Naresh Kumar Etc. v. Chand Mandal Etc.
!"!#$%&'()
*$+,*-*,-
"! # $ %&' ( ) *( !% !( ) *(
!+, -( ) *( # , -( ) *(
. ...
*,- ) !! -*!
**!
!
! (
! (/ *
!
(!+! (!
)!***!
+*
.0 001!
!( -
!
(/ / *+!
!!
#23 415 + * *
1(10(00063/ - ! 7 849
(
!
(/ / (
!!
*!
!!
! / 7/ - ! !
**
/
!
-1
(! !
** -: -
.;/!/!* *+/ (!
849
/ -! !<!
(!
*(!
// 849!
!<!
= /)(!
* ! /
/
)!
!* *
**!
(!
* -/ ! * )
*
(
3(!
1
1!
/
*+(/ / - ** -( *
- *+/
(7
!&!
*(+ / ! (
.0 001(!+! / !!
*!
&* 3>0( !( !
!
? ! * /
(&* 31@(
! (
*
!
!!
=3 133 >@00 * A* /+A
!)!
&* 3>
#1'3 ( !( *+ !) -
*
!!
( - !) )-! (!
!
(/!**
/
!
!*
(/!*/
* *!
!
!
!
/
) = !( !( ** !!
! ? -(! 50 001 =! ) @- !
**!
( ! * !
B*!*B !
( !
C &*
(/"!=/ ) !
D#-/!
C !
E - D( /!*(!/*!
(/ ?!
-0(00063=/
-
*!
5(00063/ )
!
!* (
5(00063
!! 1 2
!*(
!!
!
!/!
!-
***!
+ * /! *+!
!!
#23 415(/!* *
, !
&!
/!* !/
* C! 7 * -E!
!
!!
-!!
!/! (!
!) D
)!*D/
)!
!* *!
**!
)!*/!
!) )!
!
!!
!
* !*-(/!* /!/
! ! *
/( /)(! ! ( !
!
-** -/
! -
!)(
(
)!
( / * !
( . F !
!( ! /!
! $3 A
!+! ! !* **!
/!*
+*
.0 001
5
/ &* >
#1'0 ( ! #E /+
!
/! *+
#23 415C##
7! ! ) (/*!
!
*
7-( /!*?
/ C## 1
/
)!
*!) !* (7 (!*C## . !A 5 3*!
:!
*!
; /! ?
!! *!
!!
*!
?
!
-'#
(/ !!
10 001
!
/ +
/
/
!)!
&* 3>06> 5
/ *#E /+(*
!
(!
!!
=3 133>@00(/!
!) --
-/!
*+* !!
!
- *
/
!
*+ !
*
(/!*/
*!
=* +
/ *
!)/!+!
*+ !)/
= !! /!
!!
!+! = !(/ ** !!
! G ! (
!
- #
(/!*/
- !) *+
/
+ * 3 ? !
(
!- *+!
!
!
!
( !
*( --
(
!
!
/ (
!* ! -*
! > ( ! !
- *
!
/
/ -! ( (! H
7/
-! ! *!
# !! !
/ 0(00063 D#-/!
C !
E - D(
)!
*!
/ 7/( /)( ) !
!-* ( / !
! !
C &*
(/!
!
(!!
/ 8 100063
-!
!
!
-/ - 0&
0/ # 0"3" &2!0 #"40 040
!# # # 0):
004;
G& ( !! @/!
!
(/!*/) (+!
?
( *
!
!)( 509 ! !
(!
* 7 !
/ **
( @- ( +!
-
!
*!
50063( - +!
!
!
@(00063( !! @/! (!
!
!
( !
/ 1( .(00063 2
/ +(
G00063/
-/- ? - ) * -*!
(-!
*
-( 1(10(00063
@
)!
**
* *+
3:
1!
;(
/ ! -*
-
)-(: *+!
1!
( / / ( -
!* ; 4 !
-
!* (!/
* -
!* *
( ! -
( !* */* -!
- !)! )!*(/ *+!
H !
/)- )!*= *(
/
)!
!* * !
**!
H -(*
/ / * )- * * -
(
1( -
)-(!
** - - *!
0 %&' (
( ! !
//
-
-100063
(!/ +! (/) !
! (/ ! *
!
C &*
=( ( !
!
!)(/ )
!
! !
!
( !
( !- * ! ( *
!
D& !
"23!#52 ! '
# !& &* !3 /6 # / 2 # 0 -2 0/ # # ( 0.:.;:!)!;5.1 E
!
//
* / )
*!
!
7
-
:
- ;
(
// / ! !) !7 !
(!E ! / /
!*!
/ )!
-) *! !
*( ! !
5(00063
() /
-4-
/! !*
!
(& !!
!
03!# 8%/ 0*!"20 3 9# !
""%0 # , ) :
00;0& 5.
)/!
'* !
(/ ) *!)!
G0(00063
( !% !(
!
!+, -(
!
** -(!
.( ! !
- ! (!!
/* *- 100063
(!
/ / !
C &*
!- ( * +! =)!
!
!
/ ! ( !
(/ /**
@- - (
! !)
:) / ) ( /!
*!!* ) ;(
& !
8* &!638!0 # &( :
004;.&(* () !
*(*!
!!
/!
&*!
G13 !**(4@@( /!
*(*!
!!
/!
&*!
GG = /)(!
//!
-& (
:
! ( * *! 7
!* !
*( )!
- /** @- ( /)(!
*/ ) ! * !
C
&*
("!( *(* + (*!-/!
!
/
!
!
)!
** 1 +!
) *(!! !
* : ;(! //! 4*
*! (!
**!
!E !) - * !- )- !!* !
*
3 *! ( /)(
!* !* **(
*
* / (+!
! *!
!
!
7 *(
>5(00063-/- * !
(/ *!
*(!
-!
100063 -
!* (/!*!* - !
- !
!! / +! : ;/ +( - & # (/004 001(!
/ */ + ) 45415
-# , )
(
)!*!
*:
.0 001; /( !
( ! A!
*!*A( / ! ( )!
- / ! !
B*!**
-
*( -) H !! ! -+! / +
;
(+!
)/ 100063- !*+(
00063!
/ ! * !
(!
! (-!
!
500063
F
(509 * / !
!)!
? (!
* ( )!
50063
!
*!
*!
( /
-
( ! ( ! !
!
(
)!
) /
!
(/!*!
-**
) (!
! ) = *( !
50063
:10(00063
-;( !! @! ! ( !
-@ - (
!
(!
(* 5(.0(00063 . (* ! -
F!-(! / - /
-G00063-/-
!* ? !
!
< "2 # 0"3" <5!0-!#=2 # 0":
01;:4;&5.
1!/ &8 #9
# 0"3"8!"20 # # 0" :
01;:>;&.>G( /
-( 5(00063!/ / ?
! C ( / !
)
*!
!
(/!*
- !/ 850(00063* = /)(!
! *( !
-@- (
-
!
(:
- (/ ;( (00(00063*!/ / !
5 ( *
// (! /$3 !;
/
: ;
5(.0(00063 !!;
/ )
*!
(:(00(00063 *; (00(00063 !!!;
/ ?
! : ;
5(00063
& 7)()
>?
= *( *
// (!.(15(00063
)
)*
/ -!
!
/// -! ( !
!+
G59
(
!!
*!
!!
(! !!
G )!/ *!
/
!* * !))- )!*( *
(
/!!
(/ ! !
-
.(!!
** -(/!* -/ )! * )-
(
1!
(
* -! (!
1/ ! A
)!*A(/*
- !
)!*/* -/!
!
()!
* !
1( /!
* *
* !-(
**!
1( ! (
)! - !
/ !** -- / )? ( /!
%&'()
@*,-A