Mohinder Singh And ORS v. Ut Of Chandigarh And ORS




    
   


!"#$#%&'&()* +&($#,-&(.+!($"+#,'

 #"&"&(#,'

/'

(&(#,,&",01+!($.&!,+!($"+#,'

 #'2($#("'

,!3) (456#,7'"&%# !8##/-+!,3!

(456#,7'"&%#!,&($#,-&(.+-&$+7

,#'#(")9 ,!,8#'+&""!61$/%!"# ,"+#2#"&"&(#,' ,'##2!6& 7,&1$/%!"# ,,#'2($#("'": 
 

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

'72,! D ,'  ##2!6&  7,&1  $/%!"#  !22#!,&(.  (  5#+!6   ,#'2($#("'":+!'!&,60$,!;("+#!""#("&("+&'#(%+""+# 26&%0<'%+#3#$!"#$>>:,#.!,$&(.,#.76!,&C!"&((;,?%+!,.# 5!'&'    ;,?3#(  ;,?&(.  &(  /!,&7'  $#2!,"3#("'    "+#  +!($&.!,+ $3&(&'",!"&( ;+&%++!'5##(!$2"#$50"+#7(&%&2!6,2,!"&( +!($&.!,+ #+!/#.(#"+,7.+"+#26&%0<'%+#3#;+#,#&(&"&''"!"#$ "+!""+##3260##';,?&(.7($#,,72'!($'+!665#,#.76!,&'#$( "+#5!'&'6#(."+'#,/&%#
(,$#,"+!/#2#,3!(#("'67"&(5#0($ '!(%"&(#$'",#(."+1"+#+!($&.!,+$3&(&'",!"&(;!',#B7&,#$"3/#! 2,2'!6"%,#!"#"+#2'"'5#,#"+#/#,(3#("
($&! ,'  ##2!6&  7,&  '753&"'  "+!"  "+#  7(&%&2!6  ,2,!"&( +!($&.!,++!'("3/#$"+#%!'#5#,#"+#/#,(3#("
($&!

  







E#!,(#$,&57(!6+!',$#,#$,#.76!,&C!"&("+#2#"&"&(#,' !'2#,"+#!/!&6!5&6&"0"+#/!%!(%&#'
";!'#A2#%"#$"+!""+#7(&%&2!6 ,2,!"&(1+!($&.!,+;&663/#!2,2'!65#,#"+#/#,(3#("
($&!"%,#!"#!$$&"&(!62'"'!""+##!,6&#'" %%,$&(.601"+#2,#'#(";,&"2#"&"&(&'$&'2'#$;&"+! $&,#%"&(  "  "+#  7(&%&2!6  ,2,!"&(1  +!($&.!,+<+!($&.!,+ $3&(&'",!"&(""!?#72"+#3!""#,;&"+"+#/#,(3#("
($&!, %,#!"&(2'"';&"+&(!2#,&$'&A3("+',3"$!0
"&'3!$#%6#!,"+!"&(%!'#"+#$#%&'&(&'(""!?#(;&"+&("+# '"&276!"#$2#,&$!',$#,#$+#,#&(!5/#1"!?&(.&(" %('&$#,!"&("+# 6#(."+'#,/&%#"+#2#"&"&(#,'1"+#0'+!665#$##3#$"5#,#.76!,&C#$ ;&"+!66%('#B7#("&!65#(#&"'

 !8##/-+!,3! 7$.#  !,&($#,-&(.+-&$+7 * 7$.# $&(#'+ +#"+#,'2#!?&(.<,#!'(#$ #'

 +#"+#, #2,"!56#) #'<