← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4006/2015allowed

Mehar Kaur And ORS. v. State Of Punjab And ORS.

2017-07-31Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan13 pages

    

    

 !"#$% & '()!(  '( ***

+(

, !

-.  '( ***/



   !!"#$!   !!!$ ( (

("/(%23   ('0

( "0,

1',!4('4 %25%!

-.

( /!0

()'

"%,( 23 6 ' 

'('!"4%23  (( 

% 

!!$ 9'

0

' .  "0(#

1 ( (

 :! '' (( ;



 '< (.#6'

''"" 

 

0"   '0

 "" '= !

 /

;$$>*0

.#5

,

1'"'!

.  0

(  '( 0

   6

 (   9'0

'3"

'"" 1' (( 

$  %  6'(.#%  ' (  00"     (3

 0

 ( 0 3"#%   6(

=

5

1'%00"

 ' ( (%@(. 3" 0= !

-.

?&   (  0!('     (

"  0"   = !(

1  

 #(

 9' 00"



 =0

.#( = # /

 >*.

1> ' '

  "0(  '0" 

/



>*  

?&;%'6

 (=.#' < (%@(. <  %!

-.''0(  " 

' 7 ' 77 '.  A/

>*0( #( 6 (:!  (= '."  = !

 /

$%& >*'( !1'. 4(.#&

?&;

9'( !1''

"(%

0

"

1 3  00"# ( =""(

B0" % '(  ' (

"= .

%(1(

16'

'

=

 .1 3 6

#  '

!  '"( 5

1'A(

1' 0

00"

 &

?&; ("" =  0" = !(

1

' *77%@(. < % "  C"

(=  = !

 /

% >*'( !1'= (&

?&;.

' "0(  0" = !(

1

9' = !

0.# '(

 2"" = "(

?&?6

!  '

= (0"   &&*%' *7%@(. < % "= !(

1

C 63(% 0" "" 6

' *7% 1

'(:!  ("" =

' *77%5

,

1' == "#'(( 

?&?(:! '(  "" 

"( 0" 

' *77 9'((%0"  *' 77= !(

1

 ( (0" 6 "" 3 "" = "(

?;

C 6

 (=' '0" 6 0(( " % 

"0( '(  D ' (

"0( 6 !".'(1 9' "0(  '0" 6

/

&>*  E(%  '  (

 (=  '

=  '( !1'  ' (  "(  

?;

%'0" 

*

' *77= !(

1

.

"" 

0" 0"  *%' *77%0(  /

;$$>* F! '

0" 6 '

1'"#!

3 '= #00 % 

?;

5

1'

(:! '"" =  '

0" . ""  '(0" 

' 77. "" 

 ' 3( "( (0(=

( (:!

1 ('

$ "(  30" "

  (

%5

1'   ""(

?; '( (:!

1 ((  (

 0" 

*%' * 77%6'

''"(#. ""  '

= 

 (  (

1'0" 

' *77%5

1'( 3 "(

?;( ='(

=

1''0 "

#(1(

" (

"



@(. <  '. (3

9'0"  6( 

 6 1( !0 .  (

B "   

%



6(

5( !077 "   

B .6   

#( 6(0"

5( !0*7 9'"

.

"

# ("" =  0" 

5( !077 6  .(=

 '.

 

 =( ( " 

5( !0*776( ."" ( (30(  A.#'5 3( =  0" 

5( !0*76( .

 

 0 !

9' "00"

 6 !"'3' 0

 00"#  ('"" =  0"   '"

."1 (# '.

 '

 = ( ( 9' 0

 .A(

6

$ #

1'(  '

6""  "( &

?; (:!

1'

 '

("

((:!  ((  (

 0" 

G@(.

< ' 77%6'

'6 0

1%6 0' '."" 

#( 0" 

' *77@(. <  "  9' !1'%'

! =4 (0(:! (0( 

%'(6 (

( ='(

76 "# 

?;;''6

 (='' !" .1 3

 '0"  ("

(""  '

= ''(-'

"" =

=6 

(

'(6 "  '" ;

?;

%.!(=

!

!"

C

00"



 ("" =  

"#

10

1

'   '= !

 /

;$$>*6 "#

10

%6'

'' !"

 '(6( =0"

1' (="

C3

1'!

. 

'"" = %5

1' " "  (=  (#

-!



6 ''0(#(  (='"" =  "

3(

 " 

= !(

1

!

' *77%@(. < %  " ( # '( ."0"  ' =

B '.

 '

00"





&  !(

1'0 # ' " % ("

((0( 

3 .#5

1'6  .#'2=

( (%!

-.@(. "

3" 0= 2!' ( # " 7 '

 ((;

'!0'" '  " =     5  ,

1'   (  "" =       0"     

 #(

 9' 2=

( (4 6"1'

-!

'.   5

1'

C6

'" . " ("" =  0" = !(

1

2 0" 

* %' 77@(. < % "%("

(""  '

=%'= 6'

".

""   ='

(0(

 =0( 0(  "'"" = % '2=

( ( ('

#(0" .""  '

=.#' "

1 (6( =""'

#(0"  "#

13

' *77 9'00"

  .

 

'0( 

 (6 " 

9'6 ""

 5

1' '(6' " . ('!"(6 " 6 ( ( 9' 0( 3 0( ' ((

(0( !." 6*   

   

 

 

              

  

 ! " #    

  

$

  %

$ #       &     #   &    

 

       & '# 

    

 # ( 

    $ &          $  &

 

  #  )   #   

   # 

&  * +  &,  *

    $    !       #     # $&&

#          #     

   &    &# 

  )    #   

  

   

 

           #     &  

 #        

                    $

         $&     

- &  #     &* +  &,     $    !./  $   $     

  &

- & 

.

 !./ !   #    -              &       

 -  &   #    #

 (   0

- & &

$  

! "   

&    

& #         #  # 

    &              

&        # 

&

       

 #  (    $  # #  #   1  2    #

1'  

9' ",!

6 '(6 .#'

 "1"' ( '0

  ??& C 63(% (6 "  '".# '(

2('' 5

1'%'0

 ( (  1'

 '2=

( ( =0"=   & ???%'#  (0( 

%(:!

1''(6 "  .'"'("

% ''# =#."" '0"    

%'( 6( .4

1 ( (

 !=  ="#''(   5

1'%(  . !'0

.

1'

"1"' (  76 "

='' "" = 6 !".='0(3 "

1( /

& ;>*0( :!(#( 9'  (="

6((:!

( . =0"6

$ #

7

'  ' 0

 '  '   !=  6(  !00"

    &

  9'  0

'( !1'' ("(?

(:! ' '!""= !

 '0"  '"(#. 0

.#5

1'!(

1'

"

 =%'0" .""   '=1

'= !

 ''

 '(1'!(( (. (3 6 9'( '( !1'' ("(?

%( (''

#(0" 6 !"."" H/

$ >*0( 76

 (=' ' "0(  '0" 6 !"./

% %

>*% D6'( 6 /

%

>*

2(  !

1  '  = !

     /

%;$$>*  0

  .#  5  ,

1'%  ' 0

6((:!

( 0

'(=

1= !

 /

% &>*6

$ #

9'( # '("(



 (=

1' 

'. 4 ''

#(0"  !"."" H/

& 0(  ('( !

%6'

'3(%

'

1'(  9'0

6( 3 #  = 0

 D '= !

'( /

$ >*0(

#( % "

16'

' 6 !".0( !=''0

   0

'= !

2 '0

 " 0

'

= !

6

& 0(  0 %'< (%@2% "3 '

 ((;



 ""'"" 

 '0"  

 '0

9'= !

  /

;$$>*0

.#5

1'6  (( . (  9'0

 " $;;

 

=0!1

1' ( (( 9'

 6(  6  

 3  (( 

 ("1

1' 0

( '(=# 00"

76  (' '00"

 "6

 !(64 ( =' ( 0 (  0# ' ((%'" =6 !" .

( =(  

=

 '1( !

 "

= 

7

'  '0

''#6(

 (= ' 

 ' !(.#' ( !

".!1  4 6 '

( ='   < ( 

 9' =#'#00"

 ( (  0#6'

'"

( 3'3(##% 

'((%'# "' 00"!>  '!

-./1

" 9 6 "

1 3" 0= 2% ??  ( ' ( I??  2J  . ( ' 2

" '

 2=

( ( @2 9'00"6 

=

 ;

$ '1( !

 "

= 

 (

'3

1.  "6

' !(64 0(  0 

' (( ' 1' !( 9'0

0((((3

0

!

(,

; ' ??2%6'

'6 

=

3  (( ' "

1'' 0

6(

( 

40

1'0"  '#  0

' ." = !

6'

''#6( 4 0

 C %'0( 6( 0

E  !

" ('0

  ''

"00"



 ( '0" 6 =.#5

1' 

?&  0#=  !""0( %0" 

;  *%' 77%@(. <  "= !(

1

""   '

=%6'

'' 63(%6 ' 1 0" 

*%' 77%@(. <   "6'

'6  ' =

B  2 '

0" 6 !"" 00 % ' (:! ' '(0" .1 3

% 6'

'(:! ' !.

:! "# '(6 7

(1!'!(

1'

"

 = 5

1' "

1 "# 0!( !'  '"" = 6 ''!' ( %  ('

'' 0

'3. 0!(

1'=(%.!6 ' ! !

 E  !

"

(1!''(6 -!



( K 

 '(1'!(( "" = 0( ( ='0

6' 5

1''"(#. ""  0"   

*  '   77       ?;  '  '  6 '(6  '

 (:!    ( "" =  "(  30"  C(1!'%

# %'2=

( (

'

((;

'!0'"'" = ("" =  

0"   ('' !=.( '0"  ."" . .#(6 " 

( == 1'3 0" 

76 '

!(  '"" = '5

,

1'  (    6 '(6  '    6'

'  6  6 '(6   ??&

/1(

1'"#

 "

1'00"1

' (( '< (% 6 (1!''0

6(

 (= ' (( 'C 1' !( .#' ( !

"

E  !

" ('0

" "# ''0

6 !"  .  6 ""

1    4  '  0"     '  (  0  

 '  "(    ' ( ?

2

A!(* 

%/

$ >*0( #( ( '!((  "" (K (6'

'3(

'

1'(  E  !

" ('( ' '(' (1!'5

,

1''. "" 0" '(  3(.!' ='6  "(  3 0"  C!('((1!''C 1' !(6'

"

1  $;;

 

?

3  ((

'1 3 "

.(# '0

(  "

00"  6

  !(  64    ( 0    (    0#   ' ((%  .!  ' 0

 "'00"("#  3#(

 9'!

%'00" (3

6(( 1'"#

=

C(E  !

" ('0( 0(!

'( ( 9' 

"

  3( !( '""

16   (!11" = "# 1 =""0"  

*

3" 0

1@(. <  

(

1  6 0" 

@(. < % "%5

1'00"



?&   C0

  = !

 /

% >* &

?&;%6'

'

 1'(6 ''( = # /

% >*0

6 ''00"



%6

' " "

(

 ( :!(#( 0"   C6 "" 0"   &&*

' 77%@(. < % " 

?&?

  '

(:!  ( ' 1 '0" %'6 "" 0"  *' 77%@(. < % "



?;

6'

'"" = !

"(""#' 1.#'(  " 

' 77% "

?;

2 '

3(#!

3 0" %

1' 

?;

(:! ''.""  "(  30" 

='  C 63(%'3

11  0

3(

 '

(:! %'%

?;%(:! '"" =  0" 

*' 77.(  ( 

.

1

 (=. !'' 1

0 "

# "" = %5

1' &

?; (:! %' 0" 

' 77%@(. <  "

.(  (% ' '.1 3 

#(0"  2 '(0" 

*6 (  ( (

#(0" 6 "" %' " "  6'

"%'(0( 

5

1'6  .#'2=

( ( ;

%6'  0

'

-!

'.   '

= 9'2=

( ( ''< (

 '( 3'!""0#=  '0" ( =5

1'=!'("

(%.!'  " '  3('0

  #0"   9'2=

( ( 6

!(0(

'5

1'6 4 4(!

 '= !

6'

''' 0



(

  ( "( 6(  .#'< (

C6

'" " ("" =  0" = !(

1

9'2=

( ( ('

#(0" .""  '

=.#' "

1(6( =""'

:!(#(0"  "#

13

' *77 9' =  5

1' '(6' " . ('!"(6 "  ( (  6'

"%

1'    2('

'%'0

.

1'

"1"

' ( 6 '(6' 

??&

L( ='3  ""'

1%

"('( 1' '

1' (  (

 0" 

*%' 77%@(. < % "("

""     '

=  6  ( 1

B   7  6 "#  .!

  0"   

*  '% = 6'

"%. ""   = '(0(

%'6 '3 6 3 "

1

%

 ('

#(0" .""  '

=( == 1'3 0"  .#(6 " 

76 '!# '(  '3 =0"= '

(( "" 

#(0"  '0

 == "#'((

 

1 %6 "0  (0(%'

:!  6'( %

. 0(=  .3

!0 '0

9'!

%

 !(3 6'(6

6((  ('(  '3"(

!0 =4

1'"" =  '0(3 "

1(  9'(1!=  'E  !

" ('( ''#6(

 

 (=  . !  '  6 '(6"    '     ""  '  0

!.=  (0( 

& ???"

1 "#

' ( "" = %=#

 "

-!

#'=  (0#= '(0(3" ' =  "" = C 63(%6  1 

 '

:!

% "

':!

 ' "1"3"

#   (=   !

(4

1 6 '(6' % 'E

 !

" ('0

' ''0

(6 !".6 ""

1 0# '." = !

 = 

'"(?

2

A!(* 

%H/

$ >*0(  ('!((  "" (K ( 9'  (1!=     '  E   !

"   (  '  (  '  ' 0

'3

1 "'00". ! 3#( ('

 'C 1'

 !( 

%

 6

' !(640(  0(= .#' ((%'#' ( ' (( 1' '"" 1' (( '< ( ;



%6'

'''(.#



"

#% ( %00(



F!

3 6 ' "

# '  (!=    '

 %6( 0( ! 1(6 ''

= /'(%6(

"

 0'0

K ''#6(

 (=.#' (23  ' ((  'C 1' !( 6'

'( !"

( "

1'00"( 3#(

9'!

(% ( K  !'"#'=(

(

"#"3

15

1' (!

( =0 ""( 0 9'0

0( !' (( 1' !"#  "

1 "#  '0

 A'!

9'(

 '((

 (' (  "

1'00"

 = 9'(

1 

''0

"

(  (. ' (( 1'

( 0 '0"  7.( (0

'' (( 1'  "=  '0"     (=.#' (( '2=

( (;

7

"#.!

' (( '2=

( (6 =0"=  = 6'

"5

1'

  %'' (11  ( !=.( #( ! "4 

 1(= '0(  .0 %'0

1''!"""" = 0( '3

1"(#. 0 '#6( (:!

( 0# #

"

= !

%'( % ' '(' %

1 =4

1'"" =  '!(( 0(3 "

1( 3('1 .#.6 '' 5

,

1'  'C 1' !( ((

F ('%5

,

1''. 0!(

1 ("" =  



?&  9'

"

10( 

!1' A'!

 

'( 3 '=  11    (= ("0

!(

1'

"

10( % ' !" .0(=  3

'0

6 ' !'

"

:!   0(

1'='(!

  3( !( '"    ( '



' 1 '0

. ( " =  7

6"" "'

A(

  -!(



!

(2( "   '

!

%'C 1' !(=#%(4

1 1

B  ""'  (!=         %   0

 00( 0(   ((    

!(   =0"  

!.

 "-!

 '0(

  .

(3

  

 (   *2  4  '

2  

2    

& -     & !  $#   

 



    

J 94

1

 

(

' "

# '  (!=   % 6( '3 6''

0

 (3  . 

"" 6 9' =0!1 ((    ;



  2

A!(  *%  ;

$  2

A!(  *     2

A!(* (:! '

$ 9' ( (  (    ""    

 #(  0"    ' 0

'0( 



'"(?

2

A!(*  ( '!((  "" ((6'

'3(

'

1'( %!"#& %!!&  !  '()* $

+

5 )

6  7 86 59 7 86