High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2262/2018allowed

Amit Kumar Chakraborty v. Haryana Power Generation Corporation Ltd And ORS

2024-02-01Mr. Justice Namit Kumar17 pages

" # " $ % ' (& ) # *+ *

& ) (,- $ *+ *

& + . "/

!" 01 $ & 0 23 4* 1 $

5 1 & 1 0 6 3 7 8.

9 6

7 8.

:9 $ !" 0

+ 1 + + & 0&"*! /+! / 1 &

- *+!&0$ & * & $ $ 1 $ )2 ; +" ' 8;'9* &* < 0 01 0 ,5444 !

!1 0&& $0 ",<0 "-

6::

= 44*+&& 0

4 & & 1 " > 4;24;4

-10 0 1 $ 0 0 $ 1 00 0

*- !"7"

.& !

/ 1 & & &" !

2&"0 (

<-7 6

0 1 $ 00 $ &&0!0

/ = 44 6

; $ &0 !

- * ,<-* 0* $ ! 1 + + &1+$& ?& + .& $$ 0"&& +!"- (0+&

::8.

! "

# $ %

& '& ( ) & *(& &(+ ,-

))

" "./0 1 " -0 " " 2

31 4

&&!& 5&6&(+ - "7

/ 7 "

/0 " 31 -" " "

22 /

/0 "

" 2-

/0 "

20& /0

" $2 79 3 " !! '&

8:4:4%*++

& *6&5&(

,- )) " 7

20 " !!2 4

. - & *;++ 3&&

7 " !22 7 2- 2 /0 "

: <0 = & ! /0 "

)<)&

&*5++

&>8:%

&*+++

! 20

& 8++

2 !

&?++:%

-2

&5+:% !

.7 /0

2 2 0

- 0

' "

- ;8 '&

7 " -

=7"

! " 7

"./0& " -

7 "

" ! " " 0 -!-2

" "2 22 -/2

22720 !

"2 0

0 & " $2 79 3

7 '& "

" - 7 " - /&

" 72

) ,- )) "

0 2 /0

- / /

20 - "

, 9 !

09 7 $ :

-/2

- .7&

" - "./0 # %

!-2!22 " ! "

- 7

'& "

" " ,7

" & -"

" - 7 7 7

"& -

"./0 "

0 2 # % &

;++%;+%

?++%8+%*5++%4%?+%*?++

7 "

0 /

" 2 &

;++:% "

0 2 " ,

-2 @ &

?++:% 3&&

3 9 !22

0 &

2 " - /! "

! " /

/0 " / &

" B-

" /20

*(& &(+ ,-%

" !22 7 !

-C%

" 7 '&

"& - "./09

# $ % .

" -

"7 / 7 "

/0 " 3 " 2

31 -"9

- "

1 -0

" 4 " )

2, 2-

) *(& &(+ "

22 /

: "

, $ :

-/2 - .7

"& "./0 !-2!22&D

6 5 0"* 0 :: 8.

69 $ !" 0, "* ,<-* 0* % 0)1 *0*;,*,<-*&*$ $ ! !" - 1 0 ::: ! && +

! 10" 5 0"* $

1 + + & &" 0 (

!" 1 &"

(

& $

/ 1 = 44 - + 0

4 4=4& <&

!! '& *+>:4:$%*55:E2& <C *%;%(*

2 "

7 "2 *(&

0 /0 " 2&

0 4 3".-2 " '& %

*?:'$4:$%?8:E2&

+& *&( "/0

! " 7 '&

- "./0 # $ %2 "

2 &

;++%;+% ?++%8+%*5++%4%?+%*?++ 7

0 !

;++:% &

?++:%

&&!& "

" 17 -0 # $ % " &

7:" 2 32 33

4 3 &

!!9

# $&&:32 33

3 &D

; *$& $

@ +! " " 1 1 + * $

39 $ & !" , A

+ " (* 6* 632

0+ 21 "2 . 0 " &

:: ;$ 0" &0!"& + &0"

9 $ 1 !" , A

<1 *%'*&* & * <1 +0 8.

:9& $ 10"1 + +0

:: $

5 ! !"

$ 5 && $

&&0!0 !" - $+ * + 0 8.

91* &0" & $00!"

, A

*$7" 01$ + "$00 !

@ +!

&0 0 8.

9!"1 0 " ! &0"

+ 1 ++ & 0&" & ;

* " !

0 "00 0B ; $ 00 $ !" $ & ! !" & 6 6 7 8.

6 9 $+ *$& * (* 6* 632 $

0 ! & 1 1 +

++ & 0&" & $& & !

- +0

78.

79 & $ 00

& 0 1 + 0

78.

<1 2;,* %'* &*

7 6 ; & 0" &&

& 0 1 ! &" ! !"1 1+ !" $0- & && +0 !" - 0 ! 0 0" &0 "* 0"* , ) ,1 , (@1!1 0 ! &1+$( 0 38!9 /!+0, +( 0*&&0!0

1 + 0 ! $ & & $&"$ .*

+ (* 6* 632 0!

+$0$0 $!" ?!0,

+ & + 5 @

: 7 7* $ $ 1+ & + 0

3 78.

390 1 + $

& * $+ *

+ 1 + + & 0&"00 &10 1$ $ 3 . & !" 1 + 1 + & 1 6 3 76

78.

:9+! /!" 0"1 &

, % + 3

* $ + ! &0

!" & * $ + + $ 1 &

::$

/ 1= 44 6

; +! 001!"& & $ & 7 !0 & !

0 $ ! + + ! & * $+ * $ 1 1 0 ! 0 0" &0 "! &0 -/ "

'79 #%E

!- !! &(;(:4:$%

*( *?& +& ((6 ! " ,

20 ,22

! - ;,

+F -/ 4B-

-,2 -7 "-27

-7

#/-0% 29

((>&

2209

"& "

7"9 #%

7 !!

& +8:4<%;+*:E2& E *;&+;& (68 ! "

- 7 F.

"7 #& "

"& "

7"9 #%

7-2@

&&!&

8&+ (6?

#% "

-/B-20 7 *

2 F<

&4&: &9

3$=9

3".-2

8;:3 :4: %A3

&*+++

- 7 ,

20 3$=& F"2

77 " " /

!!29

" " /!

- &&

" 2 -/B- /

0 /!& -"9 "

- -

" < ! .

2 ! 7 " ;

0 2 0

& -"9 "

0 !

! .7

2 <

;&+ &*+ +&D

' 0

& ! & $ 1 + + +

::8.

9 $ !" - && +0 - 10 :::* &" $

(

2 (

2 & $

/ 1 1 + * & $ $

39$$ 6 * !", A

*;,4*%'*&*$ " $ 1 &0"* (* 6* 632 $ 0 + 1 0 $

& * $+ * ++ + ! & 0 &" 0 !

/!" & +& 1 6 3 7 6

78.

:9!" 0"1 &

,% +

*$ !&&0!0

&+0"

! $ 1 & && +0!"- * <1 & $ $!

! & 1!

" 0" 1 + !

! ! + 0 0 0 ! !1 $ &0 "*0"*,) ,1, (@1

( 06*

* 3*7

/!+0, +( 0 && 0 !& 1 &!" & !1 & 1 "& 0!0 ! 3 3 *0 0

& ! & & $&0 "*0"*, ) ,1,(@1*& $ 1 ! + 0 .&0 " +

0 $ & $ ! + +

7 " .& ;+"'*$1& / 1

4 + 0 0

& &

: 4, !* & &

0 8.

9 $& $

!" !

/ 1 = 44 $00 ! &!"1 1 ++ &1+$ + .& )2 ; + '* &* $ $ $ 1< 00100 &1+$ 02&

0 5 0 10"* $ &0!

- && +01 !"* & $ + + +

::!" 1&"

(

2 (

2& $

/ 1 - ; $

5 ! & 0 &" $ 5 ! /

4 !/

! $ 0+

& &" $ 0 + ! & $ = 44 + " =

* 7 " .& & + &" $ $01 1

+ 0 + $ 0 0 !

/ 1

( 0 /! +0 , +( 0*# 0 4 8 &&0 "9&&0!0 %' &

-/1 0 72 2 "

/0 "

-"0 " /"2!9

-"0

0 7

- &

# $%

2 7

" - "-2 2 0 / -@

12-0 0 "

2 %2

0 7 /! -&

"-2 /

, 0

-2 1-!0

0 !, &

# $% " , G2

0G "

, -

" 2

/ . - !

-"0

" " " 7 &

#&$% " 7

" 32 2 2

7 /0 "

-2

, H " 3-1/ 2 -2&

#"$% " 7 9

--220 " " " $

20 "-2

/ 2 "

9 !

" "

" 2 " 0 -

" / 2 " 0 "

"-2 /

2 ,20 " !79 7

!-- 9 $

209

" "

&G ,0 !

& & !*$ / 0

$ 1 + 0 5 0 '')* $+ * $ C 0?

C&0? $0 1 & + ( 0 3* :

/!+0, +( 0 !" ," " * $ 0 + / 0

& 11 5 0 ! & "

0" !/ 1

$" $0 1 $ 0 + 1 5 11 5 0 ! + ! + 0 !0 1/ 1* $ &&0/ 1$ &0!"+ -

(' () '

& &&"*$ $0 *& "

% '&

" " / 7 /- "0

) 2) ) 2) & "

9 " " / 7

-/- " -2 7

!! " 2 & 7209 " 2

72 I- 7 ! !7 -

9 "

" 2- " " , ) ) "

/ "7/20 -

" ) 2

)& 7 " 2

72 I- 7 "

20 /1 -"

7 ,

/! " !!

" 1 " 1- 2

"7" B-2! "!9 "

) )

7 "

) 2)

2& " 2

I- 7 !-" "2 " - - "

/ "

" 7

7 "

/ - /0 "

22 /- -"

-2 2 2- -2

-2 /7

B-20 7 -%B-2&

5& F " " 2 -2 ! "

/2 27"

" "

, /0 " 2

72 I- 7 -%, /2

/ - 2 - "

72 I- 7 " 7"20 2- " "

) ) " / "7/20 - /0

) 2

)& 9 -2 B-2!

2 0 " / ! 7 "7"

0 29 " /

"2 /0 )/2 "

- - " ' # ) *+ !,- &"!. / 0

!-!&

. 123 !!& "!

$ !!& 22 . '4 5 /4 +

!!" !, $ !!" . 7899' 5 *99 *9 :2 7899'5

!!; - $ !!; &

&. 1 4 5 )8 3'

" ;-$

" &";. 8 *)9 8 7< =9 *9

" "& $

"" ,",

6 )2 > )

,& ,$

,!-

;& "

" 7 =

-2

20 /7 !!0 "77 - /0

I- 2 !!

7& " 2 /! 7

" - - "

% '&

/ B-2 "

" " 2 "7" B-2!&

/0 "

-2

" / /1 "

/0 "

& "!9

" "

. /0 " 2

72 I- 7 / - "2 &

8& B-2 " / -9 "

2 !2

" 720 &

I<$4

$<4E

0 5+9 *+

I<$4D ;

*+$ * ++ 1 & 5 ! & 0 &" =

* ! $ 1 && +0 $ !" - * ! ! $ $ !" <1 $000 & 0$+

+$ & !" & ( ! + -D 1

42989'

(' ()

) ) ) !!& &! 0 1* & (* 6* 632$ +

0 ! & $ & * $ ! &0" 1 <1 * $

! & +

3 7 8.

39 ; ! $ 1 & +

::8.

! ! $ $

& ! " +1 &00"$ &

$ !" & 6 =

* & && ! ! & 0 0"$0 ! $ 0 0" &0 "*0"*,) ,1 , ( @1 && +0 !" - ' 0

& 1 $ & !" 1 " $ 1 + .&0 " + - 2 0 $ & $1 !

+ 7 " .& & < 0010;+"'; " * & ! 1

!/ 1 + ! & $ 1+

!" !

/ 1 & = 44

$ 0 ! &

+ .& 7 " 1 !" 10"* & !00 $ ! " " &0 "$ $ 1+

$00! &

+.& 7" 1 &

* & / $1 ! ++ $+ * !1 & 0&" !0

/ "! *$ 0 " " 1 " + $ 3 " 0

1 ;

& 0 1& !1 + * $+ *! $ 0 !1

0 & & 0&"/ 1 +

0 $ 0

+ "&

& 1 + 4$ 1& .&

7" & + &"* *$$ !"- 10 ::: && +0*! $1

! + !1 &0&" 40 ! & && +0$ !" - 1 & && +0* + + $ 1 & $+ * 1 & * $ $ !" , A

+ " (* 6* 632 <1 $ 1*$ 1 & ! !1 & && +0!" - *

* 1

5 ! 7 4+$

1 1 0& &

0$*& & 00 $4& 1 6 3 7 6

78.

:9 !"5

& ++ 1

& +

::8.

9& 0&"

& 10" 1 5 0 ! +1&"& *$&

& &"

(, & 12 E2@ (& !0 E2@