Sat Pal Devgan v. B.S.N.L. And ANR.













 

 !"
#$
"%&'&#(
)**
+,&
 !
 -
"./ (0
-1
, (
,2"!0

,(
, (0
&'!,&%!
3,&!' ,


4"!&!&#(",

.",'5'
+ , !
 (%+ ,
&/ 3
6!1
(1
(#!+",
4*"'7#(1"(!'

#, 3
)

#(89-"
,*
5'!&%"
**
: -&
,"'"(!
)

,*
 +5-
+ ,3 0

 

*

,*
,7 -
&(/+0
1.#% !"
$#,

,*
**
+ ,3 0
1.#% !"
$#,
!+"
,"'7#(1"(!'*
;;;
**
: -& 0
*
, -

6" ,("1
3&%5'
5,& "
%#(!"(1'
!+ !
!+"
%+ --"(/"
&(
!+"
&('! (!
,"/5- ,
'"%#(1
77" -
&'
!#
1&'3&'' -
#$
&.&-
77" -
#*
#$
<
&(
% '"
!&!-"1
'
=
  

 
       

8
.&1"
>51/3"(!
(1
1"%,""
7 ''"1
9?
!+"
-" ,("1
11-*
&'!,&%!
51/"0
3,&!' ,
1 !"1
**
@+&-"
$$&,3&(/
!+"
>51/3"(!
(1
1"%,""
7 ''"1
9?
!+"
-" ,("1
&.&-
51/"
5(&#,
&.&'&#(0
3,&!' ,
&(
&.&-
5&!
#*<A
#$

#(
**<0
1"%,""&(/
!+"
'5&!
#$
!+"
,"'7#(1"(!'7- &(!&$$'
(1
+#-1&(/
!+"3
"(!&!-"1
!#
,"%#.",'*A0BCD
-#(/
@&!+
&(!","'!
E
F
7",
((53
@&!+
"$$"%!
$,#3
!+"
15"
1 !"
!&--
!+"
$&-&(/
#$
!+"
'5&!
(1
$5!5,"

  
&(!","'!
E
BF
7",
((53
$,#3
!+"
1 !"
#$
$&-&(/
#$
!+"
'5&!
!&--
," -&G !&#(
#$
!+"
"(!&,"
1"%,"! -
3#5(!
-#(/
@&!+
%#'!'*





6" ,("1

  

,"$",'
!#
#,1",
1 !"1
*C*
(#!&(/
!+"
,/53"(!
1. (%"1
#(
9"+ -$
#$
!+"
77"-- (!1"$"(1 (!
&(
!+"
-&/+!
#$
1"%&'&#(
&(
= 
  

  80
  0
+#-1&(/
!+ !
&(
'5&!'
$&-"1
9?
!+"
6
$#,
,"%#.",?
#$
#5!' (1&(/
15"'
$#,
5'"
#$
!"-"7+#("0
!+"
7",&#1
#$
-&3&! &#(
&'
!+,""
?" ,'
(1
(#!
!+&,!?
?" ,'
'
7",
,!&%-"

#$
!+"
6&3&! &#(
%!
'
/ &('!
%#(!"(!&#(
#(
9"+ -$
#$
!+"
,"'7#(1"(!'
!+ !
3 !!",
9"
1>#5,("1
!#
@ &!
1"%&'&#(
#$
6
9?
#(89-"
57,"3"
#5,!*

#1 ?0
-" ,("1
%#5('"-
$#,
!+"
,"'7#(1"(!'
$ &,-?
%#(%"1"1
!+ !
6
$&-"1
9?
!+"
6
/ &('!
!+"
$#,"3"(!&#("1
1"%&'&#(
@ '
1&'3&''"1
(1
!+"
1"%&'&#(
&(
   

% '"
'57, 
'
1"%&1"1
9?
!+"
5(> 9
(1
,? (
&/+
#5,!
+ '
!! &("1
$&( -&!?0
!+","$#,"0
&(
!+"
%&,%53'! (%"'0
!+"
77" -
+ '
!#
9"
--#@"10
'
!+"
%&.&-
'5&!
@ '
$&-"1
9?
6
#(
*A*
$#,
!+"
7",&#1
7",! &(&(/
!#
!

+"
7",&#1
?0

!#
 (5 ,?0
*
A
(
.&"@
#$
!+"
7#'&!&#(
(#!"1
9#."0
'
@"--
'
'! "3"(!
#$
-" ,("1
%#5('"-
$#,
!+"
,"'7#(1"(!'0
&!
&'
+"-1
!+ !
'5&!
$#,
,"%#.",?
'
$&-"1
9?
!+"
6
$#,
,"%#.",?
#$
#5!' (1&(/
15"'
$,#3
!+"
77"-- (!
1"$"(1 (!
$#,
5'"
#$
!"-"7+#("
%#5-1
+ ."
9""(
$&-"1
@&!+&(
!+,""
?" ,'
#$
%%,5 -
#$
% 5'"
#$
%!&#(
(1
(#!
!+&,!?
?" ,'
5(1",
,!&%-"

#$
!+"
6&3&! &#(
%!
'
@ '
!+"
'! (1
#$
!+"
6
#(
!+"
9 '&'
#$
@+&%+
!+"
'5&!
@ '
$&-"1*

%%#,1&(/-?0
!+"
H5"'!&#(
#$
- @
,"$",,"1
9#."
&'
('@","1
&(
$ .#5,
#$
!+"
77"-- (!
(1
/ &('!
!+"
,"'7#(1"(!'
&(
.&"@
#$
!+"
1"%&'&#(
#$
#(89-"
!+"
57,"3"
#5,!

 80
   *




I
(
!+"
%&,%53'! (%"'0
!+"
77" -
&'
--#@"1
(1
5&!
1&'3&''"1*
#@".",0
7 ,!&"'
!#
9" ,
!+"&,
#@(
%#'!'*


       **
 !

"#  $"

"



%&'

(  ) * '+( $"

"



(  ,   ) * '+(