Commissioner Of Income Tax-I, Ludhiana v. M/S Truck Operator Union,




    
 
 

  ! "#$#%&'( ))#$$#% *
%")  +
,-.!/# %

0011 22 %

3$*."4 1 * * %#%,!!

!/ %

%!#,-.!/# %  0 $1%! %  & 5-

 6
7


-  5-

6 6
   -
  

 

         

   

   

  

     

 !  ""##  "   8 97.) * # 2,

 $""# %"  %& ""##'!((  ) $ *  
 +,  -* $ . /0$     1 

,(


" %& 
 +,""## $%(#2  $0 3

4342  $0

%!$&. $%(#/$
5* 62786

- +&

*'

5 #$+$0 ##9$0 (%$#:($ #9'

$ ;

     $ (+   74%#
 +,""##$%(#$($ $ $#9$

# $0        "!$$     $  -12<    

""#$ %# "&++ %&  ( = "

( "$

0$0$0

 "&+9 (%  (#(> $$;

    $ (+   74%#
 +,""##$%(#$($ $ $#9$ #$0  $$ 
*?

-56'+ $!$9 "!$$ 


 +,  -*

,( 9  (  %& (%

 (#"&+:($ ( 
 +,  -* > $$$;

    $ (+   74%#
 +,""##$%(#$($ $ $#9$

# $0 9#$%#  ( , ( "&++ ( =" 9 #$%$#$&""#&  #   ($ $0 @+  A'
>/ 3$ #&  $ ""#+&%$   " '$ $+9 $

 $!$ +%&=$0  + !$(  0 $  $0 %0  '0$ + $ 0 9 "# 
 $# $( $ + + &$:($ -

*  #$0
 + 

9 $

9 "  (  1?

 ?5

58($0 #! "$ "" $ #

(  $! 
 
 "$

0"8) $ $   (# $"

+!$(0!+0 $9 9
 
 

 $0  $0

$  "&+9 ! ( ) -12 ( $"&+  (  %$ 
555?16'

"$,"&+ 
5-55?16'9+  "$!#! $ 9= $ (%&  $0 

$  $   "&++ %&  ( ="

?

(%  (#"&+  ("!$$ )  9 # %""#$ %#
9"#  %  $0

$   ## ( ="9 + 9( =   , 9  ( $%#;$ 0   "!$(% $? ) $

$9"#  %  $0

$  9#$0$%# %$$0   (#  $#@+

A'B%  2++$$ 
 +, %$$0 A'
@+

+ ( =" 9#$0$%# %$$0#& $    (  ,$ (# ""#& +9$ $+

  ( $ ," $% (  ? 9$ (#

1 ?      
 +  ,  (#  -*      $ $0     "#& (%+$ %&  $0

$   #(    9:($   ( ,( " "!$$  -12 (%  (#"&++  ( ="9 $

$

$#     $(%  (#"&+$,  

6'9 $

9= (
   9 $##9 $!$9 "!$$ 

 ( $$ 
*?

-56'

9+  $ + +9 +"# (   1?

? !$    

,(  $ + 
   $$ 
    9+ %& $0

$ ( 

%& $##9$0 "&++  ( ="$,  
A

6'$0  "&+(%  (#"&+9 $

,9  (   (   %&         :($  (   ) $  -12         00$!  %&             $#    ""#  %    2++$$ 
 +, ""#C2
 D9 !$   

A

-,(

##9  ""# # $0 "!$$

 9""#$ %# "&++ %&        ( =  "    #     $##9    
  + ( 

 8$$ $ 9$  " %& 2
  !( $# ""#%  $%(# <$     1 

,(


 $%(# $+$  ""#   $+   " %& 2
 7  $ ""#%& !( ? ; !  #  (# ""##'!(  "" % # "  1
$ $"( %&#  (# ""##'!(  $( # &%  $  0$ !(%& $2($


 

     

         !$    5

9 $$9    ('



 

   ! "



 !#!!!!" 

# 

!#    $!%!

 $ 

!& ! 
 

  

   '
 (

)*+
, !!

, -   

+ !   , 

#!,

  !

&'
(

.

""! !!

!# 

, 

!,#  !%!"  !"!



,"   $ ,

! !

##$ " #

,/0!  ""!$!!

    ! 

&'
(  

 .

 )  

!#    !  '('!(  

  .  ,  

""!$    !%

    $ 

  &)*'.(   

 *!$  

+"! 

 #!, $ /$ 

1!% & 

1!# 2 !!

 


3 $
 ! )*.""4

 
&)* .#$567 % 8%*" & 3"

9! 

'
 (

6*+'12(

%! , ! 92,!#!$ 

 1:$9"#&  

; 
 $!%92 '&!!


 &&
  
 &)* .#$56 8% *" &" !9!

<

 )!,

$$  !0 ! , ! 

* ""!!#! < 

)!,

$

$  !0 ! , ,%!



"" !#!