Devinder Singh And Others v. Financial Commissioner & Secy. Urban Estates, Haryana And Others





    
 


 

 

! "# $% %"



!

& '
((

" #"") %"

* +  

    !"#  $ %"&    !"# '"& (")%" " 

"#(%# ,-!, "%+  "- ./"',- '-!,0 "',1")  " 2% .%",-

-!0 "',1") 

$ %"&*  3%+ %" %!%'' $%4/ 5%" %6 -4/ -, 

%",7% -75

/ 8 83%' 5 /$%9 4/" "%!'+(  /': %" "(("'" #"  " '"#"

8 ,;$%", "<(/ $" % -5

/ 6"

  /

'  "  %  + /9(  %  % 4/ 4/ % '+  ') -  %  9

/  +""    %   (     %  *$%    &"

(+

3"

+" ) 6 -4/ ,*%9' * '( -, 8 " %",7% 8-7= "(  8-,  4/ % 9%"/ "%'-,

('),% -,5%% 5%

/ 

%" = %+"  , % - 5 

/3%

/% 9 $  9)&/''> % 
/" 
8   
 

         ?2/$( 8  ,% 9 +  % ')% 5%" % -% 9

/+"" ,% /"%"+" 9""

"( 8-, "%"+'  - #  8- "+"/%"/ "

@

 +&#," "!"-# & #! ./ .012  %    &

&  !  %'

 - &  "  # !" #

3 5% $   )% $     

% -, )

/ "%6 -4/ -, 

 ,@  5%" 5"/ "    6   -4/  -  %  9  (,  % ,  ''

+"!

-"' $%"(

(+

%''++')A" 95%" 5"/ "   % 9

(,% /%+" %''  // "% +"!

6 -4/ -,

-% 9 "+'B 3% '+ C+"

9)%&/''> % 
/"

 

 /+", C"9'5 @  3%  +"  +/"

/   

%' -"'( ')

"+/"+  / $+"'( ") 4/") "") $  /  %  /"!)    /9')   %  ' +"+     9  4/"  > ,  ++"   % ' %++"+"0!"

( D 

8 4/"%'  %%) '92

,

) '

%"%92

9 &"%+/"+ +)(  (+

, % %'  - 9. "%+/"+ C $% "9+ "+/9'  ' +" ": %""  /"%""



, 9 , %"" ' %  $,% " ( ') "

 ' 3%" ",! %/$% %  %'  - . % "%"( "  (+

9/  !"%'

  9 . %  "% ' -3%+" "4/  9 9  ') "/++'

( 5%% $ '"

%' -  3%6$ '/"9)#  %5

8-% +"! "%' +"

(%!'+  " "%'  -= +"!% 5% $ )%   8- ) %' 4/ E D/ "%'  -5%" 5"/ %" %9

(,% ''%+"!

8- "' $"( (+

"++') 3%++'9') %+"!

8 - "+)(  (+

5/' ')9

+" "%' -%9  9 " 5%% %++ ) "%

"(  8-  3%++'9')  #   %5

8-5%%'

5%"+'  ! '"

%C  ! $ %%' - %''



"+'3%

 #/9#   %

! %"5 +"! 8-,% "+'  / "  #/9  #    %''    9  %'   +"2/"

%$ "'++'

% 0
-*+' (" ("

"(9/ /9 + $ % 

%  6$ '/"  =  %      %"

C+"

')"9) 

")(+' 8 -5 9"$"5+

%' - 5%'')" +"% 5/'9 '"   "+'3%"+' " + %' - '

" #/9#   5 8-+"! A%5!",9)#/9#   +"2/"

%$ "'++'

% 0
-  3%  5  8  -  +"! "  !"'

 (+""),  +"$"

!     '')  9 '

'$ '!( /" 9". $5) "(%

%+ "%'5 +"! (% ( "( '  (+     +/9'  +/"+ 5%% %" %' -3%5 8 - 9' 5" +"! $ "%9 '

+"!

'$ ' %' 5% ' /$%94/" %%)$%9 

% 5'$ '! +

3%

// ' -9 "%++ )  "%5 8-5/'  /"(

+"! "( #   0
- ') %+" "%'    -  %!  9  E D  9 "    5%%5/'9%%"% 9 /++'

(  ''59)'" ' -

 $ - +/9' %/ '     -    %  

'  0:  9/    %

5 ++"'" "%(( (  %5

8-  5/' 9 9'

'5 %'  /%+/9' %$! /%+/9'  9. % +/9'  %    =   ')    % +/9' %'  % 9

%%"5 %

+" 

 9'%( '92

% 3%%" $ 92

@- %+/9' ' -5/' 9+"(

9' " "+'

 "(( (  8- "(   %+"

9 %! 9 E D/ "%' - % '"  / "  #  %"  %    9

/  ')5% %'"

/% %' +"

9 %!9

E D= %"5" , '"

"( %' -   9 " ,%'



9 %!9  %" ", 5/''+ 9)!"/  %5

8-B 6"

/

' "%#  +/% "  '$'+   -5 

/

%+"   %"5 "( )$" 9)% 
/" - "%" $'"

/

' "%+" 

" % /9(

9! %!5C+"

9)&/''> %

/"  

 /+", /"!5,% "

# % -,8 8,% '+ 4/%+ , '" % -%9

/ 15!",%# %''9'9")%"  " % +" "4/ " $5%%' +/"% $F" $%'  " 5%'5, %' 

4/  "4/"  "  (+'   )  +"2  "  %"5   3% + %''( / 4/"$" $%'  4/ " +" C( %  9'%#. -''%"

/

"  %5"+ "' + 
/"% C+"

 ) + %"  3%5"+  +  " $') *2 %> ' ;/$  

0/"! "# $%0'' !

;/$ %%" +. $F"  < F %%"*+"9' < F