M/S Happy Forgings Limited v. State Of Punjab & ORS

   
   
 

  !

"#$ %$&'(')*  

+


      

        
 * ,- .
. - ,- .
/ .-- 0$($)#* 01(2"32")4.$)'0%5&"#$6'#2 071 '##"74%5&"#$ 0#2$8$#'#')$0( 0."96"4%%'#')"7%5&"#$$)$0"74:)9";  "9$(2')%"7 2$8$#'#')$02"( "880"&2$%  #2'(&:0# 6'#2 " 80"3$0 0 %'0$&#')<#2$0$(8)%$)#(#<0")#$=$>8#') 0>8"3>$)# &$)#0"7("7$( #"=  :)%$0  #2$ 
$)#0"7  ."7$(  "=  &#4  ?@  ")%  :0#2$0  %'0$&#')<  #2$ ":#20'#'$(#0$ :)%#2$">:)# #"="70$"%38"'% 2$87$"%$%&"($ #2$8$#'#')$0'(#2"##2$8$#'#')$0'(')#2$ ;:(')$(( >"):

"&#:0')<&0")1(2"

#(")%2$"53 0<')<80$((7')$ 0:($ ;3>"):

"&#:0$( &>8)$)#(  0 :062$$7$0($<>$)## 808($%

 $=8")(') '#($='(#')<:)'#)#$0>( #2$)%:(#0'"77'&3

A4#2$ 8$#'#')$06"($)#'#7$%#&$0#"');$)$ '#()#2$$=8")%$%&"8"&'#32$ "887'&"#') '7$%;3#2$8$#'#')$0 0<0")# (8$&'"78"&1"<$ ')&$)#'5$( "(  "  >$<"  809$&#  6"(  "8805$%  ;3  #2$  '0$&#0    )%:(#0'$(  ")%
>>$0&$4:)9";5'%$>$>%"#$% A+

#')&7:%$%0$%:&#')

&$)#0"7("7$(#"= 0>BC# C 0@3$"0( 0>#2$%"#$ (#"0#

&>>$0&'"7  80%:&#')   #2$  $=8")%$%  :)'# <0$$>$)#  6"(  $=$&:#$% ;$#6$$)#2$8$#'#')$0")%#2$.#"#$)+




)&$((')"70"#$

&$)#0"7("7$(#"=6"()$ #2$')&$)#'5$(#62'&2#2$8$#'#')$06"( $)#'#7$%#2$&"($($#:8;3#2$8$#'#')$0'(#2"##2:<2(>$#2$0 &)&$((')(  6$0$  <0")#$%  #  #2$  8$#'#')$04  26$5$04  #2$  ;$)$ '#  

&)&$((')"70"#$ &$)#0"7("7$(#"=6"()#<0")#$%4"("0$(:7# 62'&2 #2$8$#'#')$08$0 0&$8"'%BC&$)#0"7("7$(#"=##2$.#"#$(#2$8"3";7$ 0"#$6"( C4'#%$($05$(0$ :)% AC2$(:;>'((')'(#2"##2$8$#'#')$0 6"()#"# ":7#4"(%$7"36"()#2$8"0# #2$.#"#$')<0")#')<#2$;$)$ '#

062'&2#2$8$#'#')$0(2:7%)#;$>"%$#(:

$0 #2$&)&$((')2"( )#;$$)<0")#$% 0#2$$"07'$08$0'%4'#&"))6;$<0")#$% 0"8$0'%

'5$3$"0( )#2$#2$02")%47$"0)$%&:)($7 0#2$.#"#$(:;>'##$%#2"# #2$.#"#$6"()#"# ":7#"#")3(#"<$2$8$#'#')$0 "'7$%# :0)'(2 0$D:'('#$') 0>"#')"##2$0$7$5")##'>$4"("0$(:7# 62'&22$&:7%)# "5"'7#2$;$)$ '#426$5$04#2$ "&#"('#$='(#(#%"34'(#2"##2$8$#'#')$0 2"%"70$"%3&2"0<$%&$)#0"7("7$(#"=EBC 0>'#(;:3$0(")%%$8('#$% #2$(">$6'#2#2$.#"#$)&$#2$#"=2"%;$$)&2"0<$% 0>#2$;:3$0(4 0$ :)%  #2$0$  #  #2$  8$#'#')$0  "#  #2'(  (#"<$  6:7%  0$(:7#  ')  :)9:(# $)0'&2>$)# #2$8$#'#')$0"##2$&(# #2$.#"#$2$&)&$((')(##2$

A )$60$=8")%$%:)'#("0$<0")#$%6'#2"5'$6#2"##2$'080%:&#("0$ &2$"8$0)"&&:)# &$0#"')&)&$((')(<0")#$%")%)# #2"##2$#"= &77$&#$%'(8$0>'##$%#;$0$#"')$%0$($)#734#2$;$)$ '#'()#"5"'7";7$

0#2$0$"()#2"##2$$)#'0$#"=0$<'>$2"(&2")<$%4"('#2"((2' #$%#)$ :)'

0>%(")%.$05'&$"=462'&2#"1$(&"0$ #"=$()')#0"F.#"#$4 ')#$0F.#"#$("7$(")%"7($=&'($%:#3  #$02$"0')<7$"0)$%&:)($7 0#2$8"0#'$(46$%)# ')% ")3>$0'#')#2$80$($)#8$#'#')%:;#4#2$8$#'#')$06"(<0")#$%-$##$0  )#$)#")%"<0$$>$)#6"("7(('<)$%6'#2#2$.#"#$ 0<0")# &$0#"') ;$)$ '#(4;:#  0))F&>87'")&$  &$0#"')  0>"7'#'$(4 #2$;$)$ '# 

&)&$((')"7  0"#$    &$)#0"7  ("7$(  #"=  &:7%  )#  ;$  "5"'7$%    ;3  #2$ 8$#'#')$00>7$##$0%"#$%

 

 ))$=:0$F

!4'#'($5'%$)##2"#

'0(#82"($ $=8")('):)'# #2$8$#'#')$0&">$')#80%:&#')) ?A

462$0$"(#2$($&)% 82"($ &">$')#80%:&#')'):<:(#4 

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

62'&22$&:7%)#"5"'7 #2$&)&$((')4#2$<0'$5")&$&:7%;$0"'($% ;:##2$8$#'#')$0&)#'):$%>"1')<0$80$($)#"#')(")%&2"0<$%")%8"'% #"=EBC

B 0#2$0$"()(>$)#')$%";5$46$%)# ')%")3>$0'#') #2$80$($)#8$#'#')2$(">$'(4"&&0%')<734%'(>'(($%

"9$(2')%"7!

:%<$  :05')%$0.')<2'77!

:%<$

 

+ >1 2$#2$0(8$"1')<G0$"()$%*

$(G 2$#2$00$80#";7$*

$(G