High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3860/2015dismissed

Karambir v. Hvpnl And ORS

2023-05-17Ms. Justice Jaishree Thakur6 pages

- ! "

!

! "

#$%&

$'( )&*+,*-.#)+%.* ))- %,

&/( 01%

& ! 1% !"

# -! "

3 "

! 20 % 0 45 #

2.

2 23 2&

60 !

32 788 6

! "

! ! 9 3 "

1 3 ! 00

!

0 .

21 !2 ! "

9 ! 3!0 * )0 ; (

0; 36

78 #

*/

1 " 3"

3 <!6-& !2 "

3 <!6 32 787 8787%

:;3

6

9"0

! !6 2

6 6 =" 1 0 23!!1 2

;3

4 77

20 #> 7 277 13!!300 3

77 3!0

6

1 "

3 6 0 ;

" 3 !0312

- 9"0 !00 6 !

; 20 6 0 3!! 3

77

3 "

3

600

0

!-!

!#0# 3"!0 "

?0*"#

31

!!61!36 !6! !!00 6 !; 3; 2 #> 2

1 3!! 3 00 3

8

!6! 3:! ) ! 13! 9"03

660 1 !20 #0* 3!!3 !2 ""0"2 ;! 0 3 !2 90 ; 22 ""01 31!060"

"" *% 0

3! 9

! "0 ; 60 "

19"0 3 0

! ! 3! ! 9 6

/ ; ! *%1 2 0 9"0 3 60 7 32 7772 ! ! 9 (!

360 3 !0 "0

300

"

*:

0;1 1

! 2"

20 9"0300 3

01 3!! 3 !00 6 ; ! 32 ! 6! #> 2 0 6!# 6

! 0

0 2 "

1 3!! 3 00 3 9 6

% 77" #> 7 77! 6

0 ;

!"

" 6

3 ! 031 "

! ! "

0 " 66

!!6 2

6 6

- =" $ "0

2 :;" 61!

3

4

3 1 3!! 3 "

;

-!2 1

3 2

@%

= A .

""01 ! "

3

<

!"

23 <!6-&

3 "

3 < !6 - & 0

-! 3!0 * )0 ; ( 2 "

0;

788 6& # 585B)5B85( 88 !300

3 < !6 0!

2 788 ; 3 < !6 "0 ; 3 60 -! :

2 6! # %

2

8 0

3!0 2 788 !3

3 <!6 221 ;3

60

! "

0; @%

= A % 2 "

0 32 2 60

2 !

1

01 0;36 3 < !6 "0 ; 2

; ! * 3!! 3 "

;

3 60 -!2 3 !

?0*"# ! 2

!"##$% &

''

(1 !* 3 ! 3 !60

0

2 ; 0

-!2 1

8 4 1

22 " 260C

2B "# /"0 ;13 <

5

5 0; 3653 < !6 -! "

! 60C

8 4

!

60C 2" "

01 6!

- ! 3 060 !2 1 ! !

0

!

%

3 < 60C 6

1 !"" ;3; 2

3 "

4 0"" 62

3 0

6!

60C 1 ! ! 6

9"0 (!

1 3!

3 9

! .

6 9 (!

360C 13!! ! 60C

29"0 !2 1

! 2" ;1 "

6!

60C

1 0 0 ""

!02

0 "

0 ! 2 60C

2 !

5 0;365

5" 3 <

3 ! 3 "0 2 9 6

" ;

?0 *" #

!%" 2 1"

3

60C

!3< !*

3

! !

6 =" 1!

31

""020 1"

3

<6 ;

00.

6

13!!3 0 ""00 !

13 0

2 660C .!! 0 02 !" !" !""

< -! :

2

2 ! # 3! ! "

3 0

60C

0 ;!

! " ;3 !9"0 (!

%

2 2

"

9"0 3

2 2 !; !

-

6 =" 9"0 20 0 1 3!! 3

3 D 3!

""

3 ; !3 1 0 6 "

! "

;

6 !.

<6 1 "

! "

0 " 61 3!! 0

2

.

! ""0 "2 6 !1

3 "

<33

!-!3< 2 ;13!!"

2 ! 2!

"

00 ! 3!

3 !3

< < 6

"

1 3!0 "

"

2

<%"B

0

1 3!!

1 "0 ;53 <!

0 !

2

0 ;

46 0;

!

!# 5- 0.2 !<

20 ;1!< !

0

0 = ;0

6" 7 ; ;

312 <

220 ;16

;

!2 !" 2!< " 2 ; ;-!2 1 !:

3! !

3 0

60C

3 6 1

!2 !< 2 " 2 ; ; 7 % 2 ! 0

< 6 " ; 3 ! 9"0

1

<

1 9"0 3 < <

3 ; ! #0

-4 # 1 3!! 3 22 6!

"

?0 *" # D 3! !

! 1!3 2 0 6 "

0 :;13!! 3 ""0; < 6 0

3 "

2

<33 -!"

3

6 ;

"

-! 3 < !

! !2 1!

0" ;3 !9"013!

360C

0;

2 ! 9 (!

? 3 60C & 1 2 60C

2 2 9"0 3 " 3 0 "0

3

"

.

3 !2 2 1

2 ; ! "; 6!

;

!

3 "

#

0;1 ! 1 6 2 # ! $%&'

<9E >! !"< 65

F5 >! !"

0 F5