High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/614/2010disposed of

Cit , Ldh v. Maharishi Markandeshawar Edu Trust

2015-10-21Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary10 pages

!"# $$%&&%' !'

$ ()* '

!(+,"-./0%('( 11 ++('

2 !&.& 34&3(0(!%&0%3(!5('/ &06(!/.

%'!.& 77 &1'/ '

!"# $$%&&%' !'

$ ()* '

!(+,"-./0%('( 11 ++('

2 !&.& 34&3(0(!%&0%3(!5('/ &06(!/.

%'!.& 77 &1'/ '

3 9 :-3 ;

3 3- <-3 3

! & '

3! (= &0 0%"/2 ! 0 (11 ++('

3! (2%0('5(!"/2 ! 0 ! &1'/ '

3 " > 0%&=./?$ '

"6 &0(++/%&1& 611 (+&& ('/8"%'60% $$'@. & %'&+(60(2 (!%& ' !/ !$%'( %'> 0%&.!

0 & (11 (+&0(2 '%+ /> 0 $$%&&%' ! '

$ () * '

!(+, -./0%('( (?(%'& 0 !/ !& /(

AB*'' ).! A,1(&& /> 0 '

$ ()11 ++( !%.'(+" +0% '

0C<" 6 +0%*!&0!

"C 0 !%.'(+<, ! /%& .&&%'? 0 ? ' !(++(6?2 !'%'? 0 &.=

"% %&(11!1!%( &.$$(!%D / 0 (

&(&.'/ !

0 ! &1'/ '

9(&& && 6(& !.''%'? '%' /.

%'(+ %'& % .

%'& ' EB#" ( & (!

0 ('/ & %D.! 1 !( %' .'/ ! &

%' A*, 0 '

$ ()

*! &0!

<,6(& (!!% /.

%' 0 1! $%& & *%' &0!

" C 0 (&& && <, .!%'? 0%& 1 !( %'" !

(%' ?.&

(&0 !

%1 & ($.'

%'? 8"E"EE49 6 ! & %D / ' 8"(' % .'/ !&

%'#A9

6(&%&&. /

0 (&& && .!'%&0 0 !

.!' %'

$ ' ! &1'&

0 !

" 0 (&& && .!'%&0 /!

.!'%'

$ / +(!%'?'

+&& ""#"49 .& @. '

+>" 0 (&& && 6(& & !2 / 6% 0 @. & %''(%! ('/ ' % & .'/ ! &

%'& *, ('/ A*,

60% 0 6 ! /.+> ! 1+% / %&9&( %&% / 6% 0 $( !%(+4 2%/ '

1!/.

/ > 0 (&& && " && &&%'? % !%' !! / 0 (&& && (%+ / )1+(%'

(&0!

%1 &($.'

%'?

""# "$%

8"E"E49.'/ !&

%'8

6(& $(/ (&& &&%'? 0 '

/ % % ( '

()##

""$ ") !

#%%""% *

'('

% 8 .!%'? 0 (2 2 !>& (!

01 !( %''EB#"

(%' / .$ '

&" %'

+./%'? 0 / (%+& &(+(!> 1(%/ /

!&4& (> (&0"%'(//% &(+(!>1(%/> 0 @. 6 ! & %D / %' 0 %'& % .

%' 0 (&& && '2 '

!> (&0 /!(6' ('/ (&0 ($.'

%'? A"B8"E49 6(& .'/ (

++ ? 1! $%& & ' 0 !

.!' %+ / ' A" (&& && / +(! / '

+&& "A"#"AA49 0 (&& && 6(& & !2 / 6% 0 @. & %''(%! ('/ ' % & .'/ !

%'& *, ('/ A*,

60% 0 6 ! /.+> ! 1+% / ' (11!

%( %'$( !%(+4 2%/ '

0 && &&%'? % !%' !! /

0 ($.'

$$"#

-%.%*%

-%+%/%

-%.%*%

"""

)

0% #

"""

% ' 0%& 2 !> / .$ '

9AE" (' ($.'

"49 (11 (! /

0(2 ' 1(%/ (?(%'&

'($ !;0+.6(+%( '

0 /% ! '

%' 0 &(+(!>

! ??(!6(+"491 !$'

0('/.!

0 !$ '

%'%'? "49(?(%'& 0 '($ !;0+.6(+%(%'/ .$ '

9AE 6(& '&%/ ! / > 0 && &&%'? % ! (& % 0(& ' 1(%/!$.' )1+(%' /&.!

0 +%& ('' ) /6% 0/ .$ '

9AE '

(%'%'? 0 '($ &E/

!& '

(5%'?%'

'&%/ !( 0 /% ! '

$"""

-%.%*%

$"""

-%+%/%

$$"# +

2 3

#%%""%

'('

0 &(%/ (&& &&$ '

!/ !& /( / AE 6 ! $(/ &.=

! 0(++ '? ! 0 $$%&&%' ! '

$ ()*11 (+&,9"-./0%('( F%/ !/ ! /( / E8 *'' ).! 9, %' "+ (!' /*,& (&%/ "0+/%'? (//% %' .'/ !

%' 8

6(& ' + ?(++> &.& (%'(+ "%'(&$.

0(&" 0 & $ '

&/' &.& ('

%( 0 (! &(%/ (++ ? / !

%1 & 6 ! ?.&

(.& 0 !

%1 &6 ! /.+>.'/ '

! /%' 0 5&

('/(+&%' 0 (+('

&0 &06%'? 0 ($.'

6(&/ 1&% /6% "60% 0%&! ?%& ! /.'/ !

0 ! ! " 0 (! &(%/ (//% %' .'/ !

%'8

6(&!/ ! / / + /%&9&( %&% / 6% 0 (! &(%/ !/ ! /( / E8" 0 ! 2 '. (11!( 0 / 0 '

$ ()11 ++( !%.'(+* +0% '

0C< 6 +0%," 60 /%&$%&& / % & (11 (+ 2%/ !/ ! /( AB(%!$%'? 0 %'/%'?&*, F%/ !/ ! /( / 88 *'' ).! 9, %' 8" 0 + (!' /*,& (&%/ 0 (//% %' $$"#

.'/ !

%' B9

! +( 5 + ?(+ ! /%%+% % & 0 $(%' .& /%&(?! ('/' ?( 0 2% 6 (5 '> 0 && &&%'? % ! 6(& 0 0(/ 1+( / ! +%('

' 0 & $ '

& 6 /

!&" '($ +>" !;0+.6(+%( ('/ ! ??(!6(+" 60 6 ! '&%/ ! / 0(2 ' '$(/ ('>1(>$ '

%' (&0"

0.?0 1(>$ '

"49 6(& 1(%/ %'

(&0

! ??(!6(+ (& 1 ! 0%& (/$%&&%' ! 0 && &&%'? % !('/%' 0 & %D // .$ '

&"(&.$"496(& &06' 0(2 ' 1(%/ %' (&0 !;0+.6(+%( 0 + (!' / *, ($ '

+.&%' ! $(%'%'? E /

!& .+/' 0(2 '$(/ 1(>$ '

%' (&0%'2% 6

0 (%/(2% &.!'%&0 /> 0 $" ! 0 && &&%'? % !" &1 %(++>60 ' 0 >6 ! ' )($%' /2 ' 0 ! 2 '. 0(& (%+ / 1!2 0 .' )1+(%' / )1 '/% .!

!/%'?+>" % !/ ! /!/ + %'(//% %'$(/ > 0 && &&%'? % !

0 ! 2 '. (11!( 0 / 0 '

$ () 11 ++( !%.'(+ * +0% '

0C< 6 +0%," 60 /%&$%&& / 0 (11 (+ 2%/ !/ !/( /AB//% %'(++>"% ($ '

+.&%'

%" 0 ($.'

%& (// / (& .' )1+(%' / )1 '/% .! " & %++

0(!(

! 0 )1 '/% .! %'

.!! /6(&' 0 =

('/ %'?&" 0 (&& && 6(& '

% + / +(%$ / /.

%'60%+ $1.

%'?% &%'

$ .'/ !

%'&('/

6 0 ! 2 '. 0(& (11!( 0 / 0%& .!

0(++ '?%'? 0 !/ !& /( / AB 1(&& / %'

(& &> 0 " +0%

!$ 0 ! &1

%2 1+ (/%'?& ('/ 0 & ('/&

(5 ' > 0 1(!

% &" ++6%'? 1%'

& $ !? !

'&%/ !( %'

*(, G0 0 ! 0 (//% %'8"E"E49$(/ .'/ ! &

%' 8

> 0 && &&%'? % ! %& + ?(+H *, G0 0 !

(&0 1(>$ '

&(+(!> (& .' )1+(%' / )1 '/% .! (++&.'/ !&

%'B

- (!' / .'& +(11 (!%'?! 0 ! 2 '. &.$%

0 ! 2 '. 0(&!%?0 +>%'25 / 0 1!2%&%'&

"%'(&$.

0(&" 0 (&& && (%+ / & (+%&0 ? '.%' ' &&" ! /% 6!

0%' && ('/ %/ '

% > (&0 ! /% & ('/" 0 ! ! "(//% %'8"E"E49.'/ ! 0 (! &(%/

%' %' (+ %'

$ 0 (&& && 0(/ !%?0 +> ' $(/ 3! 2 !"% $(5 &'/% ! '

"% 0 !

%1 &!$%'? 1(!

$ (! (5 ' (& /'( %' ! .' )1+(%' / ! /% 0.&" 0 !/ !&1(&& /> 0 11 ++( .

0!% % & +6(! +%(+ & (&%/ ' 0 0 !0('/"+ (!' / .'& +(11 (!%'?! (&& && &.$% & 0 11 ++( .

0!% % & +6 0(2 !%?0 +> /%&$%&& / +(%$ 0 ! 2 '. 0+/%'? (&& && 0(&/.+>1!2 / 0 1!1 ! '

!% &6 ! $(/ %'

0 ! + 2('

! ?%& !&&06%'? 0 / 1&% & 0 ($.'

0.&" 0 (11 (+ 0 ! 2 '. /%&$%&& / G 0(2 ?%2 ' .! 0.?0 .+ '&%/ !( (!?.$ '

&+ (!' / .'& +! 0 1(!

% & ' 0 1! & '

(& " 0 1! $%& & 6(& & (!

0 / ' EB# .!%'? & (!

0" /'( %' !

%1 & ($.'

%'? 8"E"EE49 6 ! & %D / 1(! % .+(!& ! (//! && &6 ! / (%+ /.

%' (&0!

%1 & $ '

& 0!% ;('&(+" '%!

('/ 0!% (&01(+ '('/"

6 ! !

!/ /" 60 & 60 ' 2 ! (&& && & % > 0(& ' ?( %2 (&0 (+('

0 0(%!$('

0 !.& 0(&%'& !.

/%2 !

(&0>1! 1(!%'?(5 (&0 !

%1 &6 2 !"+( !'">.!'%&0%'?(%/(2% &" (2 1 !&'& 0(2 ! &%+ / !$ 0 %! (!+% ! 2 !&%'& 0 && &&%'? % !/%/' 1+( ! +%('

' 0 %!! &%+ /2 !&%'"

%'(&$.

0 (&" 0 %! (!+% ! & $ '

& +( 5& ('> /.! && !

0! ( 0 ! &1'/ '

(&& && %&(! ?%& ! / .'/ !

('/" 0 ! ! "% %& +(%$%'? ) $1 .'/ !

%'& ('/

6 2 !" 60 ' % %& & (+%&0 / 0 !

%1 & !$ 1(!

$ ('/ .'/ $ '

%' /%' 0 (

5&"%' 2 '

.(+% >".'+ &&('/ .'

%+" 0 ! %&('>$( !%(+4 2%/ '

!/ &06 ($.'

6(&&1 '

' 0 =

"% %&' / /.

- (!' / .'& +! 0 ! 2 '. &.$%

1(>$ '

&(+(!>%' (&0"2 !('/(2 0 @. ($.'

6(&$(/ 0 /

!&4& (60% 0 2 '/%/' ! +

%' 5&(

0( %'?&"(&.$"E"AE49%&

'&%/ ! /(&%'

$ ! 0 %'('

%(+> (!.'/ !

%'B

' 0 0 !0('/"+ (!' / .'& +(11 (!%'?! (&& && &.$% & 611 ++( .

0!% % & +60(2 !%?0 +>/%&$%&& / 0 (11 (+ 0 ! 2 '. ' 0 %'& ('

(& " 0 (.

0!% % & +6 & !2 /

&%'

6 /

!&" '($ +>" !;0+.6(+%( ('/ ! ??(!6(+6 ! '&%/ ! / 0(2 ' ' $(/ ('> 1(>$ '

%' (&0('/ $(/ 1(>$ '

"49%'& (/ 8"49 %' (&0" 0 ! ! " 0 (11 ++( (.

0!% > ($

+.&%' ! $(%'%'?E/

!& .+/' 0(2 ' $(/ 1(>$ '

%' (&0 %' 2% 6 0 (%/(2% & .!'%&0 / >

0 $" &1 %(++>" 60 ' 0 > 6 ! ' )($%' / ! && &&%'? % ! //% %'(++>" ($ '

+.&%'

% 0 ($.'

%&(// /(&.' )1+(%' / )1 '/% .! "& %++

0(!(

! 0 )1 '/% .! %'

.!! /6(&' 0 =

('/ 0 ! ! " 0 (&& && %& '

% + / +(%$/ /.

60%+ $1.

%'?% &%'

$ .'/ !

%'&('/

(&% $(>" 0 %'/%'?& 0 (.

0!% % & +6(! ' + ?(++> &.& (%'(+ " (.& 0 $( !%(+4 2%/ '

! 2 '. 6(& /%& (!/ / $ ! +> ' 0 1! $%& &%'

(! &(%/ 6/

!&6 ! ' .'/ 1(%/&(+(!>%' (&0 !1(!

+>1(%/"2 !('/(2 0 @. ($.'

"(&/ 1%

(2 " 0 ! ! " 0 ! $(%'%'? E /

!& 6 ! (+&

'&%/ ! / ' 1(%/&(+(!>%' (&0"60% 0%&(

.(++>('/ + ?(++>%'

.!'%&0%'?(%/(2% &>E/

!&/ '>%'?

0 >/%/' ?

0 &(+(!>%' (&0/ &' $ ('

&! $(%'& % 0 '

%! 2%/ '

%& '&%/ ! /" 60%+ (/=./% %'? 0 $(

! G% 0.

)($%'%'? '

!' / /

!&4& (&" (& 06 % (' %' !! / 0 > 6 ! '&%/ ! / ' 1(%/ &(+(!> %'

(&0"2 !('/(2 0 @. ($.'

6 2 !" 0%&(

%& +( 5%'?%' 0%& (& 0.&" 0 %'/%'?& (&& && %'? ( 0 .' )1+(%' / )1 '/% .! %& ' 0(!? (+

.'/ ! &

%'& ('/

(! ' + ?(++> !!

(.& .'/ !1!2%& &

%'B

($.'

60% 6(&.' )1+(%' / )1 '/% .! 6(& (// / 0 %'

0 (&& && 2 ! ('/ (2 0 %'

$ / +(! / > (&& && ('/ &0(++ ' (++6 / (& ( / /.

%' .'/ ! ('> 0 (/%'

$ '

+.&%'

&&('/ '2% 6 0 (! &(%//%& .&&%'"6 %'/ 0%& (&1

0 $(

! 0(& ' ' '&%/ ! / > 6 11 ++( .

0!% % & +6 %' 0 +%?0 0 (! &(%/ & !2( %'&('/(

!/%'?+>" 0 1! & '

(11 (+&(! (++6 / 0 !/ !& /( E8488 ('/ AB" '' ).! & ('/ A" ! &1

%2 +>" (! & (&%/ ('/ $(

!%&! $('/ /( 5 0 $$%&&%' !'

$ () *11 (+&,9" -./0%('( ! (5%'? ! &0 / %&%' %' 0 +%?0 (! &(%/ & !2( %'& 6% 0.

%'? %'+. '

/ > 0 (!+% ! !/ !& 0 *, &0(++ / %/ 0 $(

! (! &0 %'

!/('

6% 0+(60 (11 (+&& ('//%&1& /(

!/%'? * 3 ,

!"# *;

3 3-, ;/