High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24202/2017dismissed

Bhagat Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2017-10-26Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan5 pages

!"!# $%"

&#$#$'%&( &()*)

#!#&'+ *%,!-!%.'# &()

&)/'%.&%#) 0 1

2 0 0 1

2 0 (&)&%#

(&)&%#

!33*.4'5!#&+'(# &/&#$#$'%&( 676767 676767 676767 676767 &#$#$'%&( !. )*-,&5#&. $3)&8+ #' ! /('5&)) '+ (&5(*$#3&%# +'( !//'$%#3&%# !) ! 3!8& '%)#!-8& *%.&( # & "&%&(!85!#&"'(9$%/*()*!%5&#'!.4&(#$)&3&%# .!#&.

; $))*&.-9# &$(&5#'(&%&(!8'+ '8$5& *%,!- % #&(3) '+ # & )&8&5#$'% 5($#&($! .$)58')&. $% # & !.4&(#$)&3&%# /&#$#$'%&( !))&5*(&.=3!(>)$%# &+$%!83&($# //!(&%#89 '# &(5!%.$.!#&)-&8'%"$%"#'# &"&%&(!85!#&"'(9? ' !4&!8)' )&5*(&. = 3!(>) !) /&( +$%!8 3&($# !4& -&&% !//'$%#&. &#$#$'%&( !)-&&%.&%$&.!//'$%#3&%# 8&!.$%") '%(&5'(.

?'*8.$%.$5!#&# !#*%.&( $))*&.-9# & $(&5#'(&%&(!8'+ '8$5& *%,!-'%# &)*-,&5#'+(&5(*$#3&%#'+ '%)#!-8&) @3!8&:+&3!8&A $% $)#($5# '8$5& !.(& !%. (3&. '8$5& !.(& '+ *%,!- '8$5& 8!*)& /('4$.&) # !# ? $8&

/(&/!($%" ! 5'3-$%&. +$%!8 3&($# 8$)# $% # & &4&%# '+ #?' 5!%.$.!#&))&5*($%"&B*!83!(>)!5!%.$.!#&)&%$'($%!"&) !88 -&!55'(.&./(&+&(&%5& &.!#&'+-$(# '+# &/&#$#$'%&($) CC!%.# &'# &(5!%.$.!#&)? '?&(&-(!5>&#&.$%3&($# !4$%")&5*(&.&B*!83!(>)$ & =3!(>)!(&5'%5&.&.89&8.&( #'# &/&#$#$'%&( &$%)#!%#?($#/&#$#$'% !)-&&%+$8&.$3/*"%$%"# & '++&%.$%"58!*)& !%.? $5 $)$% # &+'88'?$%"#&(3)

D@!A$%# &&4&%#'+# &5!%.$.!#&) !4$%"&B*!83!(>) # & 5!%.$.!#& )&%$'( $% !"& ) !88 -& $" &( $% # & 3&($# @-A EEE EEE EEE @5A EEE EEE EEEF ;

&!(%&.5'*%)&8?'*8.!("*&# !## &'++&%.$%"58!*)& $)!(-$#(!(9!)!8)'$88&"!8$%!)3*5 !) &!(8$&(!.&5$)$'% !. -&&%#!>&%-9# &(&)/'%.&%#1 #!#&#'/(&+&(5!%.$.!#&)9'*%"&( $%!"&$%# &&4&%#*!8$#9'+#?''(3'(&5!%.$.!#&) !4$%"&B*!8 3!(>) #$)*("&.# !#)*5 .&5$)$'%?!)5'%#!$%&.$%3&3' .!#&. C ;

%%&E*(& < !%. ? $5 !. -&&% /*# #' 5 !88&%"& !%. */ &8. -9 # $) '*(# 4$.& ,*."3&%# .!#&. ;$%$4$8($# &#$#$'% ==C'+@ !4$#', $%" 4 @ !4$#', $%" 4 @ !4$#', $%" 4 @ !4$#', $%" 4

#!#& '+ *%,!- !%. '# &()A

#!#& '+ *%,!- !%. '# &()A %%&E*(& &!(%&. 5'*%)&8 !("*&)# !## &(&!)'%!%.8'"$5+'(+$E$%"!5($#&($!? &(&-9! 9'*%"&(/&()'%?!)#'-&"$4&%/(&+&(&%5&? &%-(!5>&#&.$% 3&($#?!)# !#!)/&((&B*$(&3&%#'+-&$%"!3&3-&('+/'8$5& +'(5&!9'*%"&(/&()'%?'*8.-&3'(&&%&("&#$5!%.!))*5 $%

;

!-&##&(5!/!5$#9#'.$)5 !("&# &!(.*'*).*#$&)!##!5 &.#'# & !))$"%3&%# !4$%" &!(. 8&!(%&. 5'*%)&8 +'( # & /&#$#$'%&( !# 8&%"# !%. !4$%"/&(*)&.# &/8&!.$%")'%(&5'(.# $)'*(#$) '+# &5'%)$.&(&.4$&?# !## &4!8$.$#9'+'++&%.$%"8!*)& @!A'+

?'*8.%'#(&B*$(&!%9&E!3$%!#$'%'% 3&($#) #$)-9%'??&88)&##8&.# !#$+!5!%.$.!#&/!(#$5$/!#&) $%!/('5&))'+)&8&5#$'%? &(&$%# &&8$"$-$8$#95($#&($!!)!8)' 5($#&($!'+)&8&5#$'%)#!%.).$)58')&.-&+'(& !%.)*5 5!%.$.!#& 5!%%'## &(&!+#&(*/'% !4$%"-&&%*%)*55&))+*8-&/&(3$##&. #'#*(%!('*%.!%. #'5'%#&%.# !## &&8$"$-$8$#95($#&($!?!) !(-$#(!(9!%.?('%"89+(!3&.

(&+&(&%5&$%# $)(&"!(.3!9-& 3!.&#'# &.&5$)$'%)'+# &'%2-8& */(&3&'*(#'+%.$!$% 0!.!%!8!%.'# &()4 #!#&'+ 0!.!%!8!%.'# &()4 #!#&'+ 0!.!%!8!%.'# &()4 #!#&'+ 0!.!%!8!%.'# &()4 #!#&'+!33*GH!) 3$(CC< !33*GH!) 3$(CC< !33*GH!) 3$(CC< !33*GH!) 3$(CC< == == == ==!%.

!9!>4 '!

!9!>4 '!%$4&()$#9@A

< %$4&()$#9@A

< % # & /(&)&%# 5!)& # & !.4&(#$)&3&%# .!#&. ; $%(&)/'%)&#'? $5 # &/&#$#$'%&( !.!//8$&.+'(# & /')#'+3!8&'%)#!-8&@"&%&(!85!#&"'(9A !)-&&%/8!5&.'% (&5'(.!%.!//&%.&.!)%%&E*(& ;

&%&(!8$%)#(*5#$'%)+'( # &5!%.$.!#&)?&(&5'%#!$%&.$%8!*)& 8!*)&@4$$A?!) $%# &+'88'?$%"#&(3)

D4$$ !%.$.!#&) !(& !.4$)&. #' "' # ('*" # & "*$.&8$%&):$%)#(*5#$'%) +'( +$88$%" */ # & //8$5!#$'% '(3'%8$%&!)?&88!)# & (.&(@

A'+# & '++$5&'+$(&5#'(&%&(!8'+ '8$5&4$.& '+

? $5 $)# &"'4&(%$%".'5*3&%#+'(# &&5(*$#3&%#

/('5&))@ A'+'%)#!-8&)$% *%,!- '8$5& &

#!%.$%" (.&( 5'%#!$%$%" .&#!$8&. 5($#&($!:&8$"$-$8$#9 5'%.$#$'%)&#5 $)!4!$8!-8&'%# &(&5(*$#3&%#?&-)$#& @???

/*%,!-/'8$5&(&5(*$#3&%# $%AF

)#!%.))/&5$+$5!889(&+&((&.

#' *%.&( 8!*)& @4$$A '+ # & &%&(!8 %)#(*5#$'%) +'( # & /(')/&5#$4&5!%.$.!#&) 8!*)&

?!)5!#&"'($5#'# &&++&5## !#$%# &&4&%#'+5!%.$.!#&) !4$%" &B*!8 3!(>) # & 5!%.$.!#& )&%$'( $% !"& ) !88 -& 5'%)$.&(&. $" &($%3&($# = &#$#$'%&( &(&$%)*-3$##&. $)!//8$5!#$'%+'(# &/')# $%B*&)#$'%!%.)*-,&5#&. $3)&8+#'!/('5&))'+)&8&5#$'%!)/&( #&(3) !%. 5'%.$#$'%) 5'%#!$%&. $% # & !.4&(#$)&3&%# !(#$5$/!#$'%'+# &/&#$#$'%&($%# &(&5(*$#3&%#/('5&))$)%'# )#!#&. #' -& *%.&( /('#&)# %.&( # & "&%&(!8 $%)#(*5#$'%) 5'%#!$%&. $% # & !.4&(#$)&3&%# &!5 !%. &4&(9 !//8$5!%# $%58*.$%"# &/&#$#$'%&( &(&$% !.-&&%/*##'%'#$5&# !## &

(.&('+# &'++$5&'+$(&5#'(&%&(!8'+ '8$5&-&!($%"

?'*8.-&# &"'4&(%$%".'5*3&%#+'(# &(&5(*$#3&%# /('5&))!%.)*5 (.&($)!4!$8!-8&'%# &(&5(*$#3&%# ?&-)$#&$ & ???

/*%,!-/'8$5&(&5(*$#3&%# $% &#$#$'%&( !) )*5 ?!) 3!.& !?!(& !# # & 4&(9 # (&) '8.# !#$%# &&4&%#*!8$#9'+-&$%"-(!5>&#&.$%3&($#?$# '%&'(3'(&5!%.$.!#&)# &5!%.$.!#&&8.&($%!"&?'*8.-& /(&+&((&.

9!//89$%"# &.$5#*38!$..'?%-9# &/&E'*(#$% 0!.!%!82) 0!.!%!82) 0!.!%!82) 0!.!%!82)5!)&@)*/(!A# &/&#$#$'%&( !4$%"-&&%-(!5>&#&.$% #&(3)'+3&($#$ & !4$%")&5*(&.=3!(>)$%# &+$%!83&($#8$)#

5!%%'#%'?-&/&(3$##&.#'#*(%!('*%.#'(!$)&!5 !88&%"&#' # &&8$"$-$8$#9!)!8)')&8&5#$'%5($#&($!!%.!)5'%#!$%&.$%# &

? &(&-9# &5!%.$.!#&&8.&($%!"&#'

# &/&#$#$'%&( !)-&&%/(&+&((&.!%.# &/&#$#$'%&( !)-&&% .&58$%&.!//'$%#3&%# '(# &(&!)'%)(&5'(.&.!-'4&# &?($#/&#$#$'%$) .$)3$))&.

# $) '?&4&( 58!($+$&. # !# # $) '*(# !) %'# &E/(&))&.!%9'/$%$'%'%3&($#)!)(&"!(.)# &4!8$.$#9'+# & '++&%.$%"8!*)& $))*&.-9# & $(&5#'(&%&(!8'+ '8$5& *%,!- $)3$))&.

@ A @ A @ A @ A

'#&

&# &()/&!>$%":(&!)'%&.

&):

&# &(&/'(#!-8&

&):