High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/6489/2011disposed of

Shobha Rani v. M/S Shareen Hire Purchase Pvt. Ltd. And ANR.

2015-09-17Mr. Justice Arun Monga3 pages

!"##$%&%'()#*"#+,#- ./ )+")1,1! !'% **#22!'"

3#-&4& 5&)1!-##'%-# 4-$1!&# -%6!"#7%+%"#8 !'"1#- #&*'8#'"&

# $

91#"1#- #*-"#-&2$!2*!*#-&+!:,#!22;#8"&##"1#<48=+#'"> ,#-##--#8""1# #*-"#-&-'"> ? 91#"1#-"1#<48=+#'"&1428,#-#*-"#8%'"1#%=#&">

-#&#'"( -@)1!-+!/86$!"#/ -"1#!**#22!'" &'<4!'&!2/86$!"#/ --!'8##*))!$18#6/86$!"#/ --#&*'8#'" AAAAA "!

# $

'() 1#$1!22#'=#%'"1#*-#&#'"!**#!2%&""1#%+*4='#8-8#- 8!"#80

*!&&#8,:"1#88%"%'!2%&"-%$"48=#/!2!'81!-/;1#-#,: "1#,<#$"%'&4'8#-)#$"%'?"1#-,%"-!"%'!'8'$%2%!"%'$"/

-&1-"B $"C %2#8!=!%'&""1#!;!-88!"#8 ./1!6# ,##'8%&+%&&#8'"1#=-4'8"1!""1#:;#-#,!--#8,:2%+%"!"%' -@)1!-+!/2#!-'#8$4'&#2!**#!-%'=',#1!2"1# !**#22!'"&4,+%"&"1!""14=1!&*#-"1#*-6%&%'&)#$"%'?

0 "1#

$"/$*:"1#!;!-81!&",#=%6#'""1###$"#8*!-":!'8%'$!&#

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

#- "1#-#-#/'4&#42 *4-*&#;428,#&#-6#8,:-#+!'8%'="1#+!""#-,!$E""1#,<#$"%'= $4-"-8#$%8%'="1#,<#$"%'&!-#&1!&%";428,#!""!2!-$%$!2 #F#-$%&# 1!6#1#!-8"1#2#!-'#8$4'&#2-"1#*!-"%#&!'8!**-!%&#8 "1#*!*#-,E 1#!;!-8"1#!-,%"-!"-8#&'"-#6#!2!,4""1#+8#!'8 +#!'&&#'8%'=$*:"1#!;!-8!'8/"14&/"1#-#%&!,2!"'"6%2!"%' "1#*-6%&%'&)#$"%'?

0 $"1#*2#!"1!""1#$2!%+!'"1!8 !$D4%-#8"1#E';2#8=#"1#!;!-8'2:;1#'"1#:-#$#%6#8$*:"1# #F#$4"%' !**2%$!"%' !**#!-& " ,# <4&"%%#8 !& "1# !;!-8 2!$E& "1# $+*2%!'$#"1#!-#+#'"%'#8*-6%&%'&"1#$" '+:6%#;/"1#88%"%'!2%&"-%$"48=#1!&'"$'&%8#-#8 "1#!-#+#'"%'#8*-6%&%'&"1#)"!"4"#!'8!&;#22!&$*:"1#

* !;!-8/;1#-#,:"1#!-,%"-!"-1!&!%2#8",&#-6#"1#+8#!'8+#!'& "1#$++4'%$!"%'1%&8#$%&%'""1###$"#8*!-": '6%#;;1!"1!&,##',&#-6#8!,6#/"1#%+*4='#8-8#- %&&#"G!&%8#!'8"1#+!""#-%&-#+%""#8,!$E""1#,<#$"%'=$4-""8#$%8# "1#,<#$"%'&!-#&1%'!$$-8!'$#;%"12!; " %& #F*#$"#8 "1!" "1# ,<#$"%'= 4-" +!: 8#$%8# "1# ,<#$"%'&!&#F*#8%"%4&2:!&*&&%,2#/*-##-!,2:;%"1%'!*#-%8&%F +'"1&-+"1#8!"#-#$#%*"$#-"%%#8$*:"1#-8#- 1#-#$-8&,#&#'",!$E""1#4-"&$'$#-'#8-"1;%"1 1#*!-"%#&/"1-4=1"1#%-$4'&#2/!-#8%-#$"#8"!**#!-,#-# "1#88%"%'!2%&"-%$"48=#/!2!'81!-' 0/;1+!:1#!-"1# ,<#$"%'&-!&&%='"1#&!+#"&+#"1#-$+*#"#'"4-" 1#!**#!2%&!$$-8%'=2:8%&*&#8 +,-+./+'

1 "!

'(.+23