Amrik Lal Chawla v. State Of Punjab & ANR
!"#" $ % && '(") * + , -+
&&
"
" $ ( .
(#/#
/$1
$3
, (#
&&& #4 $3 $ # 5% 6* 5& 0 0 5
0
!
!
"#$%& '''
! ) *+ ,- *,.* /0 123
*
.- ., .+;"
!
# 5
5 ) ! ! !
0 1;
.; ., .+;"
5
/ 7893
6 &
8 6 ,: ., .+;"
5 6
5
6 &
8 ". ,= *,,-
.- ., .+;" # 4 !
7! " .;
!
7!
! 6
4
#
6 *+ ,- *,."
/0 123
6
!!
5 5!4
#6
!4 4 ! 5!!
6
! 4 5 6 5 !
/ 7893 5
0
4
0 1= 1., 5
!!4 6!4
! !
!
!!
! !5
6
!!4 ! 8 6 &
.+;"
) 6 &
!4 ) 6
!
6
!
"#$%&
5
!
5
64/ 7893
& !
4 !!4 6
5 !
0
6
5 6
7!
6
(
# >& 5
6 7! : :
/
!
7! && 1& 7! " .;
!
7! #*
!
7 9
( 80 8 !
?! !!
!
?!
6
8
! && 5 4 0 !
&6 @ !
7 6 A 8
# >& 5 =*2"#/.3 97# 2;1*2,,= .:#.*#2;
6 7! : :
/
!
7! & 7! " .;
!
7! 1& #*
7 6 A 8 ..#.,#22 .*# ,-#;*
!
7 8 9 !!
!
?!
6
A 8 5 4 0 !
&6 @ !4
6!6
6
5 ) !
4 ,: ,; .++2 0 1., 5 (
4
!
6 !
0 4
0 1..
5 !!
! #
5 789
!4
5!!
& !4
6 5
0 !!4 5 6
4 !
!
%
6
0 !!4 6!4 !
!!4
4
!!!
6 9
6
5
!
6 6 0
7! &
6 6
% .;1*1=,#&9#&&&1+:=- .: 4 .+=2
#
!"
#$
%&'() *%+(,-%.*&*'&*%/) 0
11#'%(23 '4%.&5'+&2) '-,2&.%.)#,-* 6.&36+7%8%+(#%./%+%) 55,22,+'.23 ,9,2,+2)
,2&.,:&%+(!'22,+6(-'2;%+(
'46&/ 55,22,+'.2,+&*'!&%&'
7 !687':&< 6+&,+- 3 2'.9,:' 3. 46.42' 3 4'+2,+ 3 &*' '541/''23&*'!&%&'9'.+5'+&%+(!&%&' 6&+562 (,'2 2''=,+- %82.4&,+ ,+ '+&.%1 6&+562 (,'2 %+( '+&.%1 9'.+5'+& '+&.%1 6&+562 (,'2 .'24':&,9'1/ %+( 9,:'
9'.2% !,.%(%5)
%5(,.':&'(&.'3'.&&*'2687':&:,&'(%89'%+(&2&%&' &*%& &*' 9'.+5'+& 3 6+7%8 *%2 8''+ :+2,('.,+- ,+ :+261&%&,+>,&*&*'9'.+5'+&3 +(,%)&*'?6'2&,+3:6+&,+- 32'.9,:').'+('.'(8/&*'!&%&'9'.+5'+&'541/''26+('.&*' !&%&' 9'.+5'+& 8'3.' &*',. %82.4&,+ ,+ &*' '+&.%1
6&+562 (,'2%+(&*'2'.9,:'.'+('.'(8/&*''541/''23 &*'!&%&' 6&+562 (,'26+('.&*'!&%&' 6&+562 (,'2 8'3.' &*',. %82.4&,+ ,+ &*' '+&.%1 9'.+5'+& '+&.%1
6&+562 (,'2)3.4'+2,+%./8'+'3,&2%+(9,:'
9'.2%*'
5%&&'.*%28''+:+2,('.'(:%.'3611/%+(&*'9'.+.36+7%8 ,2 41'%2'( & (':,(' &*%& &*' :%2'2 3 !&%&' 9'.+5'+& '541/''2-,+-9'.& '+&.%1 6&+562 (,'2%+(&*%&3 &*''541/''23&*'!&%&' 6&+562 (,'259,+-& '+&.%1 9'.+5'+& '+&.%1 6&+562 (,'2 . 9,:'
9'.2% 5%/ 8'
.'-61%&'(%2311>2<
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
!
5! 5 6
6!4
!
6 (
8
&
5
! 6
0
4 6 ! $%&
6
6 !
66 !4 !
6
6 !
(
6!4 6
6 ! 6!4
!
6
6
!
6 !
54
5 5
C
5
!!5 !
.- ., .+;"
!
0
#
"#$%&
5 6 6
!
5 4
4
9 !
5
!
4 5 6
6
/ 7893 4 5
6 6
6 6
C
5
!
(
7#
6 5 6 4 46
64
9
4 *,,-
!
*,.:
0 6!4 ,+ 4 0! 6 54
!
4 (
! 6
!
,. ,: *,.:
!!5
6 (!, :
;0 5
0 <