High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24037/2017dismissed

Yaddin v. State Of Haryana & ANR

2017-11-10Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath5 pages

!"# !"# !"# !"#

$%& &'()(*+

$%& &'()(*+,&-.&/ ,&-.&/ ,&-.&/ ,&-.&/

$11(* &%(%(*&/ 2) %$%& $/3$*$$*1$*%4&/ &)5*1&*%) "+ "+ "+ "+6 7" 6 7" 6 7" 6 7"88" 88" 88" 88" /&)&*%+ "/$%()44$914$/301,'$%&0

/%4&5&%(%(*&/ "/$9/$.4"49*%$0 0$/3$*$ 88"0 7# 88"0 7# 88"0 7# 88"0 7# 4()5&%(%(*() (:&1 /)&&;(*<$=/(%(*%4&*$%9/& '&/%(/$/(

/>9$)4(*<%4&(-59<*&1/1&/)1$%&1 ? $*1?@ 4& 5&%(%(*&/ () %4& $/5$*'4 /$- $*'4$3$% 2(::$<& "$14(0&4)(:$<(*$0 ()%/('%940"&=$%*&$/9;4 %4&)$-&,(::$<& -$1&$'-5:$(*%$<$(*)%%4&5&%(%(*&/(*=4('4(*>9(/3=$)'*19'%&1.3 %4& (,(:0&/A59/4(/;$0$*1,(1&4()/&5/% @?1$%&1 B

9*1%4$%%4&5&%(%(*&/4$)*%5/19'&1%4&$*'4$3$%/&'/10/&<$/1(*< %4&$::&<&1%4& % %4&$*'4$3$%/&'/104&1(1*%<(,&$*3(* /-$%(*% %4&4(<4&/

('($:)$*1*()/&<()%&/&1=4('4)4=)4()'$/&:&))*&)) $*1 %4$% 4& 4$1 =(%41/$=* %4& $-9*% 5$(1 % %4& :$.9/ 9*1&/ %4& " '4&-& .3 /<(*< %4& 1'9-&*%) *)&>9&*%:30 4& =$) )&/,&1=(%4$)4='$9)&*%('&*@B %=4('44&)9.-(%%&1/&5:3 *@C $::&<(*<%4$%%4&/&'/1 %4&$*'4$3$%()=(%44()./%4&/

&&*"41$*11&*(&1%4&/$::&<$%(*)4& &59%3--())(*&/=$)

*%)$%() (&1=(%4%4&/&5:3$*1$

/1&15&/)*$:4&$/(*<%%4&5&%(%(*&/ 4&/&$ %&/0(%=$) 9*1%4$%4&4$)-()9)&14()5)(%(*$)$/5$*'4$*1 =4(:&&D&/'()(*<4()5=&/9*1&/&'%(*B %4&$/3$*$$*'4$3$%($E '%0 @@ F / )4/% G%4& '%6H 5:$'&1 4(- 9*1&/ )9)5&*)(* =4(:& $55(*%(*< ()%/('%&,&*9&

('&/094 /4:1(*</&<9:$/&*>9(/3/1&/ 1$%&1 ? 5$))&1 .3 /&)5*1&*% =$) '4$::&*<&1 .3 =$3 $55&$:0 (:&19*1&/&'%(*B B# %4&'%0.& /&/&)5*1&*%*%4& $55&$:$:)%4&)$-&</9*1)=&/&%$;&*.3%4&5&%(%(*&/%4$%%4&:1$*1 *&=/&'/1 %4&/$-$*'4$3$%4$).&&* /'(.:3%$;&*$=$3.34()/&$: ./%4&/$*1%4&)$-&5&/)*4$1=(%41/$=*%4&$-9*% %4&:$.9/9*1&/ %4& " '4&-& /- %4& 5)%

('& .3 /<(*< 1'9-&*%) &)5*1&*% 954&:1 %4& /1&/ /&)5*1&*% $*1 1(/&'%&1 %4&

()%/('% &,&*9&

('&/0 94 % '-5:&%& %4& &*>9(/3 =(%4(* *& -*%4

/-%4&1$%& /&'&(5% 4()/1&/&*'&0%4&5/&)&*%5&%(%(*4$).&&*

(:&1 4& 5&%(%(*&/ 4$) $55&*1&1 %4& %/9& %/$*):$%&1 '53 %4& $55:('$%(*$)**&D9/& (*=4('44&4$)59%%4&1$%&$) 4() $55:('$%(* () 59/5/%&1 % 4$,& .&&* -$1& % %4& %$%(* 9)&

('&/0 :('&%$%(*0$<(*$$*1(%()$::&<&1%4$%4&1(1*%/&<()%&/%4&'-5:$(*% $*1/&%9/*&1%4&)$-&%%4&5&%(%(*&/&4$)$:)/& &//&1%$:&%%&/ /&)5*1&*% =/(%%&* % %4&

0 $<(*$ 1$%&1 BC /&<$/1(*< (*(%($%(*<1()'(5:(*$/3$'%(*$<$(*)% (*"41$*1 $11(* * @ 0%4()9/%5$))&1%4& ::=(*</1&/+ I9*)&: /%4&5&%(%(*&/)9.-(%)%4$% &&* "41J $)(*0)4$J &&*"41$*1 $/9;4 J 49/9 &&* 4$1 /'(.:3 %$;&*

$=$3 :1 $) =&:: $) *&= /&'/1) %4& $*'4$3$% /- %4& 5&%(%(*&/ $*1 4& 4$1 :1<&1 $ '-5:$(*% % %4& %$%(* 9)&

('&/0:('&%$%(*$<(*$(*%4()/&<$/1 * 4&5&%(%(*&/()':$(-(*<4() (**'&*'&*%4&</9*1%4$%)(*'&%4&/&'/1 4$) .&&* %$;&* $=$3 /- 4(- .3 %4& $ /&)$(1 5&/)*) $*1 * 4$) .&&* /&<()%&/&1$<$(*)%%4&-1&)5(%&4()'-5:$(*% 1$%&1 0 %4&/& /&0 4& 4$) .&&* =/*<:359%9*1&/)9)5&*)(* (*'&%4&9/%()*='*'&/*&1$.9%%4& /&'/1 %4& $*'4$3$%0 $.9% =4('4 %4& 5&%(%(*&/ 4$1 -$1& $ '-5:$(*% *

0%4&/& /&0(*/1&/%$)'&/%$(*$) % =4$% () %4& 5/</&)) (* %4$% '$)&0 %4& %$%(*9)&

('&/0:('&%$%(*$<(*$ () 1(/&'%&1 % .& 5/&)&*% (* %4& 9/% * 1E9/*&1% .&)4=*(*%4&9/<&*%:()% '53 %4()/1&/.&<(,&*%%4&:&$/*&1 %$%&'9*)&:9*1&/)(<*$%9/&) %4&5&'($: &'/&%$/3 $%%$'4&1 % %4() 9/%0 / '-5:($*'&K

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

(*=4('44&4$)-&*%(*&1%4$%I $<(*$ / 9/%4&/5&/9)$:K 4&)$(1$55:('$%(*()$:)*%1$%&1 .9% 4&5&%(%(*&/4$)1&:(.&/$%&:3'*'&$:&1%4&$'%9$:1$%& /-%4()9/%$*1 4$)59%$ $:)&1$%&***&D9/& $) =4('4()%4&/=()&1&*(&1 .3%4&5&%(%(*&/*%4&</9*1%4$%(%=$)*:319&%)-&':&/('$:-()%$;& 4& 9/% 4$) %$;&* %4() (-5/&))(* %4$% (% () 1&:(.&/$%&:3 -&*%(*&1 $) .&'$9)&%4&/&5/%=$)-$1&.3%4& (,(:0&/A59/4(/;$ ,(1&/ @?1$%&1 B (*=4('44&4$1'$%&</('$::3-&*%(*&1 $.9% %4& %4& % $*'4$3$% /&'/1 $*1 / *% <(,(*< (* /-$%(* % %4& 4(<4&/

('($:)4=(*<4()'$/&:&))*&))4&5&%(%(*&/0(*/1&/%'/))%4& $ /&)$(149/1:& *%/&<()%&/(*<%4&'$)& %4& % %4&$*'4$3$%/&'/10 -&*%(*&1%4&1$%&$) =4('4()%4&/=()& 0-9'4$ %&/%4& /&5/% %4& (,(:0 )9.-(%%&1 .3 4(- % %4& &59%3 --())(*&/ 4&/&()$'$:'9:$%&1'*'&$:-&*% $'%)%4&5&%(%(*&/.3<(,(*<%4&=/*< 1$%&$*1-&*%(*(*<%4$%%4&'-5:$(*%**&D9/& =$)-$1&%%4&

B =4('4()%4&/=()&)9.-(%%&1%%4&

$)%4&/(<(*$:()=(%4%4&9/% (*=4('4(%())5&'( ('$::3-&*%(*&1 *,(&=%4&/& 0$- %4&'*)(1&/&15(*(*%4$%%4&/&()* &///*%4&5$/% %4&/&)5*1&*%)(*5$))(*<%4&(-59<*&1/1&/$<$(*)% %4&5&%(%(*&/$*14&*'&0%4&5/&)&*%5&%(%(*()4&/&.31()-())&1=(%4')% B

J=4('4)4$::.&1&5)(%&1.3%4&5&%(%(*&/=(%4%4&7&<$:&/,('&) 9%4/(%30"&=$%=(%4(*$5&/(1 %=-*%4)$*1(*'$)&%4&')%()*% 5$(1(*%(-&0%4&"&-.&/&'/&%$/307&<$:&/,('&)9%4/(%30"&=$%)4$:: (*(%($%&*&'&))$/3 $'%(*(*%&/-) %4&9*E$. 7$*1&,&*9& '%0 ??

() 9/%4&/1(/&'%&1%%$;&*&'&))$/3)%&5)(--&1($%&:3%/&',&/ %4&$*'4$3$%/&'/1) /-%4&./%4&/ %4&5&%(%(*&/ 88"# 88"# 88"# 88"# ,&-.&/

,&-.&/

,&-.&/ 0 0 0 0 4&%4&/)5&$;(*<J/&$)*&1

&)J 4&%4&//&5/%$.:&

&)J