High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2628/2012allowed

Parhlad Singh v. Robin Gupta And ORS.

2023-03-23Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan6 pages

!

"# $ %"

&&##

'( ) *(&

" & !

"+ ,

&&##

- .

" ,

"& / !

!

"# $ %", % )( 2 3 , $"& 4"

, 5( / 16, $ 2 6, 4"

""

)(%"

-&

($ '" # , 7 "

"

% ) *(&

8 ,'9*(&

8+ /+: ( 4-& 3 ;

,4"

"8 ( ) %%

/45;

"

)

4# -< )( #,4"

"

, - %-&

&

, " %

%"

1 =, "+ & ## %- 3# )3 4

)#* % !

% % -$ 2 ,4"

!# $

$ 2,4"

"> "- 3#+ ) % #

" >

)( -,+" "3"

" - ##"+. $ ,4"

"

#- "+., "

- " 9 6"

(. % "- 3#,(#

#3) " " ##+

" #%+ " "- 3#> ( ?(

"+ - "&

# %

. &# ( %# % %

)3&

/ ) *(&

<"# & 3 % -&

# ." #%+ " 2 %

% ,

#&

+

- : " +

- # )3 & / , "

.&# ( %# %

% "- 3#)3* % !

,+"+ ( " #( # @( + & ## %

- 3# : "+

- #)"

& /, " "

#

. # &# - 3 )? %

/ ( -& 3 # & 3-&

& / ( -& 3 "+

-

# )3 "

. ( #% # )? %

#

&

"

) # )3 " # ##( + " "

& #

% #

" - - , ("

3

.&# ## & 3 - # &

:( - + - & +

@(

&& ( # (&& " & -

" % %(- , " < )( # ##+ " # &

& #3

-&

7,1 #%+ " AB& (-

# %

##

,& )#)3 " ? #3 ##3 = # %

"-&

" -+ #+ , "& #. %"

-

-&

, +" "+ % & 5+,#3 /8 ( -& 3 "(%"(# :"

" # (# "& ) % %

"(%" " 7 # &&

" &( ) ( # %

+" "!

"# $ %" "

(

?( "

. &# ( %# % %

)3& / :

3

.

+ "-

%+ "

2 < )( #

%

)# "

"

( ( %# % %

% )3 / ) *(&

") *(&

)-# & -&

&&## 1# <"+

(#3 # )# & 3 -&

/+ : ( 4-& 3;

,4"

#%

+ "# ) # 3 "

"" # @( + % (#3 ()3& /8 +

+ "(":( 4-& 3<" , ) # 3 & 3 "-&

+ %"

#3"# )? #)3 # 5+, :

" -&

)3 < )( # -+"

"#+ -

#3, % 4"

"&# %

% 3& "

%(

?( (# % &- ) # 3," ( ) -&#3- <" , & &( 3#"

) ( " -+ "% " -&#3- 6( " "4(

" - +(# )

. 3( -&#3- " ( "-&#3- "

##)#3 4 %

"+ %

% 3 ( ,1

-

,+" " )( + "& % ->

-

"# &

3 )

. ),1, ( ## ,1&&#3 %-(# &# 7,+" " %%(& 3 , "#-(

,D7 2,1

( - # D& # "(%" " &

) %

*- -&#3 (&& )

% " - D& -)()( -

--.+#%

##

" D& ( % ##3 -)( ( (

" # " ?(+(#)@( (D&

( ( #

" - - :"

"

!

E "" & (

%,

,1

:-3 + %

"(-) ?( (

)3 ,& "&

,

3

(# @(

3 "& (

%(%)3

& (

% ?(3 @( % #% "&

, (%

##+(&

- 9& % +

(-

, "

!

(

" 2 ( " ,1(

"" & # &(

% ?( & # #3 &&3<"(, ( " " "

!

( ", ,1

"

%:-3 +, -+"

#+ <" "("

!

# "

(- ,1 3 "

%,+" " 3- %9& % + & "&

( ?(

+(# % ""&

# ##+(&

- #,

"

!

(

" = # "

(- ,1 &- ) # 3<"# ( ?( (

)3" - +(# ) + #.,( "+ & (- "

" - ( # - # D&

# E "" F % # D&

# F

( ?( (# % " % - # #% 3, , "

" &, - , && - , (

-

# # , !

- " - 7 <"(,

#-&

-( , 7,1 -&

7,1 : " + 3, ""

-( ,7,1

, 7, 87, <"# +(#)

% A =B& (- "

# % -&

(

<" " - % # ( " -&(% "

&&#3 ""

+## "("-

, # ##+& #3+ $ " - #

& #3 ##+, - ## ( &&#

3,

& %#3 #$ 6 ?

%&'(&'))'*+,'-.'*/0,1 '+ %&'(&'))'.+)(*23'

'+