10 7120 :5 *

42 A7+ -. 5 0* !5

.3 5!

5 ,

+ 52 5 !* +2-1 4 5 2 -!2-1

- , 2,, 262+ -.

:012 67

1 ,2,, 6+3 *

:1+3-:

5 12

+ 0+

7 8 -!

21 7

+3 45 -. 5 72 2 75211 , 52:

2+ A7

;<852+3-720 4+6+

+2+ ? 85 * 26*2 :52+

@ 27+5 2:

!"# $%$&&%$'

)*+,

- ./

0 1 ,2,, 6+:

052:

2*2+!*

5;!* 2<3-.512

+ 0+

78 -!

217

+35 *

: +252:1+5 2,2 5 2 4 *

5 ($"5"(%"'#$!8&'#15! ):

7+ , 0292 ::762+A!+72

5* 4 *

3 2!:!122 7:

+ ,455

5-:2110 :2 .+26F62 .00- :5+:

& *

13-!* 5- ,

11+ 52 0.3+*25 21 2,3!*

5-7 , 1+32200- :57 0-22 +: 72-150 3 520 02 ,!

+7+3.5 2** !*

35!* 10 5 7- ,7

!2-1 - 5 7

, 21

- ,7

!2-1 02,, 262+

- , 2 012 6735!27G! +3:

035* 7*1

5 5A!+,0 +-.5$

C-1*@ 3 721+ 2 $%# & %!

3 *

+ '

()& * 85 162 *2 2, 2*5 : 5 2+ 6 +7 2 @ 27+ 5 2: &1

" "

2 3 45 6

" "

" 7

&%/ "

8 9

$1.&; <7++

$=>5 45

+ "

?9 @ )9 $'45A 45 *

49 15 4"5+ "

" ?9 $'45A 4"5+ " B

" " B

" ?$'45A 4"5+ "

" C D

?$'45AE 4"5+ C D

7++ ;( 4C :

5 &%%& F ;8 3 (

;

=. 1

0 ? 76 2+ ,;< :526@ 27+* 7*13 5 !,5* +1.+712 35245 2+2-1.-7 0 21+!*

.00- :57 0-22 +: 72-150 32 +4575

5@ : E

35 !*

35 !,52 .!75+2-1+00-

- 621++:

05 0.3-!.5 - 2, +5- : :+2-1.*

51352, 0 :+2-1.*

2 00- :57 0-22 +: 72-150 345 0 21+ 45 2 +2-1. 2 G!2 !0 : E

3 -! 0* 261.

2 +712

0 5 #+721 ) +3 72 ++1.

7 ,5252+22 ++2-1.- ,2

-7 ,2,, 262+-.012 67852++712

+-.58 9 :

$1.&; <7++49

$=>5 !

35 !,55 2* !0*

2, + "7H7"5 +*5.7212 +0 215215 :2 .00- :5 +: 72-150 7

+3*7211.45 252, :5 -7 ,

11+35

+2- !5-7 ,- 452 .+2#

35 !,55 5 21 2:!

* !0*

3 52 45 2 . +

5 3 5! 77!

!-G! 1.3 5 -. 5 2+ 52** , : +

, :2 .+23 -* !0+ -2G!1 :5

, 67 2 2 00- : 5 +: 7 2-150 0* 261.35

6 ,5

+ 40 G!2- : ;!* 2<"7H7"57

+3-! +

50*1 . 32 +

72352+

! 02 !

+752 ,+35 !*

3571202 -7 0 1+ 76+2-1.*

32115:27 + 7 7!02 7 2 +2 5

: 67 -. 5

+32 -71 1.7 ! H+35!:

+712 ,455 5

:2 .+26F657

+32G!1G!2

: 012 . 67 2 +=

5 20 - , 2,, 262+ -.

- , 2 012 67 )52202.35 021 :

52:!

* 7*1;<52.5 72 -+ 21 :+2-1.*

+3-!

1.!*

/ 2<50 :277*2 7 :57

+ 012 673 0

,-7 , 7

++-.5#+721 ) + 626 5 - , - 45 2 +2 4575 46 3-7 07

71!++ -.

,50 : 0 1+

-< . :!

5 +

5 :3 02. 21

!-G! 1.-7 07

71!++-.5#+721) +3

2 :

: 012 . 67

- , 2 012 673 520- ,2

, 21+2 !

5 3:50+721 *

5 1+525+27 !1+

526- +7+

0+721@20

:57

+- , 02+35!*

5-7 , 1+ 6735 !*

35 20411

-+0+ 5262 +!

, 673. 5 !2

;!* 2<35#+721) + 25 2

71!+ , #

321 +712 + !* 235202 +2

5#+721) + :

45,!+1 12++ 52*

:5IJ!+ #+721;#12 .

KI'

10 / J 21 7*1I & 85 :

352 -

4+ +455 0 526* 7*13455 250 : 10 :5*

5 0.35!2: 2* 10 .0+721@20

- ,02+ "77"521535!2

-720 7

++2- !

0+2- ,502 +=

455 0

-7202** ++ 5252++242 2+

2,#

321

-+ +3:

05:27252 +3455 5 2 72!21 @! 5 !*

:5+232 +=

, 5 :3

35!* 5

110 :5*

29 , *1273 "77" 5 276

-. 50 012 67345 -.35 02.7

71!+525

5+2-! 422G!1 :5 , 67 5 0.

+2!75422 -!2-1

-7202,, 262+-.5 , 012 67 2++

321 -,25 +:

+3455 5#+721) +3++ 211.*

7+ 0292 +21+ 762 7+ 2175793*2 7!12 1.2** 2 , 5 2+6 :5+235

!,50*1 .0 :2 : 0+721 75 G!3 5! !

61 , 5 -1 79 752 , 7 7

45 :

03 5+2-720 7+#

3:52+ 0*1 .0 :21!12 1.35 -.02.-7 07

71!++G!2 !*

5 :35!!-G! 52** 10 29 , *1273 42

, 21-! 4+

012 67-+- ,2

,2,, 262+ -.*

7 :012 67

1.3:5!* 20*1 .+ 75 G!252, :2** 10 29 ,*12735!-.5 #+721) +7

+312+ 27

71!

3525 2

7+ 7 :2 .+23-!.52++

5- ,5 10 :2 .*

1 52 0.3 26.

7!12 1.5!-G! 276+7

= !*

5 :3 +!

,57 :

:012 673-!4 !1+ 2!

211.

12+ 24117

71!

-.5#+721) +352276 !*

-! -720 7+ :

0 2 ::76 72!21 , 7 7

45 -.5 4 !1+-+ 21 :+2-1.*

$ 46 3

4 52+ +26 35 + -@ 27 ,57

:5 *

32-720 7

++-.5 12#+721) +

+, ++-./010$ 23+"$ 2!2112

5* :52-1.45 677

5 4 $ 4

46 4 7 45 7'8 ( 7

% 7 "

&7 7

7 '8 ( '8 ( M' 5

-!2-1

2,, 262+ -.

#12 673 2 5 20 42

7+ 45 012 . 67 0 :2 &352* 3 J!+

#+721::7 ;0 +0

B< 2+ , :5 7

+ 62152250 :5 ;2< 8'

8 ;8< L'L'J 2** 10 29 ,*127

-72002+

:5* 7*1;!* 2<+712 +-.5$

C-1*@ 72 1+2$%# & %!

'6(-.5#+721 ) +352 0+245755 46 3++

-+5*

3 0 1+ 5 0.3++029* 10

, : 3 5 +712

: 124 A!+,0 ;!* 2< 52 5 -.5 2* !0*

525 7!

, :52++2 422G!1 :

: 673 -:26 2-1.

+ 4+6265 *

85 !,5 5 2+ * !0*

-!2-1-!5

! 12+6+ 7 -!52+* !0*

-720 72 !*

5 *

$ 46 3 5 2+ 72 6+ 2++!7 ,+752 , ,

!6265 *

3 :

7 , 1.

-! ,52+* !0*

3-! 2!

211.21 ++722

+!.21 !*

5#+721) +3 ,2,1: 5 +26 2 5 ,3 5

!,5 0*1 .0 : 5 2 : -1 79 752

, 7 72!21 7

75 G!;<3 45 -. 02. -720

261+525

, :5+2

52 0.*

13 -720 7+:

02 7+ 21, 7:201.5

5 -.4221 -2+ 50+721 *

352 5+2-!:

2411:

0+ 2

4227

, 21+2 +-720 5 2,, 262+-.

-7202 012 67 ? $ 46 32 2+ , : *

;!* 2<3+71 5252 - 7

++ 2 .*+:

02 +

526- 7

++ 5 @ ;!* 2< 2+1.3 7

6+ 7 -! 5 * !0*

;!* 2<52- 1+-.5*

35 -.35 7

2 ,6

4,52, 5 *

:50+721- +3 2 @ 27+ ;!* 2<

*7!

!1.3 5 -.

7 + 7 72 - 2, 5!* 211

0+ 2

3-+5 -.5

:5+272

-2+ -2G!1 :2 7+ 21, 7 :201.5

1.3 -+712 2 :

:012 67 2++

3 -+712

-2 -!2-1

,2,, 262+-.

:012 67 -.5* *

B !

5 3 7 0 :5A!+,0 +-.5 *@ 3 721+29

!"# B

&+ )*: 45 32+712

02+ 5 @ 3525- : :

+ , ::3 52 0 + 4+ 57

+!12 1.21 5 !

2 +:2-1 ,5 -720 6+ 5 * *

5 9 , G!2 5 2**

+ , ::- ,02+ 5:26

'6 5 4 7 5 +712

: 124 02+

+7;!* 2<02952++712

-2 @* !12

:124 035 -.35@* !12

:124 03202+ 6 +7 ;!* 2<21 02955 !

+- :626 5 +: 7 *

1 7

+3 3 3 21 1 5

+35! 22 .095, , :5 + 40 2 02+5 !

32 +52

3 5:!117 0*10 32*1 5 !

3-+

*76 :5-2 3:2 .3 :+12.2 +1275

85 :

3 5 , , : 5 - : : 5 2**

+ , ::3 0 :56 +7;!* 2< +-.58 -!

+321 +

!:: :

02 .11,21.2 + - !*51+

&( 2 56"5#$!8&'#15! 2: 02535 : +

0 54 *

+45 - 62

263520+0+ 850*!, +

32*2+-.512

+8 -!

+302 2 +2 +2:: 0+ & * + :21

,45211* + ,2**172

;<3:2 . .

. /

. + * %L 55 *29 ,= 2

+ / M=

55 *

2-1 / M=