High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/6374/2011dismissed

Hanuman Singh v. Sona Devi And ORS

2015-09-02Mr. Justice Vijender Singh Malik8 pages

!" # $ % & '( )) *"&

+ (" ,

#"$%"&'%!'!

#(')* '%%"+ ,"#

-.,/( 01 2 "* $

#" 0"1 3

-.,/( 0# ".%,* !"

,40

4/ #1 -"

"*+./("#+#

"()) "*()''"0)#+#

" "(" 5") 1(0 .+ ))20 0( )!)3 ""+"3!3( 3!3("" ("!& ) 1(0 (+()''"+ ( )

" '()"

& )#(0'( (( " .&+ )( $.' 4&) )'( "+()% ())'( "+()) ( 0( ( .

)1("0" '! '"" ( ( )'( "+()) ) #" '( #0&

&"( 0 " &)) 31(& )5"'& ((

& ( ")+ 0(( 0)) '+"

( )!)3 ( &

) 3" 1(& )0&))") 6&' (&" 7)!" '( ("*"&,)) '(

(" -8, $4&")3'+"

'(&1(0 "" "))30("("+"0() "+")'( "+() 1("0" ')(")+ ('"0'( (""0)( $.'#

& ( )'( " +() ) 0 &

&" &)) 3 " ( 39 0)) . !+6&' :((&4&")3'+" ("&'( 6&' &" ;&"(" "& 0(&)4&) " "+() 0( "+"&)!!&)3) 1( ("*()<== "

&6 "(5)'( "+()5& 5" "+()5&

" &&))3:)&+)'( "+()&)6&0))!" "+()# &&(& ( "4&"

( >""?!3)

" "+()"'""3 '+()9 0'()(

$.'))4&) ()'( "+(); 4& )3#

'>""? ( )'( "

+()))+")7& (""(")"#0(( #())!" ')& )'( "

+()( ")" 3" 3 ""3'9 ""

(")" &"" "+()"'""3 '

+()#(

0))'+"

(&#""+

0(("'0"" "( "

1(6&' '%*4 40/ 5 " ""!+# &))3

" & (0( (! . "( +()#0((0 +)+ ( 9

#(" "#!.

" "&"0("("" )+)!)!& (

(0(+()0" (0( (!

. $ 9( ("+&(" '"( ) &"

(() ( (0(0 "()

"+"' ". "(+()9(+ ("&'((3 )30(("!(+()3!>'""3 '@ -&!)"""?1( "&4&) > ")+() @.')3?1( ((0 "(. .')3 (+" "0 '".0))(""3 )+"( ". "" ) 0 " "+"0))" & ,= AB))0 "& (+()& ()3 """' ' )) '& ( 1() & )& )3 +"' " & & " " " 3 ( "& (&"& 0(

" "31( ) (+()"! ()3 )>.&? +()0((0'( ')( $.' ( 0&)!5)'( "+()5 &&!)"++()" '""'")3+"&

#( 0(+).

" ( 3 ( "+ ' ) (

)& ("(& >3 & ##4)$" , 4740/%4& 0& 896" ())"+ "+() 3&!))& )(()

+ "+ ' ) & ( &(" ' ( "+ ( +()C " ())"+" "+()D("

( "!" "3)(" "(0 &""

& " 3( & "&!B $ & )("+ ))3 )( 1( &!60((&!B ()) )3" "+ ' "& "+ ' "

+()())!&( 3!""!!3(; ") E+"

? 1( .)"( " 0&)"+" "+() ("( "!" "3)("" "(0 &"" # & )() &("F( 1(

&(&("F

! ("&'(( " ) && "0( "

" '" +") +() ( " "

'"F 5 '" +()5 5' +()5 (+ !

" + !3 ( & $<<< & " E , = G

+ "

<<<0(:" 5" "+()5 1( "

"4&") &("F "+" "+()H ).( " ) (0&)!'" "+" "3+()& "

"" $3"&0"# (( "+ &"" 0& "( " " +()!

+ )3 "" ("3" " " +() ""3 ' ' '"& " (F"& &"# ()) !

+ "" 3"1(") &"(""'" ( "

!""&! "'" ) "" "+() ""3 '" "+() #"4&" (" ))( &"! "3 0 ( )3!&(""+") 0( ( "+ " & " " "" & " ("4&" " "+()) 1(& )

"()) ))("

! " 0(( ")3 0"(&0((0(+ 0&))7 ( (;&"

)9 ;8*"&-"+ /& " (" $ ,;,;+) =$)0( & &" ) ("

&90 " (+ ') ""+ ' "

3)!&"+ ' 1(&"0")3 ' 6&' ) ; 38 * 0" '( ,;,;+)

(0) '0((

."+ " 0(" + ) 0&)!"")+ 0" '(5 &"#:) )& 0("("+" (+()) &( !&("0"(" "( "!&&( 0( +()0". )3"0( ("0 ( ) )&" 1( B ) ) 0&)! ")1(")

0" '(50) ( : " '("*() )0) ")') 73 (!"+ 9 "0

" () +&" ()) "+ ' " & ".(0 0(( !) ' ( '"3# 0(( )'( " +()#

)3'+&)&!&( &" "+ '

) ("4&"9 0)'( ") &".(0 0(( &"&(""3 '"#0&)4&) 3"4&"

" (

" )& "+" & )(+" "+() 1()00)0 )9 ;8*"&;())7("( = ;;$ 1( 0&!4& )3"B (F!3( &" ;&" 0 &" ;8*"&-"!(&8) =;2 1(0 ""0(( )3"+# )3#

"4&" " "+() "0(")+ "&)0(( 0(+" ""!+9 ()'( (!""+ ( ( &" ;&"(" ! ) "(0 "

(+()0(( &"'""3 '&!)"""

&)!"+ !3" ")3(+ '8*"+ # ( ")+ ('0" ! '"" 9( &" +()(! '"+ (0(+() &"(0))'+"

() "4&" 90)))!&" 4& # 3("

'"!&#+F( ('0"! '" ")

)("&)")#("+"0("+())) ('")0&)"4&"" "+() ( ) !& "('"

) "+(+()&)! + "+ !3" 0( (+(" "+()) 1( "" 0&)) +) ) " ' 0(( )( 3 "+ ' ) 0((" " # ("+" "+()I(+)"3 0) " "+()0(( )3 ( '""'E;""'' & (& >2 $4044"089 ( # & ) ( : ("0 "4&"#@ ::

>'""'? 3 "+() "&"

"&))3 "(""' '#" 3 "

+() "& " 0( & " ( ""' 'C? 1(""0 #0( "&"""3

' 0#0( "&"# 0( &))3 ""'E""'""'0(( ""3' ")3""'0(( )3&))3""'90)) !#(" "#!+&(+()0(('

"&)" ""&)"&" &!'

('"3 ""+ 0(("('"""( " .& + &"'""3 '+() &!)"""

)( (""!3( ( 0 ""3 ''( ")+ 8"

& ))" " (6&' &" ;&"

)9 ; 38*"& "

9"" (" = ;; #()0(( "+ (0 +)+ 9('""'" 1("+" )'( "+() 0&("F"+)'('""' 0))9

" ( (( &" (" 1(&"0(0+"# '&(" ()(0 + (" 0((+)) "+)'( "+() 0&("F"+)'('+()0))9' )" " ( 6&' 0((" ( ;&" 0 () ' ( " " +() &

"3# &"

&!)'( "+()

&(& " ' !) " (" ' ("+ & "

( (& " ' ( )'( "

+() " " +()0(( 0(+)"3!"+ "

")3 &&))3:)&+ (3 + +") 1(" " +()

0("4&" ) "+0(&&( (0 "))0"+"0(&&( ( )('"""#(:( ) ( '"

= ))0 ' ""+"3 " ( &""

9 """ ( "" "+ ' " "'(

"+"3 "( &""9) . 3 "

" +&" )) 1() 1( & 0((!3( )) "!( &"" 0))!"" ( ) ""+"30(((! "+ !

(* 252:;