High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22684/2018disposed of

Madam 'X' v. Chancellor Panjab University & ORS

2019-10-15Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill28 pages

! "!#$% !& '( ( )(

*%*+ , (( $-.-. !$ /0( 1*!#$22 3 *!4*5 !./$0.-6 *!% -1$0 (( $07 !%$!-0 &

8 9 ( :

"# $%&'()!

#*#+

,#+ $-

$. ''

$ " $/ 00000 3 ( ! #" #+*(1 (2 " -%3%-3%4 -53%-3%46

"%33%-3%7%43--3%76 -33.-3%7 %534-3%7*"8#'-3'-%'-/'-&'-4'.% 9*

8# : ;;

2-3%.1 <<2 - =# # #

>*#"" $%

(#> =#

. 9

* #",

(# ##=# !9 3. "

8 * 1 * 2 (9 "

" 1 $.2 8#

?#" ##

" $. # +# # " # "# # # +#

* ! " " " "# -% # ! * # " *" <@< $. <A< / 9"# 8#

# *:<* # # !* #*

" " *+#" B;.01*<*=

9 8 # 8# # C# " < D=# << "E E*<9 "# %/%&-%

# ! "# < "E *E "< :<* 8 # "# # %/-

# !*" +# " " 8#

"# !

+#" 8# " # $ %$ % &% '%( ) * &

% & % '%( %

(

( +

% %(

% ( ( +

&$,

% - #) . % % +

(

($&$ %( ) %$ ((( ( / & - + / ( + $0( /

',%,%$/ $ '( %$ ( &0 &(

( + 1$ ( (

((

( ' (

((

( & %% ( !

%$ '' ', $

$ ', % &(% %

((

( ( &

, $ ( $ %& *

( $ ( ' ' &,

&&('

,((' %$

,( ,' %$ ' (

,( ,% '( ' 2 ( - ( , & ( ( (

( - $&( 0000000 3 # (%$() 1

( (

( %$ &$ (

%%% (%$(

# 1D #

2F G ; B

FB 4"#

" =# #*:<* # ## "# # #*#

#"#

#" 9# B 8# : ; ;

1 * 2

35%--3%. 4 9 B

F / C / #* B(

!0-.-"-. !

!-$!*2 +72*.!-0 ++.--$$( 1%2D

*"# * B!

' #

#*' !

1-2 9 !

"***

12 " )

* ")

#*'1%2 #

"6 1*2 * "

* # 8 "

"6 12 * " '"

# " 8# '

*F 7 9 #*

%&3/-3%& 18#'%2%73/-3%&18#'-2 $%

""* 8# * $ . =# >#" !

" ?## *

=# * ?!

" !C

" > * * *

#-%3%-3%418#'-32 *

(# "

5 &0

&$6

$1&( & (

'( & (( ( ' + 7

1 1%(6 6&

2( 89 &( ) : : 2

$ % . ($ 7$ 6

6 % .'

9 6(%# 2;

## %

, 3 <

( 7& =.'

. <

( &>7$ 7,

( < & , . 2(, <

( 6 &>7$7, ?

,:.'

@ A B52

4 12

# -53%-3%4 18# '-%2

" # B

5 ( (

$ ( 2%% +

( ' ( ( (%($ %$( ( 5 & , & & ( 5', & '

@ && & ( C

%(( &' (

& %+ 7

1 1%( 6&

2( 89) 2 ?$ : !D!

9 6

; : A ? 3 7%,#

$14 12

# %33%-3%7 18# '-/2 " # "

50 &(

(

&$$ (88 %((( %

&, (0 ( 6&B $&( &$

& , %

: :+ 2

$ . ($ 7$ &$$', ' *2 ( 7$? ) : A 2

($ #% % ,(

? 7$ ,/

: <$2 6(%($ 7,

( ? 7$ , .

','

' & &(

) ' 6

B $ $ 6

: : # B $* ( 6&B $/

% 6& B $

2, + 7

6B 27 $ 6

: ; #% 0(

1 !

> #% & (

&$ $ ( < $ 8 $

+(% <

( < & , '

&$ 5 (

%% &

( %% ' $

(

%%%&$7!& ( 9 (%$& ( & ' : $ 7

(#% 2 ?$ 6

; : (

'( ( '% + 7

1 1%(6 6&

2( 895$ ( ,88 (

%(( ( %

( 4 12

#-%3%-3%7>%43--3%718#'-&2

* # "

$ ( 8< $ 8@&%%

& A

1 + , % *

, + 7

$B $&

% $(

& 7!&

(,'&0 %%5 7!& ( $ (

)

$& %%% & $ 2 ?$ 6

; : 7%,# 6

$1 6

<;? ' $ # 6?$ A ? '% 7!& ( ( %

4 12 E -33.-3%7 18# '-42 # * (

,'H "+*( " :H* , !>

+* (

! !

"* " ,'

" *1> 2 =#" ! !

# =#

# *#*

:# #I "* ( $ AFF#F#?

:( 8@

&(( & $ 7G& (06 * F ( 6&B $ %% ( % * % *

- $, &$: !D!, (0 ( 6& B $ ( , ', & )

: A *2 2

($ #% % ,( ? 7$

6 % .'

9 6(%# 2;

## % ,

6( , 3 <

( 7& = .' . <

( &>7$7,

,: .'

A; 6 #( 6 &( B5 A B52

@ 6

: : # B $

( 6&B $ 6

: ; #% 0(

1 !

>#% % 6& B $

2, + 7

8 : 6 % #% $ , E

6&B $4 12 E %534-3%7 18# '.%2 # * (

,'H " # ! ! ** :H* ,' !>

+*(* >

5 ) " "# # *

" "#B

F=# $.1,

2 "

* # #

#* *

(:<* , #: * #"#

"* "

# * #*

9 " # : #"#*

< # * '

%3 E #

" # "# > -33.-3%7

# *

# !

< *

*:"#B

# *

* '# : # * '#*

%% ! * # # $% & ## #"# #

" :#** '#

(! :<* ,'

!# #

(# *"

+ * %- !*"#"#<

# %. ) #

" /

!" #

" ,

(

# *

=#,

!8#

# # %/ E # "# :<* , !>

# '# " ( > #

>> >

(: #* %& E ##*

" *

" "

# (D8# (: #

# #! !

*# #* $%:<*

> ,' !>

+*( "1*"

"# ,'

" +## # " ! !

" #* #"*

9 ? #

:# #I I

9" %G ! " #"

* %4

" $% :H* ,' !>

(

$.1,'

2 $% # ##>

" $ . %7 9

># ! * $% -33.-3%718#'-42 "=#

> =#

"E>%534-3%718#'.%2#* $% #

H *+ " # !

* * $ % * > " #

(D8# ( C#

8# : ; ;

1* 2-3%. %5 ! * $% -33.-3%7 18# '-42 #" %534-3%7 18# '.%2 # " H *+'

"> -33.-3%718#'

-42 # !

' #

# -%3%-3%4 18# '-32

#-53%-3%418#'-%2 !

8 +## " -3 C# #"

""# * * > # * $%-33.-3%7%534-3%718#'-4' .%2 12 9 *

# $%*

" " =# H "%43--3%7 " *#* * $%

""* "

' 9

" * $% # " # * #

##* $ . 1*2 9# #* $

** #"# ** 129

* !

* "#9

* > #+# 12! #"%534-3%7

> B

$.# 8

12;

* +#*=#

* #**+ # %G34-3%&18#'./2#*I

J9"=# " *

" *" * 9 #"> #

1"2 9 "

-% ! "* *> *

*">" # # "

# # !

""#

*>*

$ % *" , !

# > + *8'

(#9""*# # * #"

# "8 '# 9

D8# (

# * ( C "

$% *# # *> "# # -. ! # !

$% #

( *"

> #%33%-3%7 18#'-/2-%3%-3%7>%43--3%718#'-&2 **> *

>" # # #" > " # #

@ !

! # $ % #

>*(H -/ D # # '8"

*> ***"" # #" 9#

#" " #

$% *# #" ( # "

*! > " "

" #* > * (*"* $% # !

-& ? > > # #"> -33.-3%718#'-42 - # "* ( $ AFF#F#?

:( 8@

&(( & $

7G& (06 * F ( 6&B $ %% ( % * % *

- $, &$: !D!, (0 ( 6& B $ ( , ', & DDDD4 -G 9 "#" *"# # !

=##*# $%

9 "#" #" > -33.-3%7 ##

>!# *" "#" " ##

* $%C# # *" *# * K

H * # K

H! $%#

# !

#" > -33.-3%78 #/1%2 #

-4 9 !

* $% *# "

#"-33.-3%7#*"

*" <

%&3/-3%&#*"* * $. $%#" ,'

1 $.

* #+* ( " 8# : 1( :2 (*# 8"##( : 3G3&-3%& =#

* %%3&-3%&9 *+

*"# *( :" #*

* ( : !

# * # *

) $%( :#* $% -7 ! " " ( : -/37-3%& " (

" '

" 5 ' :7# ,- $ '&(( , % + 7

1 1%(6 6&

2( 89 $(( ,#H65, 6($6&B $ 5(

,, (( 6($ % , ,6(1 + 7

1%( % &$6& B $ 5(

& '( & (

( ' - $ ' (

( &$6B 27(,( % (0 (!

( ( %

, ( - $( %&- &$ " % ( % $4

, - $ - ( %($

((

' ( % & " % ( % $4'( ( % .

( ' + 7

1 1%( 6 6&

2( 89 "2$ ,,

' $ ', ( % +

'%(*

( 4 -5 ! (

:# #I 1 :

I2 %735-3%&( :

I * '

B2& ,%($ '

(( I <

, J+ 7

1 1%(6 6&

2( 89J#65, < $ 83K'

',)0 5!E %$I % <

, + 7

1 1%( 6 6&

2( 89K

!# (%$ 2 $! I %

3K & % 5 &$#65, 5# (%$2 $( (

( & 5 %

% #65, , ,

!* %

! % <

, + 7

62( 5 &$#65 , 5%( , (

,( % 6B 2 &'(( ( !E %$!F# (%$2 $!5 ( *'& $ -

% ( ( %

' ( 6&B $ L (

(

$(( 6($, % 2( , F (

&$ ?* F#H6>5 4

.3 9 # *( $% *"# -33%-3%G $% * B5 6B 6B 2(

$ $ ( $ (

(

, 6B 27 (( ( ' % %%(& - , +

, (

( (

(- $%

(

( &$ *'& ?,& 6B - $ ( (( ,$ , - ( , 5

'%%($ 7!&(6 * F ( 6B4 .% )" "( :: " -73/-3%G18#'%&2( : #( "",'

#"# ! #

# * $%

# .- ! %-%--3%G

( : # * *

## " # .. !*"# :

I 353%-3%4 "

1 $%2

1 $.2 #*=#

%53G-3%4

I* B5 : $ ( 6& B $ %

($ ( % ( ( ' %%

( 6& B $ 7!& ( 6 * 5, 6&B $ ' (

%% &$%% ( * , H#(06 * '%%7!&(06 * - :7#

(

$ ( %

( A

1 + ,

+ 7

1 1%(6 6&

2( 89 %- $

& %%%% ? 6&B $ 5: $ ,- 7!&( 6 * &, ( 6& B $ %$ (0

( ( ( , *

- , &$ : !D! , ( ( 6& B $ 5: $ %

, ( %*

$ ( ' ( (06 * 4 ./ !#8" > "

1 $%2

">#" !

) > #" $%

-33.-3%7(

! =#

" * " $.

#* * .& #""""# * $%*#"# # *

# > :" * #

## **#

" *+> 3434-3%718#'-72:<* ,' ! B*( ((

( (

&$ %$ ! " " "# $

% '(( $ %( & ' ', %% %(

: : & ( %$& ( ( (

& ,%%

$&$ 7!&

( ! "

% &"&% % '(&)&)*+,-&)&)*+.&'&)*+).&,&)/+ )/&,&)/+'0&,&)/+)(&0&)/+,&.&)/+(&.&)/% & &%

&1 .G C

#" > %534-3%7 $%>

"* # 8

#''* '

BM (

$ (F 7!& (06 * F ( 6& B $ %% ( * % *

: A &6 ,H(

8 :( 8@5 & ($ , 6B A 60 3FF8 0*** 8898@2+ 0** & - $ (

( 88 8@ 2+ 0*** 8838@ 2+ 0*

9838@ 2+ 0 & (

, ' , 8 8@, &$ # # (

* % *

88 8@

:$ 8@ ( : A % * % *

%($ 7!& (06 * F ( 6&B $ 3838@

(

2'%(##

6A < ' ' 6

B $ %(6: : &(

( , 6B 3838@2+ 0* 2, , (

(

88 8@ 2+ 0** '

8 8@, &$6# A < ' ' - ($(

&, &* % *

( % $ 2 %

7!& (0 6 * F ( 6&B $ #:

M #% ?,%$+ ' 6

' 6&B $ %(6A < ' 8 8@5 ' (

( , 6B < 8@2+ 0*** * &$ 0( * % *

& &$ 7!& (06 * F ( 6& B $ & (

$ (F'( ,

% ( ((

%%$ B $ ( E+( ? B $.

( %( % + 7

1 1%(6 6&

2( 89 7( $ - %(&

$ ,( +

%' $ $4 .4 :" * #

* ! #*

*#*

$%>

$% #

#" > "#>

"* 9# #"> 9 "

* .7 C*# " ! + H # * > $ % #" !

#+#9 #

I ## *#*=# -33.-3%7 18# '-42 * $% #"!

<*+=## !

! %534-3%718#'.%2#* $%

" +* ( %/3.-3%7 1 8#!2 # "

%33%-3%78 ,!! # "

%43--3%7 9 #

> >* $- $% #" >* #9# #

$%*

" " H " %43--3%7 " *# ** D#"# ""# " # *+

" #* > =# " /3 ! # >

* 9

@ /% C ! "

* #

#*# $%

$.9"

>* "

$%*

* > #" #+#C# >

$.# * #

#*# $% /- 9*+* "#

* !

# * $% #" >%534-3%718#'.%2 *

* $%* *

* # #" * # +# '#

" "9" # #

" # # *9# ##

# ! % ( #"* "# * * # * " #

**!

/. ; # " # !

* 8# : ; ;

1* 2 *

*+ " "* !

* #*" $

** * "*=#

*# * * """ // ; *

'( ( )

; "> A>$ ; * A>$