Icici Lombard General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Mohinder Singh And ORS
!
" #
$%%&'(' )**
!
"# ####
"# $%&'('
)* '*+) ,-) ")
####& "
...
) +,
- --
-
.%(% $)
# &# '
*/ 0 " -*")
# 12 3)/ 0 "/
"#
# ##'# 5)*
/ 0 "
"
1#
2 "
# #'# $*8/ 0 " "
1#9 # /// -
- 0 :)*
4*
"*
!
* *+ - " 6 # #
" *"
*
;"*
)"/ <") =
:
1# :
>#>#?
-*+
+
)*
@0* '*+) ,-) -)
*4 0)*
*"
"8
9#9#?#
"
1# 4*
2 "*
8*+ ) "
"*#
0"
4 "
-)* ) A * "*
9#9#?/ @0* '*+) ,-)/ !
+
"
+ "*/ +-*")
5 ) '*+) + 0*
+ '
"
")* "*0 0 '*+) )# ")* -!
8/ 5 ) '*+)
*0*+ " !
*+ +* ""* 1#;B 5>? -)
@0* '*+) ,-)/ -)
) 5 ) '*+)/
" !
1#;B 96# "
6 ##/ -) @0* '*+)
)*+ " 1#
"*
) (
;"* / ' * '($/ 44-)*" *+ +* ""* 1#;B :C9>
)*4" 4
<") 44*+ ' *= *+ *0 ) + *+"
4 ")* 8 * 4" 0"8*+ 5 ) '*+) -"
" -*") 4 *" " !
@0* '*+)# * "/ " !
@0* '*+)
" +*
" 1#
"*
)
-) +
- "!
44*+ ' * "
# @0* '*+)
"*
"* +*0
*
*2 *
* "
"# *0 44*+ ' * + -!
4
"# * 4"* & "
1#? " 9#9#?
+* "
"""
5 ) '*+)# "
*
" @0* '*+) 4* "*"* *08*+ 0* *
' "* DD
" $)*
"/ ??
)"/ <") "
??=
**+ #
4 *0/ -
44*+ ' *# :)*
*
4
"* *"
) + *+"
*0*+ 44*+ ' * " ,
'*+)#
@0* '*+)
* +
) *+ 4 ;
2 ;
' ) 1)
"
+ "
"* *"# @
<:%= <%:'=# @0*+ *"
+"
*
* 0
")
*
- **+"*
"
0*
" * 0"# @
) "* 8"
4 ,)
* :0
'0* ;"*
6#9#?# @
*"
*+"
!
")
")
")
"*"*
" " "
2*"
-*""
"""
4* "
1# *"
*# & "
1#6
-*""
"""
*
** *"!
"*+ *0 44*+ ' *
"
) *+ 0 * 44 "*0 *0*+
* "
"* *"
-
"
) *+ 0 * +* ""* "*4* " 4*"
"*4* " 0)* #
)*
*0*+ " !
) + *+"
* #
*0
""*
"*
-
""
# B") "*
0* * )+
) ")# **+ 0* 0*
*
*
) "*
"
-
"*"* - #//7
) *+ "
2*"
0
* !"
"*#
*+ ++*0 -
"*
!
4* ""
2 "
4*
2 "*
8*+ ) "
"#
*
*
# &# '
*/
"/
# ##'# 5)*
/
"
1# 6
2 "
# #'# $*8/
"
1#9 )
# * +
"*
!
*""
+
"# @
!# @
* "
* 0 !"
)
4 " #
"
4")# '"*
") *
#6/7 ") "*+ ) "
*0*+ E
"
!
"8
# /7 ") *## # /?/7 #
+ 0 *4
"
8 + "
-" + ")
*
"*
* *
-8 4*+ "!
F)
"*
)
"
++ !
-8/
*
"
#6/7 ")# & !*+
"
* +
"
+**+
+# +
4") ")
9 9
"*0 !# **+
"
E "
*
"* -*
0 -*+
#>
"
"
"
*+ *
"*+
' ' )
"
??
"8
# /7 # + "
"
- "0"
2 " @
*""
"
;
2 ;
' ) 1) -)* )
"
) @
"*
)
") "*
"
)
4"
* 8"
"# @ "
)
"*
") "*
) * )* # @
<%:'= E*"* +*+
*
" * 0"
!
- )*
!
0* -) "8 *
* * @ *" *"!
+"#
* *+)"
"
") 4"
* ")-*
/
4") +*
#/7 ") "
)
*
" " "*+ )
* "-
*0*+ E
"*
)
76
*
*
*"
"
""" # @
4*"/ ) ")!/ *"
*+"
-
"#
"* * G 9G *
**+ + 4")
* *"
"* *
)
* **+ + #
")*+
- "-
"
""
E / @0* '*+)
"
;
2 ;
' )
-) "
-*") *"
*4# : 0
*
*"
*+)"
" 0*
' "*4* " *+ -)* )
")
GBG +# %E#
"
"" %E#
" * 0"
0
"
0* )*# "
+
"8 *+)"
@+ 3+ ")
*
9#9#?
0"* "* 8"
%E# 6#
* 4 "
*4 *+ 4*
4")
"*
"
!
*
4
*+ * "
!#
"
") +) *0 0
"* )! ")"*
*"*
0")
)
2 "*0# 1 0* -")
0 )0*+ " *
" */
- -8 *"
")
"
*
*+ #6/7 ")# '"" )*+ *+*"*
+
"
*"#
>
#
$ % + 0* "*
@
"
B ) %+**+
)* # @
44 +*0
*2 *
* *"#
"* *2 *
>H "
* "# **+ 4 "
* *""I ) )* ) 40I
- )!
*
*"* -)* ) A *
"*
") +)
*4I *0 *!
4*"
-)* )
A */ E "
" 4
-*+ ")
"*+ A " "*
!
" #
!
$
$#% &'
''' #!
!
" !
#(
" !
!
!
)
!
$#*'
''' #+
"
#
!
#
$#*'
'''
)
?
#,
-'.
%'.
$#/0 ''' #
0&
#) 1 , 2 0# 5:
34#
$#/0 '''
34 $#- &* '''#
"
$#- &* '''#
$#3 &'
'''
5 #
$#6 '* '''#7 ""
/
+
"# %0 *4
"* -*")
+ ")
* "
+"
+ 2
"
* ")4"# *"" !/ -8 *"
-8*+ # :)4/
*+
"
* -8*+ *# 1 "/ ' ' )
"
??
0*
*+ "*
*
"8
# /7 E "*
")
0*"* 4
" 4
0* ' ' )
# !*+
! "* 8
)!
8 9
-*
4*
*+
"
#D/7 #
*+ E"
"* "-
*0*+ E
& '
( ) *
* +
+
#
&'.
5
#!
#:
!
#
#
!
&'.
5 &'.
#(
;
5
;
;
#7
)/ 4")
+ 9
4") +*
-)* )
4")
+*
*
)0*+
* "
* # 1#6 , "
3 / *
" /
"
"
"
) 4")#
)/ 0 *4
0*0 "
* *+/ ")
*
"
H
*
" "-
*0*+ E
# *+ !/ "
#6/7 #
* * % ,
'*
&
- .%! & + "*0
"* *
G ?G# ;
-
)-
"
)
-
"-
*"* "
+
"*"
* * H# *+ !/ !
"
*
#D/7 # "
+
6# *
#6/7 9# 5 !
7 #/ J #9/7 #
"* * ?
D# :"
#?/ /7 *"* "
#?/ /7
" "-
!/ "
#7 -
)
""
E
) #/7# ") "
-
1# "-
0 44 "*# 0 * /
"*"
#/6/7
** " 0#
*+ !/ - " 6 # #
*4*#
4*
"*
!
"
-
2 "*
4*
)* '*+) ")
* *
# -
-
**