H.S Dhillon v. Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited & Others


 

       


   

 

 

          



   


!  " 

 ! "! #$%& ' (!)*$+%, " -*"! %.(! %.& )!/  )0*



  1 1   



     #   2".!- !.!.*( "3&&". 4 %,5! %.)'.))3+*6.)*".&.(3+ 3--+.73!.*(6.+ %, 6*" !  (!"3+%'.(.)!"3!.4 ".,$(3+ 3(%.&3"

 (786*")*"!9! ".,$(3+9:-"35.(&6*";$3).(&! 73"&
) !! (;$."5" -*"!3(%! - (3+!5.'-*) %*(.',5! 3--*.(!.(&$!*".!5 3)-" 6 "" %! -" ) (!2".!- !.!.*(   3"%! )$,'.)).*()'3% ,5+ 3"( %7*$() +3-- 3".(&6*" ! 2".!- !.!.*( " <  )7*- *6#$%.7.3+" 4. 2*6! %.)7.-+.(3"5-"*7 %.(&) .(.!.3! %,5! 3--*.(!.(&$!*".!53&3.()!.!) '-+*5 .)4 "5+.'.! %

.+  = "7.).(&-*2 "*6#$%.7.3+" 4. 2!  *$"!)3++(*!3--" 7.3! !

4.% (7 3)3(3-- ++3! $!*".!5!.)32 ++) !!+ %-"*-*).!.*(*6+32 !3!#$%.7.3+" 4. 2.)+.'.! %!*! -"*7 ))*6'3>.(&! % 7.).*(3(%(*!

3)  " &3"%)  !  % 7.).*(  !3> (  ,5 ! $!*".!. )  4 (  3)  " &3"%)  !


;$3(!$'*6-$(.)' (!.'-*) %*(! % +.(;$ (!!  *$"!)*$+%, " +$7!3(!!*.(! "6 " 2.!! 2.)%*'*6! 3--*.(!.(&$!*".!5 (+5.(3 "3" 73) 2 " ! - (3+!5.'-*) %*(! % +.(;$ (!.)6*$(%&"*))+5 %.)-"*-*"!.*(3! !*! '.)7*(%$7!3++ & %3&3.()!! % +.(;$ (!*"! ;$3(!$'*6- (3+!5.'-*) %*(! % +.(;$ (!)3> )! 7*()7. (7 *6!

*$"!.(! "6 " (7 ,5!  *$"!%$".(&! 7*$") *6#$%.7.3+" 4. 2.) 23""3(! % ?

3"( %7*$() +3-- 3".(&6*"! 2".!- !.!.*( "%"32.(&! 3!! (!.*(*6!  (7!*! 6.(%.(&)" 7*"% %,5! (;$."5 66.7 "3% )$,'.!! %!3!! (;$."5 66.7 "3%7*) (!*'*%.65.)6.(%.(& 

(373" 6$+- "$)3+*6!  (;$."5" -*"!2 6.(%!3!! (;$."5  66.7 "  *".&.(3++5  )$&& )! %  !3!  4*.7  " 7*"% %  )*$+%  , )7. (!.6.73++53(3+5@ %, 6*" .'-*).(&- (3+!5 $!+3! "*( 34.(& " 3+.@ %  !3!  -"**6  , 5*(%  " 3)*(3,+  %*$,!  23)  (*!  " ;$." %  !*  , )!3,+.) %,$!*(+5-" -*(% "3(7 *6 4.% (7 23)" ;$." %!* )!3,+.) ! 73"& ))+.&!+5'*%.6. %! 6.(%.(& $!$+!.'3! +5! (;$."5

66.7 "6*$(%!3!! 73"& ))!**% )!3,+.) %$73'*%.6.73!.*('3% ,5! (;$."5 66.7 ".(! 6.(%.(&)" (% " %,5.'%* )(*!73++6*" ;$3).(&*6!  (!." % -3"!' (!3+-"*7 %.(&).(.!.3! %3)3&3.()!! 2".! - !.!.*( " A (! .()!3(!73) .!.)6*$(%!3!73"& )2 " %$+56"3' % (;$."5  23)  7*(%$7! %  *(+5  36! "  &.4.(&  %$  *--*"!$(.!5  !*  !  2".! - !.!.*( "3(%! ;$3(!$'*6-$(.)' (!3+)*%* )(*!) '!*, &"*))+5 %.)-"*-*"!.*(3!    " 6*"   .(  *$"  4. 2  + 3"( %  ".,$(3+  3)  ".&!+5

<
" 6$) %!*.(! "6 " 2.!! %.)7.-+.(3"5-"*7 %.(&).(.!.3! %3)3&3.()!! 2".!  - !.!.*( "  2.7  $+!.'3! +5  7$+'.(3! %  .(  .'-*).(&  - (3+!5  *6 " %$7!.*(,5!2*)!3& ).(! !.' )73+ *6-356*"3- ".*%*6*( 5 3" B

".!- !.!.*()!3(%)%.)'.)) %  $  %  !"   $&$)! $!  "% $+3!.

 !"