Naveen Lokesh v. Union Of India & ORS


 

       


   

   

 

  

     

  


  

   !"#$"#%$"#&'()#*#+$,"-'.(/#%#0-%$#(1+$"#(1)#,$2



  3  





    "#  4%1$  0#$1$1-+#%  500.1#(  6-%  $"#  0-,$  -6  #+1-%  #7$1-+ +)1+##%  8%579  357"1+#:  5(;#%$1,#(  $"%-')"  #+$%5.1<#(  *0.-=*#+$ -$17#-> '$-6?0-,$,-6#+1-%#7$1-++)1+##%8%579 357"1+#:  @  0-,$,  4#%#  61..#(  '0  /=  $"#  51.45=  #7%'1$*#+$  -5%(

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


+)1+##%8%579357"1+#:

"#%#,0-+(#+$,7-+$#+(#($"5$5..$"#@75+(1(5$#,"5;#&-1+#( $"#,#%;17#$45,6'%$"#%7-+$#+(#($"5$5,$"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%05%$17105$#( 1+  $"#  ,#.#7$1-+  0%-7#,,  0'%,'5+$  $-  $"#  6%#,"  5(;#%$1,#*#+$  )1;#+  -+ BC"#1,(#/5%%#(6%-*7"5..#+)1+)$"#61+5.,#.#7$.1,$ "#%1/'+5.%#&#7$#($"#0.#5-6$"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%-+$"# )%-'+(,  $"5$  5..  $"#  @  ;575+71#,  "5(  /##+  61..#(  '0  6%-*  -'$  -6  $"# 75+(1(5$#,4"-,#+5*#,4#%#%#7-**#+(#(5+($"5$$"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#% 4"-05%$17105$#(1+$"#,#.#7$1-+0%-7#,,1,#,$-00#(6%-*7"5..#+)1+)$"# 57$1-+-6$"#%#,0-+(#+$,  #5%($"#,'/*1,,1-+,*5(#/=.#5%+#(7-'+,#.500#5%1+)6-% $"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%$1,54#..,#$$.#(0%-0-,1$1-+-6.54$"5$+-%1)"$;#,$, 1+5,'77#,,6'.75+(1(5$#6-%500-1+$*#+$*#%#.

=-+$"#)%-'+($"5$"#45, 1+$"#*#%1$.1,$>451$.1,$ $1,-0#+$-$"##05%$*#+$$-61..'0$"# ;575+71#,  67-'%,#$"##05%$*#+$,"-'.(7-*#-'$41$"0.5',1/.# #D0.5+5$1-+5,$-4"=$"#;575+71#,5%#+-$/#1+)61..#('06%-*$"#*#%1$ .1,$>451$.1,$  + $"# 1+,$5+$ 75,# -+.=@  ;575+71#, 4#%# $-  /# 61..#(  '0 $"%-')",#.#7$1-+0%-7#,,7-+('7$#(/=$"# 51.

"5+(1)5%"++#D'%#
C$"#1+6-%*5$1-+'+(#%$"# 7$%#7#1;#(/= $"#4%1$0#$1$1-+#%4-'.()-$-1+(175$#$"5$5..$"#@#*05+#..#(75+(1(5$#, $'%+#('06-%500-1+$*#+$5,500%#+$17#>3 '$'+6-%$'+5$#.=-+# -6$"#75+(1(5$#,-'$-6$"-,#@75+(1(5$#,"5(5/,7-+(#(56$#%5$$#+(1+) (5=,-6$%51+1+) ?

$1,+-$575,#4"#%#5$%51+##4"-45,'+(#%)-1+)$%51+1+)

A
1+6-%*#($"##05%$*#+$5+(.#6$$"#$%51+1+) "##05%$*#+$(1(+-$ %#7#1;#  5+=  1+6-%*5$1-+  5,  %#)5%(,  $"#  4"#%#5/-'$,  -6  $"#  5/,7-+(#( 75+(1(5$#'7"575+(1(5$#*1)"$"5;#/##+566.17$#(41$",-*#*#+$5. 1..+#,,#*5=500#5%56$#%,-*#$1*#7.51*1+)$"5$"#7-'.(+-$7-+$1+'# 41$"$"#$%51+1+)5,"#45,,'66#%1+)6%-**#+$5.1..+#,,"#%#6-%#$"# ;575+7=7%#5$#(/=5/,-+(5+7#75++-$/#7-'+$#(5,5+1**#(15$#;575+7= $-/#61..#('06%-*$"#451$.1,$#(75+(1(5$# @ "#(#71,1-+1+ 

   



!

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

'.5$1 #