High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2851/2016dismissed

Sudharshan v. Mundra Delhi Pipeline Pariyojna

2017-01-27Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal,Mr. Justice Hari Pal Verma6 pages

!"# "# # $#! !

#%"&% #'( ) ! #%! #&# "# *& !"#$ %&'()!*+,-.) "/)+0-%1"( %&'()!*+,-.)"!- "(2)!#"

#&+,%' -.$- #"& # #. .##-.$- ##&

"/)+0-%1"(3

/"##0%%& 1!

" 0#& 1# 2

3- 4- -

- - 4- - 3- 5 3

- %0 # $%$ "# )0$#-" "$1 + #

5 ,# %'-" "#"7$# 8 - #' #%! !#%7-0%"-! !

# 5 "#%! #%&% .6! *2" 9# : .- 3 #"#-;".;-

4-&!1%"

4- #6!# 2#2"!% ! "#$ !

,"!#2#"- # <"((# /" & !"#'- :- ):- ,"!#2#" # "#- ;" & !"#'; $ %#

- ! " & # % 1( - 1! 1( 0# %/" & !"#'$0# 3

- " #+$%! = -

>?&## 0""0# " & !"#'-"% # %&&% 1 #"%# . %#<!2-0"$0# " #+ $%! " 6!# % = -

>? &# # 6! %'0# & &#".8"0#0""

"1 &!2 "&# 0#& 1'"% # 4 : !

% #"& #!1 ""$%!

"% -0"""& % #1 2! #!#1 @ -" 1

&#&#%'1'"%# !#1%0/" & !"#' 0%%"%# !#1%0"$ %0# & " & # % !!#% #&" 0" "&&% 01%

" "# " - %# !

% # #&

!1 " " & # " % ' 1( #2# $%! 8 - 6!

% - #"# %' #2" ! " 1 + # %' 2 !

#2#!

&#%! &&% /" 0 #"& " % # 0" " % #/"'#%1#'2#0#& /"!-"# % /"& #"#$" & 0"! '

&#/"#0 A 2 "#$# '

#& 0 A 2 " % ! " %' 2 !

#2#!

&&% - & 0 & #% #&) !#"# !1 " " " - $ 0%/"%# !#

5 1%0"%#'0#"2"# & "& #0"! "#1 2 '$ %#2# 2$%! /" #$1 # #0" )#%# !

% #"&# &#!"&&# 1+

.&#"" ".-" #%7$# &0#!

# 5"# A&# 6!##2" !# '% #"&!#& # &# &#%! #% &#! # &% "# .

#!#$' "# 1( - %%# !

# ". 3 ".&##1## #2# 2!

% !

# ".

".%0"

& &'1%"% # & 1 2-%# (!#! 1' '&# # !

# 0"" " &&% &#& 1 % 8 - " & &'1%=

B "$%! -#2"

(' 0"""1 + /"$%!"1- " ! !

# 5 "./" "1 1'" & !"#' !

# ".8 -" !

# 1'" & !"#' &1%"# " &#-"'"%%"$#2" %&&% 1 #"#<!2 0" "% 0"(!# # '&#"# !/" "#<!2 % #

4 3 /"!#1'"& # "&# 1!

& #2# 2$%! - 6! 0"""'

0!%1 %"2"# & #

4 " .C!#"#&#'# # 2 A 2 % #&

. #$%! # -!

&!%' $ "1 %1'"% #"0""$%! 1'" & !"#'0 (! #/"% " "$%! 0 -

>?-0 #%' 0" ##1#$! #'$ " # %?# "#08 "1 "# -"% 1'"% #"" $%! 1"2"##" 0"01'" & !"#'!% 1&)0$#-"%# !# 1%0 " (! # & 6! % #C#"&!#&-#% 0&%!&

"&%'!1'"7$# 3

&#$ 2 # ! #10# #6!

# &%

"/"&%'0&&%1% %%0"#"0#0

1'"%%# # # 3

8 "&# -" & !"#'"

0# 3

/"1( " &%'0!

# %'"$%! "6!#% #!" %2 % 2#% !& " #&%'-"%# !# 1%0-2 -

>?&##1'"%%#-" "$%! = -

>?&##/"#& &"0# "%# !#1%0 &# # '&&%

. "#$ ##- !#$0-"0# "%# !#1%0

11## !-%% 2 # # # 1'" !# #"$%! #

. ##2! #2# 2&'

#1'"& # # - %'- "#0 $ %1'"& #"#1 #" & !"#'#1 #"!#1%0,% % " ' "1 %" #"#0 '% #&-

1&- " - " % 1' " & # " !

%%'

C#"# 1$-0 " ' ! # # # "0# "%# !#1%0/" 0#& ## 2%'

5 , # &# 2 0" " ##- !# & - " # #6!# # 1'"!"#' # &#$# '

&&% 2 " 0# 1' " # <!2 # 2 " & -0"" '1 6! #2"!#

#1'"% ## 1"" !

"1 $ %1'"&#/"!2"

".&#$""&#$ # #2

'"#%0 #" 1 2 ##% 26! - "0$#

".&#$"" "# <!2 !

# !1? # !1? "# "%% 1 % 2"#1'- # ' &&%##$ . #"&!#&

A 2 " ## " 0# " # <!2- # $ '"$1#?&&#8 1#1 %#

&#$ #!

#": .6! .- 34#!

#"*2" C# & /# &# ' : .6! -*"1%

*% .-

5/" # 1A

4 &' "##1 #& *(", % <!2

)#%D# $ <!2 ""#&+ 2># E> ""#*&#1% E>