High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24351/2017dismissed

Sant Kaur (Since Deceased) Through Lrs v. State Of Punjab And Others

2017-10-31Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath6 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

&"&"&"&"$")#*+ $")#*+ $")#*+ $")#*+ !'",!-*.&%'$#/#$#!&#/0"1*-213& #"%"%'#*& 4& "!"# -'5!)!'/"1#*& #&6'/#'"& 7( 7( 7( 7(8 37 ,,7 8 37 ,,7 8 37 ,,7 8 37 ,,7 *#&#'"( 7* ##6!922!*:!;+/<$!"#+

*"1#6#"%"%'#*& ,,7 + .30 ,,7 + .30 ,,7 + .30 ,,7 + .30 1# 6#"%"%'#*& 1!<# $1!;;#'2#/ "1# */#*& /!"#/

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

A -'/#* *"%$;# '&"%"-"%' '/%!:%"1!6*!=#*"1!""1#6*$##/%'2&%'%"%!"#/%'"#*?& "1# !66;%$!"%' %;#/ )= "1# *#&" #6!*"?#'" ?!= )# &"66#/ 1# &!%/

*#<%&%' 6#"%"%' :!& /%&6&#/ )= "1%& -*" )= ! /#"!%;#/ */#* ' CA

+:1%$1%&*#6*/-$#/!&-'/#*(

1# *#<%&%' 6#"%"%' $1!;;#'2#& "1# !$"%' %'%"%!"#/ !2!%'&" "1# 6#"%"%'#* * #<%$"%' -'/#* "1# -'5!) -);%$ *#?%&#& $"?!9%'2*# #*#'$#""1# !$""1#*#1!& )##' ! ;#!&# 2*!'"#/ )= "1# !'!;

#6!*"?#'"""1#6#"%"%'#*D&1-&)!'/ *! 6#*%/ '#=#!*%' A !'/!

"#* "1# $?6;#"%' "1# '# =#!*+ "1# 6&&#&&%' "1# 6#"%"%'#*D& 1-&)!'/ :%"1-" !-"1*%@!"%' $'&"%"-"%'2 $1!*!$"#* "1#6&&#&&%'!&-'!-"1*%@#/ !'/;%!);# *#5#$"?#'" 1# $-'&#; * "1# 6#"%"%'#* &"!"#& "1!" "1# /#6!*"?#'" "9 !$"%' -'/#* "1# &!?#$"'":$$!&%'&#!*;%#*!'/"1#= :#*# /%&?%&&#/ ' ! %'/%'2 "1!" "1# 6#"%"%'#*D& 1-&)!'/ :!&

-'/ %' 6&&#&&%'&%'$#

!'/1#'$#"1#!$"%'

* #5#$"?#'" :%;; '" ;%# 1# $-'&#; :-;/ &"!"# "1!" "1# #6!*"?#'" 1!/ $'$#!;#/ "1# !$" !%;-*# " )"!%' #5#$"?#'" %' "1# 6*#<%-& 6*$##/%'2& !'/

"1#*#:-;/)#!;&!)!* *#&5-/%$!"!)= %'&"%"-"%'2! *#&16#"%"%'

1#6*%'$%6;# *#&5-/%$!"!%&*"#/ '6-);%$6;%$="1!"!6!*"=:%;;'"<#E' "1# &!?# $!-&# !$"%'+ ! &-%" * 6*$##/%'2&+ % %" %& /#$%/#/ ' ?#*%" )#":##' "1# &!?# 6!*"%#& * "1# 6#*&'& $;!%?%'2 -'/#* "1#? !'/ %" 1!/ )#$?#

%'!; 1# $-*" "1!" !66;%#& "1# 6*%'$%6;# &1!;;#E#*$%&#$!-"%'"1!""1#*#1!/)##'! 6!*"%$-;!* !/5-/%$!"%' :1%$1 :-;/ )#$?# %'!; !'/ $!''" )# *#!2%"!"#/ "1#*# 1!/ )##' ! %'/%'2 "1!" "1# 6*6#*"= :!& '" ! -);%$ *#?%&# " :1%$1 6*<%&%' "1# $" :#*# !66;%$!);# * % "1#*#:!&! %'/%'2"1!""1#/# #'/!'":!& 1%?&#;

"1# :'#* * 1%& 6&&#&&%' 1!/ )#$?# !/<#*&#+ !' #5#$"?#'" !$"%' "*#!"%'2 "1# &!?# 6*6#*"= !& 6-);%$ 6*#?%&#&:-;/)#)!**#/'"1#*:*/&+ "1#)!* *#&5-/%$!"!:-;/6#*!"#!2!%'&" ! 6%'" *!%&#/ !'/ /#$%/#/ * ! /# #'/!'" :1%$1-21""1!<#)##'*!%&#/!'/ !%;#/ " / " $!''" #E"#'/ " "1# &%"-!"%' :1%$1 "1# 6*#<%-& !/5-/%$!"%' /#& '"

*# #* " ! 6#"%"%' * #5#$"?#'"+ "1#*# *#+ %;#/)=*# #*#'$#""1#6*6#*"= !& 1!<%'2 )##' 2*!'"#/ %' ;#!&# " "1# 1-&)!'/ %' "1# =#!* A !'/ "1# &"!"#

%$#* !/<#*"#/ " %"+ " /# %'# "1# $1!*!$"#* 6&&#&&%' * "1# :% # :1 $'"%'-#/!

"#*"1#;% #"%?# "1#1-&)!'/+ "1#6*%'$%6;#"1!":-;/)#$?#!66;%$!);# :-;/)#'# #&"66#;+"1!"%&+2<#*'#/ -'/#* #$"%'

"1# '/%!' <%/#'$# $" <#' 6&&#&&%' 1#;/ %'/#6#'/#'";= $-;/ )# !;"#*#/+ % ! 6!*"= #'"#*& %'" !' !2*##?#'" ;#!&# !'/ 1# :-;/)#)-'/)=&-$1!/?%&&%')="1# *#6*#&#'"!"%' "1!" 1# ?!9#& )= "1# !;"#*!"%' $1!*!$"#* "1!" 1# )"!%'& " 1%?&#;

6#*&' :1 #'"#*& -6' "1# 6*6#*"= :%"1-" 9':;#/2# :1 "1# :'#*:!&*!6#*&':1!&&#*"&1%&:' *%21"&$-;/:#;;&##9";#2%"%?%@#1%&:' 1;/%'2)=!""*'%'2!"#'!'$="!6#*&' :1? 1# :!& 6*#6!*#/ " *#$2'%@# !& ;!'/;*/ !'!;

#6!*"?#'"+ "1#*# *#+ :!& &##9%'2 #5#$"?#'" ?!9%'2 *# #*#'$# " "1# ;#!&# %' !<-*

6#"%"%'#*D& 1-&)!'/ !'/ "1# #E#$-"%' "1# &!%/ /$-?#'" %& 6*<#/+ "1#*# %& ' &$6#

* $1!;;#'2%'2 $;!%? " #5#$"?#'" )= *# #*#'$# " "1# /%&?%&&!; "1#6*#<%-&6*$##/%'2& ;"1-21 "1# 6#"%"%' 1!/ )##' /%&?%&&#/ */# !-;"#!*;%#*+1!<#!;;:#/ "1#)#'# %" !*2-?#'"& "1#$-'&#;!

"#* *#&"*%'2%" * *#1#!*%'2 1#6*$##/%'2& !;*#!/= "!9#' :%;; :*9 "1#?&#;<#& -" %' !$$*/!'$# :%"1 ;!: !'/ %" :%;; )# $?6#"#'" * "1# !-"1*%"= #<#' " !66;=

* /!?!2#& * -&# !'/ $$-6!"%' *

%;%'2?#*%";#&&*#<%&%'6#"%"%')# *#"1%& $-*" !'/ #'5=%'2 "1# )#'# %" 6*6#*"=

1#*#<%&%'6#"%"%'%&?#*%";#&&!'/ %&/%&?%&&#/F ' "1# !

*#&!%/ */#*+ "1# 6#"%"%'#*& 1!/ "!9#' "1# 6;#! *#&5-/%$!"! %' */#* " $1!;;#'2# "1# %'%"%!"%' "1# 6*$##/%'2& !" "1# %'&"!'$# "1#*#&" #6!*"?#'"'"1#2*-'/"1!""1#&%?%;!*6*$##/%'2& :#*#%'%"%!"#/)="1#!'!; #6!*"?#'"!2!%'&""1#6#"%"%'#*&:#*##!*;%#* /%&?%&&#/1%&-*":1%;#/%&?%&&%'2"1#*#<%&%'6#"%"%'?!/#!&6#$% %$ )&#*<!"%'"1!"G% "1#!'!; #6!*"?#'"+"1#*# *#+:!&&##9%'2#5#$"?#'" ?!9%'2*# #*#'$#""1#;#!&#%' !<-* "1#6#"%"%'#*D&1-&)!'/!'/"1#

H #E#$-"%' "1#&!%//$-?#'"%&6*<#/+"1#*#%&'&$6# *$1!;;#'2%'2 "1# $;!%? " #5#$"?#'" )= *# #*#'$# " "1# /%&?%&&!; "1# 6*#<%-& 6*$##/%'2&F7#!'%'2"1#*#)=+"1#6*$##/%'2&%'%"%!"#/!""1#%'&"!'$# "1#*#&" #6!*"?#'":#*#'"B-!&1#/!'/:#*#!;;:#/")#$'"%'-#/

"1"1#-*"&)#;:1!<# -'/"1!""1#6#"%"%'#*&!*#%'-'!-"1*%@#/ 6&&#&&%'<#*"1#;!'/:1%$1%&*#$*/#/%'"1#*#<#'-#*#$*/)#;'2%'2 ""1#B-!&%2<#*'?#'" 3#!*'#/ $-'&#; * "1# 6#"%"%'#*& 1!& ;!&";= !*2-#/ "1!" "1# 6#"%"%'#*&!*#%'6&&#&&%' *?"1#=#!*

!'/1!<#)#$?#:'#*&)= :!= !/<#*&#6&&#&&%'1%&6;#! "1#6#"%"%'#*&$!''")#!$$#6"#/!& "1#6#"%"%'#*&$!''"$;!%?!/<#*&#6&&#&&%'!2!%'&""1#6*6#*"= "1# "!"# "1#*6%'"1!&)##'*!%&#/ '<%#: "1#!

*#&!%/)&#*<!"%'&+/'" %'/!'=?#*%"%' "1#6*#&#'"6#"%"%'!'/"1#&!?#%&1#*#)=/%&?%&&#/ 1# %;#

A +:1%$1:!&!""!$1#/<%/#*/#* /!"#/ +%&1#*#)=*/#*#/")#*#;#!&#/ .,,7 0 .,,7 0 .,,7 0 .,,7 0

&"&"&"&" + + + + 1#"1#*&6#!9%'2I*#!&'#/ #&I 1#"1#**#6*"!);# #&I