High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/6403/2011dismissed

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Santro & ORS.

2019-11-02Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan8 pages

!"#$%&'()* +,

((-- .%$ /' /% %

0( 1%

% 3 '45 % ((--

% / !

1--+5 %%(!

$ 2$'%6%7+5

% 1$%+5 %%(!

3%-) + % (% -'/' /%9' %/ 3-"/7 9 % -+$%$5'% 4%$7 -' ($%/ %. - 7 %( 0' 9"%!"#$%&'()*

$%%'%)-4%7%7%! :0 ; +-'7 '( $0 -< " %

(% 5% (% -' ;

4$ '

-"77%',0 <

'%)-4%7%7%! :0 ; = "%57 '%)-+" %$2$'%"(--%%=" ) % %3 " % %5--7*< >%+ -- $+ - 4- $ 4 %+ %$--) --"-7" '%)-$%>$%= %'04+" "%--"7 '%)- ' 16# /+ 0 < 4$ $$'4 >$% %= ('%'?' 4)"$6%- :(-+0 <=0!

@ ;

"-71- /*< >%

%7 -' (%+ " $3 ###%A%$%0 + 4)7$ "%<=$'0 B+ "(%(% 4) (%%'7 -% -' (%(%) -'(4(

+4 %(((%-(% "%'7 -'(

# "%'-4)%(!

+ -'(7 '%)- 4 <4) +" "% ( "'2$ < 57

"%$% '%"<

%7 ' " -75-5%57 - '%)-"$%" %(! %-5'+ %%+ '(+)"4(4) $%'()

# "%'-4)%(! 9$% '()+ 5-5' '%)-C$ 7 -0 47%7% 4) (-" $-%%'57'(%' $% '()"-4-())'$ -'"% '(% % " -75- 5%57- %-5' '%)-"47 %5%5%' $%(-) # +4 %((%)%'- -'(

#$'%"%%' (%"%% C$((%$-5

% %7 %7$'+ % &-' %4$-+, %%%%% %4$-( -' ((%-)5"% @

"%'( 0 + + " % % D(%$'%' -7 (-- %-E '$4((% '7 -'C$--)+()4-4)4 %(>-) 5%--)

"%- $%'()77%5 ((% &$%4)")-7 (%((-(%)7 '4(+ '($7"%4 ((--9 $%'()44-5-4-)()'( -'

! ((-"75%(+" ($

((% %$7 $-

# 5 %-%$-% (%477 %$7 %%

' %$%7$'54)-%$- % ((--9$%'()" 4 -4 %(%)+ %% -'"%-7 ) '( %' $% '() # $((% + %%%

4) (?&$%" % -7 " '(% 5$% (-)+ (? &$% 4%5 '%47'(% 5$%(-)5%7 %(%)%<$'--)4'$-'=5%-) '?'$'$%)-4-)'7 $%5 -$( 5-$ '$% *% $- % ((-- $% '() $% %%-$(>$7'

! " ! !

!# $ % ! % ! + F4> ! @&##

! @@

4) /7-3 &$%+" %"4%5 %(%) - (%$-% - -$% %(%) $% (%) $%% % (%)(%+" $%%% $% %5% %(%) %5% "$4%7 -' %(%)) %5 -"5-5% -'(%)5 5 '(-)% $"%<' -''(

B 4 -%5% %(%)%-'%7$$% "5 -" %5 -%57'$%7 -"$% -" %. -

*%$-% ((--9$%'() $% %(-%-$(>$7'4)&%3 &$% - &

'( '

' ) !

@+" % "4%5 %5%4%7 -' %(%) % 5 -"5-5% -'(%)5E5E '(-)% $ "%<' '( 4 -' %' $%'()4)5<7 (%5/

%. -

% >$7' %%% 4) -% $- % ((--9$%'()"* '' ! +

, " %" --7" C$" %-7-%(%5(%%575 -% 4%%"7%' "%'" " $5-57) %5 -"$-4--''($%/ + "%" -4754%57 4%%"%( "% "% '-4%( '(-4-)() ' '

% +-%$-% %(!

5 '-) "%7 %4$-" >$--"7 -'(7%7'( (% -'$-4$" ' #$((%

+ %%%$ %)

+' !- '

./.

# % 0 ( 1234)/7-,$7 &$%" %" 4%5 " (%'$'"%'($-%)1 "% $'%5%"(+ "$-45$-)'5%"%% %5% 5 -+ %%4% %(%) 47 "% 4%'"%- (( "% 4) 4%%"7 5 - " (%' "%+ ") $%'()"-4-

*%$-% %( -'$% %%%% %% (4) (?&$%5" /(-*5((- &5- ! @ -7 >$7' 4'

*% $- % %( -' $% % %%%>$7' 4 % % 5&

' *! ! .36 63 4)& %4 &$%" %"4%5(%! $%

#!7'' %G $(% -'" '$%/ (-) $% " H -) 1-)I '(% 5 (<7 (-) 5' " %5--7:%:'%)-" 4%%"%' %-"% :G4-/$(%'&$% - 4 -4'(-) "% '%)- - $7 "

; $ %E%5 5 -4)"%++ %%+ "$-( "% '%4< #' 5" 4%%"% 5 -( "%+ %' (-) " '(% 5 (<7 (-) "$- -$ (%- -' (%%57 5 -(%5 -5- -

%' 45 $+ # 5" ?(% 4) &$% J' 2$'%G

$(% <G $(% '% " (%(- - 4) :G4- /$(%' &$% !7''G / G

$(%- ($%(4> (-) $%"%(%- + %%+%4) -%((--G$- --7 "% 7%$ 4 $

(-) 47 '(% 5 (-)+ $%'()(-4-)()'( -' # ( -' " 74$ )%"$3 ###%A% 1K 3-" /7 +(% -'! + % $ % 0 + (% ' 4) 7 $ "%<

@ $7 $+ " '7 5 4 77 $ %' "?'4$ )$74)$-4?( %4$ '-)<)4) %4)%%7%5 (%%4)%7%'>4 % -4$% (% " /$ %C$4 0 + 47% $7 %4$- <- ' 40

B+ (%$'%7 "$--)7)"%< ')$"% (%-?(4$ '' 7%)'( $% $%- ?( - + # '(0 + + "%$ )$7 $44 7 % %%+#) %%$ '()'%

((-'%7-)

3%>

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#