Anupam Batra And ORS. v. State Of Punjab And ORS.
!"#"$"
%"" ""$"
&'
()*+ ,- (+./0/,12 2 31456) 7)*8) )19 ,*:+80 222+*/*/,1+80 ;+8040 <*)*+ ,- 41=)> )19 ,*:+80 222?+05,19+1*0
"@A B#C@ D!
E"@""
$"
% FFFF 8+0+1* 82 G++8)= <:)86)H 39I,.)*+ -,8 *:+ 5+*/*/,1+802 82 )1/5)J </1K: 3*L)JH (3MH 41=)> FFFF "@""
$"
%N!D 2 O:+ 58)P+8 /1 *:+ 58+0+1* 5+*/*/,1 /0 -,8 9/8+.*/,10 *, *:+ 8+05,19+1*0 *, )JJ,* MQ )..,41*0 419+8 *:+
J9 +10/,1 <.:+6+H >P .,41*/1K *:+ L:,J+ 5+8/,9 ,- 9)/JP L)K+0'.,1*8).*4)J 0+8I/.+ ,- *:+ 5+*/*/,1+80 )0 R4)J/-P/1K -,8 *:+ 0)6+2 2 S+)81+9 .,410+J 04>6/*0 *:)* *:+ 5+*/*/,1+80 L+8+ )55,/1*+9 ,1 .,1*8).* >)0/0 )0 O+.:1/.)J' ?+0+)8.: 300/0*)1*0' <48I+P,80H <*)*/0*/.)J 300/0*)1* )19 Q/+J9 300/0*)1* /1 *:+ P+)80 >+*L++1 )19 &H L:+8+)-*+8 *:+/8 0+8I/.+0 L+8+ 8+K4J)8/T+9 /1 2 ,L+I+8 *:+P L+8+ 9+1/+9 >+1+-/*0 419+8 *:+
J9 +10/,1 <.:+6+ ,1 )..,41* ,- *:+ G+L ,1*8/>4*,8P +10/,1 <.:+6+ :)I/1K .,6+ /1*, ,5+8)*/,1 5,0* 2 2 2 O:+ /004+ /0 1, J,1K+8 8+0 /1*+K8)H :)I/1K >++1 9+./9+9 >P *:+ (/I/0/,1 7+1.: ,- *:/0 ,48* /1 UVWUXY CUZ [YD E\U\] ^_ `XaUW UXb ^\c]VY H & H 9+./9+9 ,1 &2 2 H )K)/10* L:/.: *:+ <S )0 L+JJ )0 *:+ ?+I/+L 355J/.)*/,1 L+8+ 9/06/00+9 ,1 & 2 2 )19 22 8+05+.*/I+JP2 Q,JJ,L/1K *:+ )>,I+ )19 .,10/9+8/1K ?4J+ &2 ,- 41=)>
!" # !
# $ !!$
% &'()*+,%% &-'.'/%% 012%% 3/'/4%% 56%% 7)*+'(%% '*8%% 5/-491:% #; < < =
#>
?@ AB#C "# #D$ >#A C !#
C F ##D !
F;
>"
BB#;!A;! #; < < !"
!" H E>;$ #;!G !#C ;#; I ;$ "A
$
BB G "$ "A !# G F#;$
;$ !"
$ ;#;
G;F ; B# !# < < < JD ; % K44L'*% % M'/'%% 012%% 3/'/4%% 56%% 7)*+'(%% '*8%% 5/-491% = $$$ #; < <
! !A B
F ;!$ !" G;>!
G;F A$ GC !" B!!#; "; ;! B "#> $ !"
NO" P !#; #>
!# "!"
; AB#C "# F $
>! G F#;$ GC !" H ;#; "A # !"
$ ;#; "A !!$
;$ "
$C
!!
;$ >;
!C
B !# !" #;Q G BA # ! #> ?;$ < O" E#; R;" #> !" # ! " $$;F H#< = #> !!$
% S'9('*1%% M'T% % U912%% 3/'/4%% 56%% 7)*+'(%% V%% W912% $$$ #; = "
"$ !"
!
; AB#C "#
;
#; !"# F" " AF"! "
G; F $
>! !" $ $ ! !# G F#;$
;$ !"
$ ;#; "A<O" ;! B#!#; #> !" X $FA;! ;$ NI#A !"
G# $ #; "
#A !# !" #; #; !"
! !" ;! $ C
F #> !" B!!#; >#A
! !" $ ! #> " F Y !#; !# G # ;!$
P
>C;F ># !" B# #> B;#;< G $A$ !# G ; F#!< B# !# < < < O" ;
! !
$ E>;$ #;!G !#; ;#; "A
Z;;[ "
G; ;!#$ $ ># !" ; ;! ;! ; !" ;X G \#;A;! <<>< < < ;#! G
BB G !# !" B!!#;< O"
A;$A;! $ $ Z;;[
A;$;F !" ;X G
;;#! G > !"
A;$$ GC ;F > !#;];! !#; $ !$ = < <
Z;;[ = O" B!!#; #;!;
!# G F#;$ GC !" \I "A
;$ "$ ;!!$ !# B;#;
C G;>!
BB G !# !" AB#C !$ ; !" ;X G \#!< B# !# < < < ?; #> !"
G# !" ! B!!#;
# $< Z#$;FC B#;$;!
$!$ !# ! ! !" "# B#$ #> #D "
F
P
>$ ># B;#; G
#$;FC !# > !#; $ #; = < <
Z;;[ = !" ; $>;$ #;!G !#C ;#; "A $ G
BB G !#
!"# AB#C "# "
G; #D;F B# !#
!"
#
$
% !& '
&!( #
& ) ) # # '!# ( !*
+'
#!!(& ,- '
$
, .!!
'
!(# ($
*( & $ (* # ($
) !' ($ )(', ($ !& (
/( (
& ( )(&&0 1 ( &!# 2# *
&
#, !
# $!
!, ' ( ( 4'
* ( ($ #! & 4'
)! % !!( $!
# !
& &!# 2# *
, 4 ($ 2 &
#,
#!&*!&& # 1
$(
- $!
& (2 )!( .!)
&'(
& 6
(
, '
!!(
$! ($ '
&!( (
( # '
!!(
.! (
# , / . ( !( , (!#
7 #& 4) * ( #& ( ( # # !& ! (
) # 1 & )( # (2 )!( .!) &
6
,
&'(
& !&
!$
#
&!( 4) * !& '' !) '( '
!!(
-
'!
!
. '
(!&!( & ($ 8 9- &
!)
# , '
!!(
( ' !* &!& )
( )( # & : !$,!
&
!) $(
($ '
&!( ,
$!& 1 &!# 8 &
#,
'
# , !& ( .!
)!#!
/( ;; ($ ! # <!
4!
=& 4 ($ , # (
& ( .
&( &!*! : &!( ($ . (& &!# )& &(
*' (,
& .( 6!
( ' !* &!&- .
&
6!
$! ($ ' !* &
!) (
# & : !$,!
&
!) $(
($ '
&!( ,
$!& 9$
,!
'( 2# *
> & # =& 4 ($ 2 # (
&- !& ( .!
)!#!
/( ;; ($ - ( - # ( )
*' (,
& .( # .!
&'(
& ( ( ' !* &!&- # &!# ' !* &
!) &
6
( ))( $(
!&!( ($ &
!) ($
*' (,
-
$! ($ &!# &
!) - )
(
# ( )( # & : !$,!
&
!) $(
($ '
&!( ,
$!& 1
'( !( ($ 2# *
!& &
++ ++ ++ 9 !
& &!# (
%9 /( ; ($ ; .& $!
# , ?(
*
($ , # !# (
# # ;- $
(!)!
'
(!&!( ($ 8 9- @!!&!(
) # ( , &(
* ' !*
*' (,*
# ((
&'
)!$!) )( !
),- & ( (
# .!
)(*'!
'
&!( ,
$!& 1 @!!&!(
) # .
*' (,
& .( # $( ( !* # )( !
(& ,- .!) !& *(
)# - &* )
(
# & ' !*
*
- # )
( (
# .!
)(*'!
'
&!( ,
$!& 1
'( !( ($ 2# *
($ @!!&!( A
) !& &
++ ++ ++ 1 : &!( ($ . & ( .
- ' !* &
!) !& ( )( # $( )(*'!
'
&!( ,
$!& !
)* ' $( )( &!#
!( $(
!& ( /( ($ ; ! # & B! A . = & 4 ($ ,
&- )!# # ( &!# )& &(-
'!
!
. )!&!( ($ (( #!
) <!
4!
3 & &
4'
& .
(
'&& # %9 /( ; ($ ;-
! "#$% !&
& & #!
" !
''
$% " ! %!
!$$ & "#'& ! ('!$%)
* +
$ ! # ,'&)" !
'& -. !
!
& ' $ #!
!& !
) ') & !$ !
! * ' $ # & ! # !&
& &
#!
" !
!
) " /* * $$ * * 0
!" $!$ '& ! ('!$%)
) ! # !
% * ' $ # '
& ! ') # 1) #!
" !
0 ' 1& !' %!
0 !
!& ! & !
)& &' #!
" !
* 2'
0 # 1) !
$0 !
!& ! & !
)) &' #!
" !&
!" !
& & !
)'$!
"#$%" !$$ !& #'
# * !&0 ' $
#&
! ! !##" "!& #!
" !
0
!" ! & & ! ('!$%)
3 4*
5 36 7$..0 ! &) 0 #!
"
! !& !
! ('!$%)
* . ! "! ! ! # 1& #!
" !
''
$% %!
* 5 #
)!)& #!
" $% !
# , !&
# & # &* . !
!& ! ! "#$%0 1) ''
$% %!
$0 ! #!
" ,* +
!&
!& ! $) " "#$%" !$$ !& #'
# * 5 2'$$ 8 '
9 !&:
'# ! !
$& ! &!$% !)
0 $$ & %
)'$!
;!
0 '& ! ('!$%)
) ! # !
% *
0 &!$% !)
'& ! ('!$%)
0 !
!& ! ''
!##"
& & % # %!
') #!
" !
0 $
! &!$% !)
& & % ! "#$%* + ,'
! ) %
#& &%
!& 0 < # 6'$ 4*
5* +
!& 6'$ !
!$ !&% & & 9 !&:
'# ! !& !
$& ! &!$% !)
$$ & %
)'$!
)& ') !& ('!$%)
"#') # !
% * + 0
# !
& & %!
! " /* * $$ * * ! ) & "#') # !
% # *=
! " #$
#! " %&"'( ) * " + & ,- # #,
"
(
%&"'( . ! #
" #!
!
,"
#
&
'
( !
/&, $ ' !
!
. '&, 0") 1 .
#!-
" #%
. # " #$
"
( !
" " #$
(
,, ) ) # & " /&, $ ' !
, #,
# % ") 2
#%
" #$
& ,
"
" $
#
$
,"
, ,. " ! , "$ # % "-
,"
,"
'
$ #
, , '
!
& "
," +()
,,.") " "
"
& "
," +(
'
$ #
" . , " '
'
$ #
& "
," +(-
!
" " #$
(
,, ,, , #
" /&, $ ' !
( &
'
$ #
) *
,&,
$ #
# " #$
" .
"
. ( (
" $
" " . ! (&
& "
,"
,&,
,, # ,"
.
" 3 . ( )4 5) * " + & ,- "
# - # & #,
!
&,
" " . & $ "
!
(
" %&"'(
$ $ ,.) ) 1 .6
"-
"
"
(
%&"'(
"
7 899:;<77 =;>;7 - 7 ?;@A;<B77 =;C7 " 7 D;AE<FG77 DH;I;>7
& ) J7 KLKM7N?KOP?KQR7 S7
, - 8OPTU7 "
6 ' VWX #, VWX