High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24101/2017dismissed

M/S Gupta & Company v. State Of Haryana And Others

2017-10-25Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Arun Monga8 pages

Gurbax Singh 2017.12.15 10:44

"#" $ %& !!" ''()*!#"+, "- !."

/0"%0& " !"*012 !&& !" 41 *!5"

$0!" ! $!

6 78 1 *.

8 78 1 * 98

! " 2 . "&/1

# " $%$&' % ( )% *

+%, - ./$$ "%.$ 0% "# . " 1 " $ . "(!-

+%& " .# " 1 - % !$ "! $.%* "-

!% " .* $- . "* - $. "!" 3 $"# %* "# "" "%*

+% #.#

$". $$*

- $! !# !$! " #.3 -/*% #$ '4%"5 "#( 4! -/ %""$# $.%$* .* 3 % 6$ 7" 1 % $ !* % $*8$""973 " %.

$*- $ . -$$

$ . # % - *! . ! .:(09;3 %.

$ %! ! (37 $ #

<, 2

, & 3 " /- $ . - "

- -3 %* - * -!# " /- . . " $# *% %! - %" )% $ 3 - " %.

%! #

<, 2$$

, & % %!-%" ".$ 3 "-% " $# % %! - . %. * " - / "

$"- $ - %! #

<, 2$$

, & - -$" % .#"1 "/*3 " /-** "*%<

+% :$$#; 3 " % ! :(3;"$%1: ;

-%""/$ *""%# # $.- " .$ !# - . * " $ $ !$%

- %"" $ $ "! . - $ . - $*.$ 3 " " !- .! $% ""%# .*$ # # $. $% .$ ( $.-$# .% ,%.

(37 #

$*- $ ,%.

(37)%3 "%

" 1 " "/* " " 7" 1 "

" )% .# " "* .! " /- 3 ""!$

$ % " "

" " .# " 1 " $ . " $* $ . !$ ("

$"/"$$* !% " **! .# " $ !$ 11

%=2

+% -"-- -.# "!- $. " " . " 3 " $ /- " $ " <

$$**

"/*" !% ". >*,, 3 " - - " !- / $

% .! <

3 8%" >* 6$ %

* "/*--$#% 3""!$

- $$#!% 8%">* 6$* " "/* - * %.$ !- ( - % )% $. " %$." ""!$8 $ -%*

* " "

!%.#

$" " % $% % $.-"7" !

" ?#8%.)% .! " - - - .# 3 ""!$

" $$* "%.$ ? ".# " 1 ! $%$ " - + .# 3 ""!$

% " >*,, ?# :957; "

-/ )% ( . *$$# )%-! "

3 - % 8%" >* 6$ ! $

- $ !$%

- "% %" ""!$

$. - 8%" >* 6$ " "/* " " 1

8%" >* 6$ " " $!$%$ "!

"* $.3

-*"%%" ""!$

"/* " .# 8%" >* 6$-3 "- .#" (- %

% * ""!$

" :(3; " . $ . - . %.

$#$-."#" #$ %.

$.$ $ " .$ %$ . / "

#$ 3

- %* $# + .# 3 ""!$

-$% . " /* "' "$ !% $!$$!$*$$**!%

.$ . . % -.

%$$$*! ""%# . "%.$ 3 $!

*.# ""!$

%, @3 - !

- + 78 ?A

% 8> :6$; ! $

- $ !$%.#8>:6$;3 -"%%"

& 3 $ <

$. 3 8> :6$; %$ " "/* " '4%"5 1

8> :6$; " $ "/*

" $ !$% - $ '4%"5 "!

"* $ .3 -*"%%" 3 $

3 "/* ".# 8>:6$;% B8>:6$; * " "/* 8>:6$; %.

!- 3 ! $ &<< <

0% " . *! .# 8 ! 8 / % "#- .,@ -%$$/ $..* / $!$ $$

!- 59C % "

.#8 !8 /% "# /*#% "

#$ "$!$ (3 - #

** " $$# %" ( 8>:6$;-

$#-%$$#-

7** %.

% "

#$ " - ""!(3- "%%, :; ( " *#' 8>$ $% 1 - .$- @ " . %# . -$$ . / -* :%%$$# -

# "* 3 $ 9; $ #

# 3 $9 # - " # .$ C :.; $ !* " $$# .$- @A$ 9

)%%.

#$98"

#$98 >!$",9893 $9. %.

# $ $$ . "#"

#$ C ( !- .! "! (3 $ $ . . %.

$# $ . " " #$ ?-! %.

$ . $ $ '

" .$ ./"

#$ ?-! .$

!. .% 3 !- .!"! (3

* + $ !$% "/*

" .# 8> " 8 !8 /% "#

% - " 8 . /* "' "$ !% $!$ $ $!$* * * !%

.$ !. .% 3 " $$ . $$ *! ""%# . * "%.$C D %$ " . .$ "%# $ - *.# " % # $$*$ % ! "

$$ %

/* "' "$ !% $!$ .# " " - $ $!$ $$* * !%

*$# -"""%"%.$ $$ - . . $$*$

< %.$ $- )%$# * " .# :2 . "&/; $%! #-!"'<'=>, : & ?/; @%7 $%! 90!0!"!A& %"! !$ ! 90!0!""!"-/! !