High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3732/2015disposed of

Kanwaldeep Singh And ORS v. Union Of India & ORS

2015-03-10Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh4 pages

!"!#$ % #& '()*!#+, #( ,-"

!#-" .-"/"

#!##(!

#( ,-"

")#(# "

*$ 0-""1% '!

2(3

- !#-"

! ! 1 !# # , "4!#+ , /- 2 0- */#!' %/1 - *, -1 # - '3-#1# *

#(!#+/#"' ) "# ! #5, ' #!# #(!

6-")#(# 2 0- !",! % /", '2 (3

- 6-")#(# #( 0" 0/#!", #(,!2 ((' (3

#- '2 /#7 5--")#(# -#( /#"'- !#-", ", #((3- & )!" !# , , '

-#( /#"'" - -")#(# " 9 #3!& ,#

/--(-&,! ,&)-)" ) ""2# -)':;

!( 3!

!"-</!-( 5!'(5: ,-")#(# " --"!(# "3!''

+"*,!

#%,/-(

4, -)/-2,"!' #(!"

1-!

-,!-'

#(2 "/'':(" -!5(!#

) - ,&-!

!#2, (5# </!-(5:-")#(# "= /#(- ,

:" 2> ? ? ,& -("&-) ""(!# ,:

->5: ,8 </!"!

!#''

-61) # / : !#-"@1 !#+-!3 # !"

&,!' """"!#+ 1)#"

!#2 ,5#!

" * !#" 2 A #( 9 , 8 </!"!

!# 2A>92# 1':2"'

!/1 #(!# &-# +- # (

,1(")!

,!"/- !# "#$%&'( )(*(& +''% ,)-.(-#/')#0#(.( (&.**(&+1')#!

2342./.%4 !

+-!

'':,'(

3#!# , " </!"!

!#/#(-

' !+,& :" 2 > ?2 , 53 1# !#( & "

/ -:

5#!

" - </ '': (1!""!5' , ( '

#(;&#-" , ) '"-':/)# &( !"!#" ,!"/- 2(

(> ) ""(!# 3

21*- .(-1*(&*(+1')/')#0# 55.##.(')!*%*(&1*)6./.#.(*(&+1')#4 #((

(> ) ""(!#

2)'5 *0)/')#0#(.( (&.* *(&+1')#4&,-5: ,5#!

""'

!/1 #(!# !# -1"

53; !

(( !"!# ,!"/- 2, 35#B #(( ,"!1!'

-':

#(;&#-" '!

# & ")'

(/)# ,-(-"2##B/-"

; #( ;A) ""(5: ,!"/- !#"!1!'

- !- /1"

# " A # ,- +-!3 # !#-" !"

5"!("

"/51!""!#

!#" 2 ,: --/##!#+-1 )!''

- )"

5- ,! -"-")#(# ;

:"/ :-

,-'

" 531# !#(5#!

"5/ ,"

1 -&!

,,'(#':

# ,)'

#(!- !#", 35#+!3#5: ,!"/- !# ,!-

"C"D, ++-!3() !#-", 3#& ))- ,( ,!"/- > , 3, -('

-#( /#"'- - !"

'#+ , #(+# ,-/+, ,- -( ,)-!# !)'"'

!((&#5: ,!"/- !#'(#-# * ' -+!#+"@" "C"/)- D2 -# !#(!")/ /- ,-2 ,

,5#!

""'

!/1 #(!# , 35#B #((5: ,!"/-

,"!1!'

-':"!

#(;&#-"3!(-(-(

(>!#, + *!#+,@" " C"/)- D2 # '" 5 , -(': (!")/ ( # ,"

!- /1"

# "2& - ,3!&

!"!1)-

!3/)#-")#(#

"= #"!(- !#-"@ '

!1- ,+- # "'

!/1 !# !# -( # &!

, ,( !"!# ,!"/- !#'(#-# * ' -+!#+"@" "C"/)- D ,&-!

!#!" -(!#+':(!")"(!# ,''&!#+

-1"$;

C!D !#-"", ''13

!#C"D5- # !!( 1) # / :; /1;8 #( </!"!

-&!

,!# )-!(#1# ,- ,+- #

!(5#!

"E C!!D ,"

!(1) # / :&!''!""/# !

''- ,- -("6-)':-1 ,

/ :#(!

E C!!!D ,1) # / :", '' ,- -( -1!# &, ,- - # !#-" - # '(

!(5#!

"2") !

'':!#3!& ,( !"!#"

,!"/- #( ,#F5'*/)-1/- -'!( /)#5: , '

!1 # "E C!3D -/#(# '( 2 "'") 4!#+ "/))'1#

-:& -( ,!" ", ''5) ""( &!

,!# )-!(/-1# ,"-1 ,(

!'!#+

!#C"DE C3D ,

:"/ :#(!

", ''()"!

, 1/# 2! #:2) :

5'!# -1""/))'1#

& -(2!#!# ;5 -!#+!B(()"!

/# C"D!#

#:#

'!G(5 #4 #((!"5/-"1# ,-", ''

5 "/57 , !# ' ( !"!# , #F5'

*/)-1/- !#*) !

' 8 3 )) 'C!3!'D 9 9 '($ -7 !- -2

!+,& :2.3"

7",& -*!#+, #( -" -!

!#"

#("(!")"( -(!#+': 2

4 6$ *)81

4 +5"