Sudhir Kapoor Etc. v. Income Tax Officer & ANR
! " #$% $!&$$$ $' $!
!"#$%
(
!"#$%
!"#$%
( )
!"#$%
(
!"#$%
( (
!"#$%
!$*+ ,%- *!# . .#/$0"'$!1$ "# .
,%- *!# . ..$'
$$-$
& '( ) *& + ,()( & -. /()(
..234# "+.! ,, 1 * 1 .
4 ( 5( 5(6(% ( , .!! 7 ,* 8*((1 ' !23 4 ,
.! /66 2,, . * :
;) # 5<(*(2!! !"#( , ; ( =2 "=<9 4
+ 1+ 98>, ( 9 9 2,, .,1
6
;) # <( 1/
( !"#)(6 ;(=)=<(*1/*, , /
!'
)(*,1 (
,*+ " / . 1 * , 8?@ * 7 > )7 )(5 " **
66 1/> )7 2,,( ', ;(=>)2=< (, * ,! ! ! * #!
!> ."!2 ,A ;(=>"2A=<
( )
( 5)* 1/ . , 1 7 ! 1 1 ' !# 1 ,! /6696 6696 1 ! 1 ,/66 ) (7 ! ! * ! * (( 6B9 ! 66 66 (, ! /66 $ 1,, , !# / ! ( ! *.1/ !"#$( ;= "$=<9 ( ! " 9( 1+
( . (,1+ * , * , +.! ) #2
! "
# $%%$ & ' . 6)
1!#!! / .! . 7 !#1! ,/ " ! ./66 96:6669 (* .,/( . 1
* 1+ * ' !
. / 66 96: 665966 * !91 !, 1+ *, :
8*(! * 6
;) #
< ) ,,5
;) # <! "$ *,,*,, ! )!>)2* ,** ! ! !
*1 " ! *! 6
* *
. /1+ 1
,
1 ', 1/6
1 1 , " ,/ * , 1 * ( 1,(* / "$! , * ! ! 11+.! !, . * (( 6B9 " . , !
( ( :B91/7 6 66(* >"2A ;<;1<C# , ;<) .,/( ,/ *, ,! ! 9! , ;<)( !. . " (,
)* ,1
1/' . ,1+ 1 . . . . 5) !
. ,,/.* ,1, ,. #* 1 * .,/. !
*,1,1 #!
! .1+ :
,/,*>"2A , 1 ' /. , 1/ A ! (* 1,/. !*+ 8*( ,! (! /66 96: 665966( *!* .*!91(1 1 ! !(# , ,/(
, ( )(*,
* / 1+
*, * 1!
(*,1!(' . ,, * 1 7* * * ,/
66 ! !
*#!
!>"2A , * , +.! ) # 2 &
()
*
+ ,-(
.$%%/0 '
# &
"! #+.* ,/:(66B9 7 !1 ., ,( 5)(1+ * + .!
. ,, !. . 9 ,,,1+ 1/ , .*, ! ,,., " .
. +/ *! 1! / 66 96: 66:965( , !
.*! , * ! 1, " !
, ! * . 1+ *,1+ ", *,1/ ! , ,!*, 1 ,,/1,1/! . .
) .,/(
* ,(*,1 .*.* 1/.
*, /1,! # (
* ,1,1 * > 2 , (( 1+ 1 + * ! / * !,1) .$ . .,, * ** (* + ! . ! ! . >"2A *( .,/(!
66*1
5 * 1! 1
( , *1/ *.,,, ,, .* + & ,/( ;<)( 1,** , .*,, 2 , ( ( ! . . 1
7 ! ( ! . *
*,((1 / 6;<;1<(*
! "# $ % $ & ' ' (
) . , (** ,.,1+ !!
:
1 ( .! /66 66:965* 1+ + 6;<;1< !.1,*,1 ! #(*, "(7 !#* # ! *1' ! )!,/( !* ,/ (( 6B9*(
,/( ! 1 , " !.1,# ! *((, **.1.1 ,*1/ ( ,,/ . 1 , "1+ .
6 1 ,*,,/ . 1 , 1 .'(*,((,! ) #2,* * 1 2
32
4 2 .$%%0 $'/
# / & * 1 ,) .$1 1+ 1/ . ' . ,
) * & % +& & &
, -$ . ' % - .% / & / * .% / % '% , % .% / * % '%
% & ( "!*!1/
* ,(
,
(
, *, ) )!,/(
, *,* ,! ,,/ *,+1,! ! . ( *, 1.
/, &,/ . ! ! , ! . *! ,( !*.1, * ! *,1 ! . 6 ) ! , ! . ( . 1/ 4
, * / + 3,** !,1
4 . . ! !
1/ 9 * 1
, 1/ >)2 , 5
( * + ! . , 9
,!, * ,1 / ' , ,,* & ,/ 23 4 5(6(% ( , 1 1/*# *' . # * . 1/1 '( !. * .
) .,/(**!,1,1 ! ' , ! /( ,/( , ' "1/1 '. . ,! "+ / ./66 66:965( . 6;<;1<,1 ,,/,* , ,/( * ,,* !
. :
;) # 5<
6
;) # < 7, .*! !/66 ! ! ( ( ! 7.#/84 9 ..2349 $4:4 #;4 #;:
43