← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22613/2018dismissed

Rameshwar Das Bishnoi And ORS. v. Bar Council Of Punjab And Haryana And ANR.

2018-09-28Mr. Justice Amit Rawal18 pages

 



        

 

    



          

      

 



!

  

         

       

     



 "# !$

% &%$ 

& 



'

(

&$ 

& 

 %

&%$ 

& 

 ( '

 %'

&$ 

&  !  

&$ 

&   )* 

  +&$ 

&   ), 

+ (

&$ 

&   )- )  ). $ /

+ &$ 

&   )0



 "# + / &$ 

& 

 %

&%$ 

& 

 ( '

 %'

&$ 

& 

   

 !"#$

%

&%

 1   

      '  

 '$()*+(,-)./.*0 (")1(2)32 3

* 4 

    '

425)  -2 ( 2)  -) ./  .*0(")1(2)32 3

, 4

   

               

  

 5 % -6*767

$ 

$ &*89*2  3

$ :4   

 

     

      



    

  1 





     2    3

 :4  



 



          %  ; 

 $   1      

      -*0,<*-  *9,<*9

 

   

 '

=



%

     >1 &

'

*?,<*-&8?,<*-

,<?,<*-  1 &

* & 



    

   1  

     5 ;?,<*;  *-0,<*; '   ' 

        )*.6 7  6'7 '

'

 3   @ : 

 A    

 *.6 7

    

   .6*7

 A  +'  



 



 

 '

=

 

  



'    )*.67& 



  



    )- 



  

 

 



 

 

 

  

     6 

7  ,<*0 2   3

  ,<*0:4 A       )*.67

  +' 5      

5 '

 

 A &  % ;

$ &

+ A  

B B%%  

 

 

 



51  A ' 5 



   



*?9,<*; 5 



  

 * , ) & ,<*; 1       '    ' 

*?,<*; 

 ?&8 *<   "# 4    !!" #   $    #  %&     

 '    (  # ) *+,-    . "/  

!!   0     

      

4   !!" 1  #   $ /    #  $  (    

4    !!  !  !  "  ( 

 #

)  

)

( 

#



 

6               !

   '   *?,<*;&  & 

   

 '  

"# /.    !!"  #  $  # %&   

 '    (  # )*+,-

   . "/   !!   0     

           

 !   2  "   0   3   

  ) 10  

!!

  4"4#  $ /%&  

  ( # )*+,-)

2

 (    3  

 

! "  

    4"4#   $ )            !  "     )



   0 

 !

) ! ( #    2 ) 

)   (  # /# 

7

/. 



!!"  1  #   $ /    #  $  (       

 !   2  "   0  5

  "

  . !! 1 #  $ /"    A

C  ' ,0;,<*;&

  *?,<*; -*?,<*; B

   "# /.      "

  !  "   

   *678*-  %*678*-)  !       

 

 ) 

 !    1          !        " *678*-  "0    ""

   "  9      9  9  :

0  

   "

    ! "  *678*-

 !    ;     "  %*678*- 

 "   6 



7

 

   

 

5

8-&<<<  



 



  

   

   

 0.&<<<  

 &

  '

 

 

  

  



+

A 

 

    &  & '       

 %%

   





 



    1 





   

  '   

 

      

   

 

        D' 

 '

      

''

'



     ).

%

## ' E '  

'     1



  

 $

' E 6$ E7  

 

@ 1       



   

     

 A 1 

 

 

    F )*;?9?  ,<*;   ' 



 F )*8.;<  ,<*;  

            

'  

 









 

  A 

  '





 



@ 1 A    







 ?;,<*;&

  

    

 

 *-;,<*;

 @  1 &   A 

  



  

      &

     A





:D ) %'

&D'

D 

 /   '

   E    

    1 

5  



*8;,<*;  "# (   

   2    !  " "!



  !      

    9  9  :

0) "!

 5 0 

  

 

! !  ! !

  #  $   !!  ""

        

    9 9 :

0        

    !

   !   9 3 )#  $   

  ! !

  !  "  

 

)      0

          



 

 

 !

           9  3      #$ 

  "  1#$/              ( 

       "!  

!! #$ 1#$/



  

      0   "

 

  #$  1#$/  

 9"

            0

  "!

      ! !   !

   )"

    < 

 5

 $  0   0     $    

  

 *8;,<*;   

@  1 

 

 '

 

  

'



    ' E  $

' E  

     A        

 

 *8;,<*;

 

     A      



'

  

  &    ), G -

 

 

 A 

   )-&



' 



 -6 7

     @  &*89;6 72 3

*89;:4&

3 

:   

  

    

 

      '   



'      



 



  A   



  

 B

 

 

    

   

 

'      

 

 

 '



 

,-9,<*;

 



 (       '   *?,<*;  

 



 

  

 

     '' 



  '

 



 



 

     )*G,  '

 A 

  )*  

 

  

E 

 A 

 



 

  

    E 

   

'  A   

 



  

 

E 

'   

  

        F 



   

E 

@ 1 

 



  +

E 

 1   

  

 ' 



     

E ,0;,<*;

 

-*;,<*;

 '

     



   

    A   

 

&



 

 

  ,<*-&

' C '



     A  '







 

' A 



  )*



     

 

  

'

 #

 

 

 ''

   '

 

  

     

  

 

    

  & '  

   &  



'  

 

 H 

 



  '  '





    

 

+ 

+'

 ' "#            

   7&8678*&

0     "   0    "  0

0 !*88-78*& 

"  "0    "     ; ! %*8-78*& 0

   *88-78*&   

         

    "    **778*&  1  ;

 0

    *6778*,     0   "!%*%78*, 0 1" 3

      78%78*,   "      !

   

   

  1       

)       

     "!

       #  78*&       

  76778*, 0  "    2  (0)     *8%78*,  2 "

    

     "!

   !    0    " ;!78,78*, 0 $ 7*678*6

   ""      "!

"       # 78*&   



 1       

)  

    

 < 

0   "   0    "  

 0 1     

  /    7--78*6  "*&  0   " 0    "  "     0

        

       #  =       2  !

    !

!   "  > 





     *+&78*-  

 "!   4   !

   "!

    0     

!

 " 4"!

      !    " 

0    4!



0 5      =

 !

   

.      

)       

    " "!   4 "

0

)     !!    

  0

0 



0 "

  9 "   <  0   "

 "!*&,78*-2"

  !   "      !   !  )

 !! ) "    ;       ! ! ! 7&,78*-   "

   



 0   9  0

0   78,78*- 



0)     "    " 

  !!  0 

 

  "  0    "    



    H 

 





  3'

 : 3'

 : 

 '

& 

  

 ,<*0 3'

 : *89;'

 3'

 :

 *-

*89;&   "# ./ 89)/4)1 /)/ // 1 !  "   

 

     " 

0    "  <              2 

!           *78    ;!  " ""

          0  !    

 1       1!"!

!  "  



 

  "

 

           

    !  "   

 

  )     

   0  "

   

 

6    ! !

           "            "   1    

  !!

   

)

    "   !



   !  "   

 

    " !  !  "  

 

         !    )       0   "      (0  

!!

 

   !!

   

 

     "  

0 ) 

"

 )  0)   " 0 !



 !

    0     !

     "  !    !

)       ) ") "0

        <     !!

  

 !





    "

)       )

   "

 " 10       "    !     

 

7     "       

!!

     89:/ /)/ //

 

  

 

 

 ! !



  !   "

   )        "  10   

    ! !

     "  ( 

#

 ! !       

    "    6&    )

   ,8    )       2"

   !

  

 0   

 !

  1 

       

 ( 

#

   

 

 

)

 ) ")   "

 ;! 

   "

       0   "0

 "

0    ")      !   "    0   !  " !

 

      

   

 

     ' 

 



  

  &



 '   

   $ '



   

' E $

'E& 





    

 

 '

  



  

 

' 

    &

' E %  %  %'

&      '  

 

    

'

 '



$ E5



 ' 



'  A

    

  





 

  

  



&   +'   

  &     '      

   

 



 &

&  5 



 

 

 E $ E



 

 

+    



  

 ' *-0,<*;  )*.6 7

6'7 

'

'

3 @ :  *.6 7    

 ' 

    

        

  .6*7

  A 

 '

 

 

    

 

 





'   

 

& '

=

  

  

 

'

 

  %   *.67'

'



 

 

  ,<*0  1  

   

 

 



6  )-7



    '    & '



 '

 



 ' '  

+ 

   &  

 )8     & 67 6 76    7  

  

 1  

  

$ 

 

&&  +  ' 

  +

 

   

 '



 

  A  '&

'  





   

 



 

 * 7&

&

   3C  +:  

        &      

   





 

     A     @ 

      

  

    

 '

  '

  

  

  

 @  1  1    A

 *8;,<*;&

+' 





 

B 



&

  E 1  

*8;,<*;

 

'



  +  



   

E  

  

  

E  =

 



    & A  

   & + '   

   

&



' 



 

  

    A 

    E  $ E  &       

     





    



  

       

 

    

  '    



 



 

 

        1 ' 



 '

   

  $

    & 

 

    

 * 

      A 

, &

 

 

   $

& %  '' '





 

 

  B    

   

    '   

 



+



+

 

*  

 

 $5 #*  ' 

 

    

 

 

   $  ''

'

 , 

  &    $5 #*& A  

 

   ' 

  B  &

,   

'   $

  

  

        

         ? !

 /   @ :/A ? #! 

  @ :/A