← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2055/2009dismissed

M/S Subhash Woolen Mills Pvt. Ltd v. Ashok Singh & ORS

2015-12-18Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal16 pages

     

!" "#$%$&'( 

)%*"+,* %*-."&$..%/!0!1 22".. &!

3% %*4$&5* &1!*"6% "%2&1"&!% '



    

   

    

 

  



 





   

    

  !" #"

  $ ! 

 

%%%%         ! "#

$%  &'%(!)* +  # %  )* ,

&'%(!) '

%#%-).-( *

  /

&'( 

 

 )"    *+ *, -**.





# 0" 

"   



 )"    '1 *2 -**3 



0" 40 # 5

"   &-(   "  )" 

  

"

 

/     /" 

"

-'

6 '2  

 

 

 "

/ 7  /     "  

/     &2( 

   "

  8 "/ 6)

 # 9

/ "   "  "  # &,(      ) 6"    

"

  

" 

"

-3 6 .

 0" '.3:



 -, 12  ;



"

'*     1','

;

    

 /"

 <  '+ 23  ;

 /

 

"

'3     '*,13 ;

 &:( ""    7"   

7"   -+ *, '.3:

 -  ''

   ':,2 ;

 

  2+***=>   /  '*     1','

;

 0/ 6"   ,    '.21 ;

      -+ *, '.3:



  23***=>   /   +    2+3- ;

 0 6"  ,  -    -,+'

;

      -+ *, '.3:



  ,1:**=>   /  +  ,    ,.1'

;

   ) 6"  -  ',    '12, ;

      -+ *, '.3:



  2****=>   /  -  '

   '12, ;



&1( @    "

3:., ;

  7"

  "  -*':**=> "

 ;"

"  ':+32=> "

 " 7    "       

 )"   ':':**=>  "  1:+32=> 

 "

  

 /  &3(

  A '

   =

$ 8

    7 

)





  "

 7"  





"

2:'* ;

   :

 '1  

/  =  B  

)

= $ 8



/  "   = $ 8



  

A '

 '*    .*1 ;

 /

 A -  /    / 7" 

 > 0" '.3:

 /" 

" 

 '

 '* 

-'*C 3'C    

 &+(

 7"   

 

  



    A '



"

 '-  

  " 

 "  ,.2,*=>   7 "  )" 

'

 '*  

  '1:+2=>

   "



   ,.2,*=>





 "

  

 

  "   7 /  "  12.:+=> &.( D 7"      )"

/ 

 > 

 

  0"

'.3:

 "" " 

  

 &'*(  

" 7"  

 /"  "

  7    )



 =   B  

   >  #      B /

" "  /  &''( "

/ 

" #  

"

"

"

 

  

"  )        7" 

 "  

  

  

 

 -3 6 .

   -, 12  ;



/    "

 

#     

  7"    

#  

   

"  )   

     



 " " &'-(   7"

 "    7  / / 

 

  7 "

/  

  "  1:+32=> 

"

   

@

/ 



"

2:'* ;

 /  =  B  

)

= $ 8 @

/  .*1 ;



 /  "

 

 0" '.3:

 " /" 

"

'

6

'* 

 " "

-'*C -3'C  

:

" 

" 

"  &'2( #

  "  ,.2,*=>  7 "

 )" 

"

'

 '*  "

 '1:*2=> @

/ 

 

"

 

  " #

     /   12.:+=> 7"  &',( #     



   7"     # 

  

/   &':(

 

  



"   

">

                

  

&'1(



" A -

-   '+ *, '..+ ">

!

               

( "#  $          # %    &           ' # $ ' $( )             

     *+, !  - !

 &'3(  

    "    &'+( ?

" " " A ' - -



  " > @" A -   > " " A -   ?

"  "   )" 

 

 "

>  

/   > 

/ 7 " "

 ?

"  "   >

/ 

 &'.( #  

 )"    

" 

"  7



  )"





 "

 



)"    *+ *, -**. / 

  

" " " A ' - -

"  )"  &-*(





 



"/

;"

  A '+

"  >

.

      "        /

!   )             ( .

   #" "#      0 223    '      /

! ) ' '   #'"'#"(  .

  ($#450 

   6           "

  (  '   (.

  ( "#  ' $  #  (.

     "

"' -)  1 )) (.

          (    

 

  ('"

  #"#  ($ 

7

, 5!  - !

'" ('  "#

 (.

     

      

   '     8          $ &-'( @



  " / 

 "  &--(

  "





 7

 >7 #B>1 # 

!    



 

 "  "/)  > 9       

 /  > -3  .

  

 >

 "  9    7 

   :

 '1 

 "   &-2(

  "



 "   " 

E7 B:='

  

/   /    "

/   "  "

 

A '1 E7 B1=-  > 

  -, *' '.+3 '' 2*              "/)  

   

  

  /" 



     / 

 '2     





;"   

 8@

&-,(

  "



   "  #B>3

 

 



"    'F 

   

   >

 

 /" 

"   @

>7 



   7   "/  /"  

   

 9    /"   7  

 " /" 

 /"  '.+*

"  D    /" 

 &-:( D 



  "

= "/ 



  /   

 C    

 /" 

 

9  

  "

  "  "/

6)

B>+ 

 /  " > E7B+='



 

 " 

 

 0" '.3:

 



   -, 12  ;

 



/

   7  '+ 23  ;

   

 /  A    

 A "      " E7 B2=2 "

 /  2****=> "      "

/"

 :#' "

E7 B+=, E7 B+=:

&-1( @ >7  



/ # >  '.31>33>3+

  

   



  "

B    A

 



;"     

 " 

"

7 '1:** ;

 



 >   "  7  "  -3 *' '.3:

 "

    "  / 9      "

  

0" '.3:

 "    



"

   D //  



 

 

 7

 "    >  

B    E7 B+=2

   8>'





   "  



"  A  

/ &-3( 8 /     

 /   /  "





 "



 " 

 "  &-+( ;" "

   "     "/ 6)

B>+  "  /  " G" A 45 ;"  G"

8 A 45

 7      "/ 6)

B>+

/

    "





  /  

B>+  

 /7

 7

 "  >  

;  "   

" /" 

9 

  " /  > D    "     /   7  ;" A 45   &-.( G" A 45 ;"  D



/ 







 " E  "      "  /  7  "  -3 *' '.+:



 H>>H   A  /

   / "     /   "  -3 *' '.3:

  "   "

   D ,'

"

--







  

/

 / " "

&2*(   ;" A 45         /

D

/       B>+

  

/      :2>

? 

 4  C

C5        " 7  "  -3 *' '.3:

  

     "

H>>H  A      B>+  "  /  " 

   :2>



&2'(   / /  "         )"  &2-( @   "





 "

   )"





 "   )"      

"

 )       

9 "    " " D ,'

"

--  &22( "

  "     

 

 #/ '+ -*':

  !