High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4886/2014allowed

Pale Ram Kandhal v. Central Bank Of India & ORS

2017-02-28Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan12 pages

!"#"

$% & & '

(

) *$ +(

,&&

$ - .

-#/# $ -( $0

$ " $

-# ,, #1 $ $ # 2% $34(

2-&/# "!

*/( "1 5"$6+

!

"

!

*/( "1 5"$6+7 & 8-(9 # # !

#

$

% & ' ()(*(

,+-# ((*) +

#

"

-

( + .

" #$%&#'()&* + ,)-.

$

/ 0123 3

#/

"

#4 $&#'()&* + -

.

$5

5 16 7

, ,

0123 3%

03386 03621&& '9!

6636* + :

;

( " #4 $%&#'()&* + ,)-.

%$5

:

&/ 5

" 1 #$%&#'()&*.

$ + ,#%,-

%# %/ "

%

#) , 9

770

00 ")" 5

< /'0 $ %

+#

,+-

+

,+- +"

,+- ((1(*) #

) 2 3#

(

2 3

1 2 - 34

# +

-

+

)5(*)

6+ 7 #

#

+

-

+ + 1

$

% &

8"- 9/

+

:7;

9 +

:7;9# " +

#

+

#

+# +

#

+

# -

"

" +

!+ ,+

-"

6+ <

"

#

!+ ,+

-

# +

;:(*)

6+ (#

+

+ -+ !

1; -"

0 -

:7(

90 -

:7(9 #

$

% & 8"-

) 0 -=+ + :75

90 -=+ + :759

"

"

+

+ ""

-

#

+

-

-

# +

-

)5(*) >#

#

+ 7;

0 -

:7( #

0 -=+ + :75

--

4 # 5- -

;:(*)

6+ ( +"

-

6+ )

"

"+ <*(*)

6+ 1#

#

-

-

+

04 ' (*

+

%& +

>"$

<;

+ + 1;?1; 0 -

:7( + (

0 - =+ + :75

-

-

<*(*)

6+ 1 #

-# & "

+ + &

#

,+- "

-

&

-

-"+

*

+ !

1; 1; 0 -

:7( #

( 0 -=+ +

:75 &

+ + 1

+

:7;

-

"@

+ 1; + (# +

#

- & +

+-

+

"

-

#

+

#

+ A # 6

) + -

(#

1#

- 4 #

+

#

6

4

(# " + +

B

#

+

+

$ 1#

""

+ - ?

%@ & +

<)<*

" (

$?$ #

+

# "

-

,+- )5(*)

6+ 7

# -

6

# + 4

+

?

%@& +

+

>C

+ "

+

-" # - ,+ -

AD/&

# - )5****?.

"

+

-"

A

4 #

,+- #

+ -

#

6

-

+

-

#

4

+ - +

+ + 1; 0 -

:7( #

+ ( 0 -=+ +

:75 + 1; + ( + + .

1'2* ;

'*; '*

%

5 5

%

%

%

%

=

'* 1>

?;

' * 5

5

5 @ ' * 5

5

5 5 % 5

< A9

5

5 %

%=

+

=

+

+ 1;

#

- - " -

# +"

+ -"

+

-

"- + -

6

"

+ !"- + (

#9 " 9+ - "

+

&

# + ;:(*)

6+ (

#

"

#"+

-

#

+

+

-

)5(*)4 -

# +

-

)5(*)4

# + ;:(*)

6+ ( + + .

;

B

,+

5 3 0 9 1'2*

4

. /% 86 ",+

9 C D. E %863%

95

5%, +

3

5 % D5

A#

"+ <*(*)

6+ 1

"

+

6

(*

04 ' <;

+

?

%@ & +

%

>"$

4

"

# +

+

# + # -

+

6+ (

6+ 1 ,+

& -

+ > +

#

+

)5(*)#

+

,+-

6+ 7>

"

#

+ -

#

6

# -

,+- ># +

,+

#+ #

-

- + -

E

+ 1; + ( +

#

# " 9 + 4 #9 " 9

0 -

:7(

0 -=+ + :75&

+

"

" " "

+

-

4

+

>#

,+

#+ #

-

" " E &

- 4 "

# 6" -

$+ D$% / $&5 ("-,+

002'1*&"

6%# + .

6 &

5

12

&5

AF B12'*C5

%

AF * * *

5

5,+@ *

5 @ *

5 =

0

5 < ,

12'*'*

55

+

/ %

% % 5 % 0

5

<

9 5 " 12'*'*

5

0

5 %

=

5

'

*

9

%

5

12'*'*

&5 5 +

5 :

+ 5

5

!

,+/ %

;1

%

%

% 5 5

5 !

9

%

5 5 !

G

5 H 12 '*'*

&5

9

G

5 H

5

5 5 %

= 9

% 5

5 5

5 C5

:

5

>&! ! #5 +

5 # "

. , % I

88 '*&"183?A>88 '*&"

30'&"*?A"

: D

5D

5

9

59

: 12 '*'*

&5 "

% 5%

9 -

J

12

&5

5

=

5

E %

12

;+

C . E

= 5

+ & 5

AF B.

* '* '* 5 '*

5 ,+ '* 5

,+% A *- A -

37 %

D

5 5 % =

3 D *-5 ,+D

5

5 ,+%

0 D 5 ,+D

% %

,+<

0+

AF B0'*

5 5

,+%

=

'*

5

5

5 5 5 %

<

% %

5

5 5 :

:

5 9 5

5 5

5

# &5

5

5 4

+ " 3

"

4

5

%

5 % 5

%

%

'

*9

5 % 5%

9 %

# &5

@

= 5 K D & "

("- ,+5&#% 001 L9 " 63 A > 001'*& 2 8'&"*? 5

# &5 5

/

K

/ % 5

12

;+

; 59 %

: 5 5

5

/

% 5

5

% %

(

C >: (**;

@+"

#

"

-/ %

$+ ((**

#9 " 9+

+

+

"

-

4

-

+ # 9 " 9

,+

-

+ 1; 0 -

:7( + (

0 -=+ + :75

#

+

+ -

#

6

4 "+

"

#

# +

#

# 4 "+

# + ;:(*)

6+ (

# -+

<*(*)

6+ 1 - ,+

,+

-

#

F:G

+" "

-"

#

#"

"

-

& & '

8*/( "1 5"$6+9 +

/ 6

? I

I